Home | Songs By Year | Songs from 2011
Love On Top
Buy Love On Top now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the song. And once you've experienced the song, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
{{Infobox song
| name = Love On Top
| cover = Beyonce - Love on Top (single).png
| alt =
| border = yes
| type = single
| artist = Beyonc
| album = 4
| released = September 12, 2011
| recorded = 2011
| studio = MSR Studios (New York City);
Real World Studios (Box, Wiltshire)
| venue =
| genre = R&B
| length = 4:27
| label = Columbia
| writer =
| producer =
| prev_title = Party
| prev_year = 2011
| next_title = Countdown
| next_year = 2011
| misc =
}}
"'Love On Top'" is a song recorded by American singer Beyonc for her fourth studio album '4' (2011). Inspired by her state of mind while playing Etta James in the 2008 musical biopic 'Cadillac Records', Beyonc wrote the song alongside Terius Nash and Shea Taylor; its production was handled by Taylor and Beyonc. A throw-back to 1980s music, the uptempo R&B song exhibits style similar to that of Stevie Wonder, Huey Lewis, Whitney Houston and The Jackson 5, among others. While incorporating four key changes, Beyonc adopts a high range when repeating the song's chorus towards the end of the song. She sings about a person whom she can always call, even after facing grief and hard work, finally earning their love and respect. The song changes key several times and ends in the key of E Major.
The song's musical composition, as well as Beyonc's vocals and versatility, positively surprised critics. Beyonc sang "Love On Top" live at 2011 MTV Video Music Awards, announcing her pregnancy at the end of her performance. This caused the upsurge of the song on several charts worldwide. It reached the top ten in Hungary, and the top twenty in Australia, Italy, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. It also debuted and peaked at number 20 on the US 'Billboard' Hot 100 chart, thus becoming the second highest debut of Beyonc's career as a solo artist. "Love On Top" remained at number one on the US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart for seven consecutive weeks, and has sold over one million copies. Beyonc won a Grammy Award for Best Traditional R&B Performance for "Love On Top" at the 55th ceremony.
Mainly inspired by the work of the American band New Edition, the accompanying music video for "Love On Top" shows Beyonc along with five male dancers, performing choreographed moves in a penthouse studio in New York City overlooking the Hudson River towards New Jersey. Critics generally commended the simplicity of the video, the wardrobe changes with every key change, and Beyonc's youthful exuberance throughout the clip. The song was part of the singer's set lists on the residency shows 4 Intimate Nights with Beyonc (2011) and Revel Presents: Beyonc Live (2012), as well as The Mrs. Carter Show World Tour (201314) and The Formation World Tour (2016).
Background and development
('pictured') motivated Beyonc for the development of "Love On Top".
"Love On Top" was written by Beyonc, Terius Nash and Shea Taylor while production was handled by Beyonc and Taylor. From June 16 to June 27, 2011, the songs from '4' were available to listen to in full each day on Beyonc's official website, paired with its accompanying photo spread from the album packaging and a quote. On June 26, 2011, "Love On Top" was the eighth song to be chosen. The quote found Beyonc elaborating on the song's inspiration:
"When I played Etta James [in the 2008 musical biopic, 'Cadillac Records'] it was the most I'd learned about myself until the recording of this album. When I went into the studio I used the same passion, honesty, and approach with my vocals I channeled as Etta James. It does not sound like the vocals on my past albums. It's a lot rawer. It comes from a deep place."
Beyonc, who has covered "At Last" which is a song originally recorded by James, portrayed the artist in the 2008 musical biopic, 'Cadillac Records' and won critical acclaim for her portrayal. She told 'Billboard' magazine: "I realized that Etta James was so unapologetic, bold and strong that playing her was a big risk for me. It gave me the confidence and the push to challenge myself a little more with my music." "Love On Top" impacted Urban radio in the United States on January 10, 2012, as the fourth single from the album in that country.
Composition
"Love On Top" is an up-tempo R&B and disco song viewed as a modern take on old school music. It also exhibits elements of retro-soul music, retro-pop, 1980s pop music, funk music, jazz, and 1970s classic disco music, as stated by Joanne Dorken of MTV UK, Cameron Adams of the 'Herald Sun' and Thomas Conner of 'Chicago Sun-Times'. According to 'Slant Magazine' Eric Henderson, "Love On Top" is a "bright, breezy tribute to the freshness of mid-[19]80s, pre-new-jack-FM R&B reminiscent of Whitney Houston and Anita Baker." He also said the song was the "perfect and totally inverted fraternal twin" of another song on '4', being "Rather Die Young". "Love On Top"s retro elements are further illustrated by its use of finger snaps, a "distorted" bass groove, and a melding of horns as well as sweet backing harmonies, especially in the bridge and the chorus of the song. It is instrumentally complete with a thumping bassline, synthesizers, tribal drums, an electric piano, a guitar, a peppy saxophone, and some backing vocals. Rich Juzwiak of 'The Village Voice' compared "Love On Top" to Raydio's "You Can't Change That" (1979) and New Edition's "Mr. Telephone Man" (1984). Priya Elan of 'NME' noted that "Love On Top" echoes Janet Jackson's "Whoops Now" (1995), Lionel Richie's "Dancing on the Ceiling" (1986) and the theme from 'My Two Dads'.
According to the digital sheet music published at Musicnotes.com by EMI Music Publishing, "Love On Top" is mainly written in the key of C major with a tempo of 99.2 beats per minute. Beyonc's vocal range in the song spans from the low note of G3 to the high note of B5. "Love On Top" is set as "both a sweet love song and an expression of girl power" as stated by Georgette Cline of AOL Music. Genevieve Koski of 'The A.V. Club' and David Amidon of PopMatters noted that "Love On Top" features "mature lyrics" alongside Beyonc "sounding vocally giddy and aggressive while portraying the message." Lyrically, the song finds Beyonc as the female protagonist expressing the happiness she feels to have her love interest in her life. "The languid, synth-soul smoocher" allows for an "enjoyably euphoric tone" before she chimes in with "Bring the beat in!", introducing "a mid-album interlude of mid-[19]80s pop", as stated by Andy Gill of 'The Independent' as well as Hamish MacBain of 'NME'.
Rich Juzwiak noted that Beyonc "ecstatically and hyperactively" changes keys four times during the song. As stated by Scott Shetler of PopCrush, she constantly sings praises of her love interest in the first verse where she also seemingly sends him subtle digs as he did not give her his full attention in the past, this being illustrated in lyrics such as, "after fighting through my fears [...] finally you've put me first." The chorus, complemented with sweet backing harmonies, then arrives, with Beyonc chanting, "Baby it's you, you're the one I love / You're the one I need / You're the only one I see / Come on baby it's you / You're the one that gives your all / You're the one I can always call / When I need you make everything stop / Finally you put my love on top." The chorus carries the final two minutes of the song through four key changes, proceeding to D major, then to D major, E major and finally to E major. This was highlighted by Henderson who wrote that "the spirit carries both her and the song into a Stevie Wonder-reminiscent climax of continually rising key changes." In this way, the word "baby" is said about 24 times throughout the song. As soon as the synthesizers drop out, the song fades out almost instantaneously.
Critical reception
"Love On Top" was highly acclaimed by critics. Rich Juzwiak of 'The Village Voice' complimented its "easy listening/easier dancing boogie vibe". Genevieve Koski of 'The A.V. Club' said "Love On Top" had an up-tempo nature, saying that it was possibly the only "first-listen earworm" on the album with its "breezy, retro-soul style." Matthew Horton of BBC joked about the climax of the song, stating that the album '4' "was named after the four key changes in the final, teetering chorus of 'Love on Top' to ram the point home." Greg Kot of the 'Chicago Tribune' commended the song for putting a "bounce" in Beyonc's step. Similarly, Matthew Perpetua of 'Rolling Stone' named "Love On Top" "a blast" as Beyonc creates a modern take on old-school Whitney Houston. Hamish MacBain of 'NME' favored the song's up-tempo style, stating that it was much needed after the "ballad-heavy" first half of the album. Priya Elan of the same publication commented that it has "100 watt smile lyrics". Stating that "Love On Top" is reminiscent of 1980s R&B, Erika Ramirez of 'Billboard' magazine complimented the song as a "Halcyon love song, perfect to be whisked away to". Spence D. of IGN commented that Beyonc's "cheery disposition" and the "brash horns" will remind listeners of "damn good" mid-1980s R&B can be. While including the song as a "must hear" from the album, Andy Gill of 'The Independent' named "Love On Top" as "a small footnote to Stevie Wonder's innovatory genius." Alexis Petridis of 'The Guardian' praised Beyonc's vocals and called "Love On Top" a "well-written" song.
Eric Henderson of 'Slant Magazine' also gave "Love On Top" a positive review, favoring its "infectious upbeat spirit" and comparing it to the styling of Stevie Wonder, Anita Baker and Whitney Houston. He also complimented the fact that the various key changes throughout the song "force Beyonc out of her scold range and into some winningly girlish soprano whoops." Similarly, Joey Guerra of the 'Houston Chronicle' commented that "Love On Top" is a "bouncy jam" which finds Beyonc in "feel-good diva mode". He added that it might have turned up on early albums from Natalie Cole, Whitney Houston or Mariah Carey. Guerra concluded that Beyonc "rarely has sounded so charming, even as she soars through several key changes." Mikael Wood of 'Spin' magazine noted that the song "imagines a perfect genetic splice" of Whitney Houston's eponymous debut album and Michael Jackson's 'Off the Wall'. Ricky Schweitzer of One Thirty BPM stated that "Love On Top" is instantaneously reminiscent of Michael Jackson, Janet Jackson and Stevie Wonder, and favored Beyonc's numerous key changes, writing:
'Love On Top' employs a similar pacing [to 'Party'], though tonally, this track reminds one more immediately of Michael and Janet Jackson, as well as Stevie Wonder. This effervescent throwback escapes corniness by reveling in its pure joy and as such, it becomes one of the highlights of the album. The numerous key changes that flood the end of the song could seem masturbatory, but Beyonc is not proving that she can sing as high as Mariah [Carey] or Whitney [Houston] because we already trust her to. It is energy and not ego that drives the constantly rising progression.
Becky Bain of the website Idolator viewed "Love On Top" as a "joyful tune that doubles as a throwback to a simpler time" and added that Beyonc's energy is "infectious". Conrad Tao of Sputnikmusic very much liked "Love On Top", writing: "[...] as she forces herself into a rarely used high range, she sets for a perfect catharsis for the burgeoning sexual passions of the album's first two thirds", and describing the outcome as "absolutely magnificent". Melinda Newman of HitFix commented "the soulful, exuberant, mid-tempo finger snapper, 'Love on Top' is deliciously sunny and sweet." James Reed of 'The Boston Globe' wrote that "Love On Top" sounds "like the pretty young thing of Michael Jackson's 'P.Y.T.' grew up to make a sequel to that 1983 hit." Similarly, Joanne Dorken of MTV UK who described "Love On Top" as "scream[ing] 'classic disco', catchy, [being] more uptempo and differing from the rest of the album", concluded that the song shows Beyonc's versatility and that it is "very Jackson 5". Ben Cardew of 'Music Week' stated that "Love On Top" is summery and "laidback, rather than massively immediate". However, he added that it proves to be a grower as it "ratchets up the key changes on the final third", further writing that Beyonc's voice sounds "particularly impressive". A mixed review came from Adam Markovitz of 'Entertainment Weekly', who compared Beyonc's work on "Love On Top" to that of past idols such as Luther Vandross and Diana Ross, but felt the tone overshadowed her style, stating "she gets lost in her idols' polyester-swathed shadows." Jon Caramanica of 'The New York Times' noted that the song was "slinky but nowhere near sexy" adding that it sounds like a song young Brandy Norwood would release.
Recognition and accolades
James Montgomery of MTV News placed "Love On Top" at number nine on his list of the 25 Best Songs Of 2011. He called it "a throwback jam" to Beyonc's older R&B material, stating that "[it's] big, bold, brassy and blissed-out, [and] it represents everything B was going for on her '4' album". Montgomery also noted that the song was an "absolute lifesaver" and "as is the case with all of her best tunes, Beyonc belts here". 'Slant Magazine's staff members listed "Love On Top" as the 24th best song of the year, with Eric Henderson commenting that "somewhere between ['4's] copious ballads and its few, hyperventilating dance tracks, Beyonc strikes a perfect balance with this breezy midtempo tribute to the 1980s." On 'The Village Voice's Pazz & Jop critic year-end list in 2011, "Love On Top" was ranked at number 51. Additionally, Nick Murray of the same publication included the song on his list of 53 Great Songs From 2011."Love On Top" was named the greatest song of the decade (2010s) by 'Harper's Bazaar', and the best song by a female artist of the decade by 'Uproxx'. In 2017, ShortList's Dave Fawbert listed "Love On Top" as containing "one of the greatest key changes in music history".
The song was nominated in the category for Viewer's Choice at the 2012 BET Awards and in the category for R&B/Hip-Hop Song at the 2012 Teen Choice Awards. Beyonc won her 17th Grammy Award with Best Traditional R&B Performance for "Love On Top" at the 55th Annual Grammy Awards. At the 26th ASCAP Rhythm & Soul Music Awards in 2013, "Love On Top" received the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Song award.
Chart performance
For the week July 2, 2011, "Love On Top" debuted on the South Korea Gaon International Singles Chart at number 3, selling 89,942 digital downloads. The song remained at that position in its second and third week, selling 52,462 downloads and 42,261 downloads respectively. It charted inside the top ten positions of the chart for five consecutive weeks.
After Beyonc's performance of "Love On Top" at the 2011 MTV Video Music Awards, the song was propelled into the top five positions of the US iTunes Store; its sales picked up by 221 percent. Despite not being a single at that time, it became the highest-charting song from '4' on the US iTunes Store. For the week ending September 10, 2011, "Love On Top" consequently debuted at number 135 on the US Hot Digital Songs chart, and charted at number 22 on the US Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles chart. Note: Billboard.biz subscription is required to access the source. The following week, the song soared number 10 on the Hot Digital Songs chart, selling 113,000 downloads; digital sales went up by 803%. This prompted the entry of "Love On Top" at number 20 on the Hot 100 chart. The Hot 100 debut of "Love On Top" became Beyonc's second highest among her 29 solo career entries; only "Ring the Alarm" began at a higher position, at number 12 in 2006. It fell to number 70 on the Hot 100 chart issue dated September 24, 2011. "Love On Top" was certified 4 platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) on August 8, 2022. "Love On Top" passed one million digital copies in the U.S. in February 2013.
For the week September 17, 2011, "Love On Top" debuted at number 85 on the US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart. It moved to number 9 on the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart issue dated February 11, 2012, and became the third song from '4' to chart inside the top ten of that chart. For the week ending March 3, 2012, the song earned the Greatest Gainer/Airplay title as it lifted from number 4 to number 2 on the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart with 30 million audience impressions, which went up by 22%, according to Nielsen BDS. "Love On Top" topped the chart for the week ending March 10, 2012; it was Beyonc's sixth song during her solo career to reach number one on the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs chart. It spent six consecutive weeks on the top of the chart."Love On Top" spent six consecutive weeks at number 1 on the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs:
*
*
*
*
*
* Before being sent for adds on any format on US radios, "Love On Top" debuted at number 36 on the BDS Urban AC National airplay chart issue dated October 29, 2011, having amassed 106 spins, including 55 in 7 days. According to Nielsen BDS, 18 Urban AC radio stations added the song to their playlists for that week ending. For the week ending March 3, 2012, it became Beyonc's first number-one on the US Adult R&B Airplay chart.
Similarly owing to the live performance, "Love On Top" debuted at number 65 on the Canadian Hot 100 chart issue dated September 17, 2011. The song also entered at number 75 on the UK Singles Chart and at number 23 on the UK R&B Chart on September 4, 2011, It debuted at number 14 on the New Zealand Singles Chart the following day, and spent seven non-consecutive weeks on the chart. In Ireland, "Love On Top" made its debut at number 47 on September 8, 2011. The song also entered at number 40 on the Australian Singles Chart on September 12, 2011. The following week, it debuted at number 9 of the Australian Urban Singles Chart, and was the most added song to radios in Australia. "Love On Top" peaked at number 20 on the singles chart on November 6, 2011, and number 4 on the urban chart on October 17, 2011. Having spent 16 consecutive weeks on the Australian Singles Chart, the song was certified double platinum by the Australian Recording Industry Association (ARIA), denoting sales of 140,000 copies.
After having been announced as a single in the UK, "Love On Top" re-entered the UK Singles Chart at number 154 on November 13, 2011, and moved to number 87 the following week. It also moved from number 63 to number 38 on the UK R&B Chart. On December 4, 2011, "Love On Top" climbed from number 54 to number 28 on the UK Singles Chart and from 16 to number 7 on the UK R&B Chart, where the song has peaked. The following week, it moved to number 22 on the UK Singles Chart, where it remained until January 1, 2012. On January 8, 2012, "Love On Top" reached number 20, selling 15,660 digital copies and bringing its total sales to 120,648 copies. The single peaked at number 13 on the UK Singles Chart the following week. On June 9, 2015, the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) certified "Love On Top" platinum, denoting sales of 600,000 copies in the country.
Music video
Background
The music video for "Love On Top" was directed by Ed Burke and Beyonc. A preview of the clip was shown on the Australian television program, 'Sunday Night', on October 9, 2011. The visuals showed Beyonc in a black leotard, stockings, high-top sneakers, and medal-adorned Czech military cap. Together with her five male dancers, they perform choreographed moves at Canoe Studios, a penthouse studio in West Chelsea overlooking New York City. The preview was inspired by the music video for "If It Isn't Love" by American band New Edition and was described as "stripped-down" by Tom Ayres of Digital Spy. The full video was initially supposed to be premiered on October 17, 2011, on Australia's 'Today Show'. However, the release date was pushed up a day and it was released on October 16, 2011, instead. That same day, Beyonc posted the following statement regarding the video on her official website:
I am excited to give my Australian fans the World Premiere of 'Love On Top'! Thank you for the amazing response to the song at radio. I have worked very hard on this video, this song is special to me and I had an idea for the video based on some of my favorite male groups. I remember seeing videos from New Edition, The Jackson 5 and the Temptations, bands I love for their beautiful harmonies, and precise choreography and I always wanted to make a video and be part of a boy group myself. It was so much fun. I put my heart and soul into 'Love On Top' and I hope you love it.
After the release of the sneak peek, Michael Bivins of New Edition told Theybf.com, "When I saw Beyonce on the MTV awards in the sequined jacket this year and with the dancers in R&B group positions, I knew then she was showing love to NE! The video teaser was part two... the classic video 'If It Isn't Love' reference." After the release of the full video, Johnny Gill told 'S2S' magazine that he considers "Love On Top"s video to be a tribute and that Beyonc as well as her backup dancers did a great job of capturing New Edition's essence. In his opinion, that is why "she is one of the greatest living performers." He went on to say, "[The video] was so cool. There's no more Michael Jackson but I think she's a beast to begin with. It's such an honor to have someone who knew, and knows, her history and to be aware of where it all started."
Synopsis
Although the song is 4 minutes and 27 seconds long, the video is 3 minutes and 17 seconds long due to the omission of the second verse. Erika Ramirez of 'Billboard' magazine and Melissa Maerz of 'Entertainment Weekly' highlighted the fact that Beyonc wears several different clothes including the dress that was worn during her performance at the 2011 MTV Video Music Awards. The clip starts with a casually dressed Beyonc moving in coordination with her male back-up dancers who are also wearing casual clothes and Nike Dunks. Wearing a black body suit with black hose, Beyonc puts on a display of footwork before breaking into the song. About halfway through, the visuals suddenly switch to night as the singer lights up the space in various formal looks, including a gold pantsuit, white suit, and finally a tuxedo complete with coattails, top hat, and cane. The choreography from here resembles that of the 1960s male groups. The wardrobe changes in fact correspond with every key change, except the final one. The video ends with Beyonc yelling "cut!" and the shot returns to them at rehearsal.
Reception
'Consequence of Sound's Alex Young praised the simplicity of the concept adding that it costs "more money than your entire life fortune." That was echoed by Andrew Martin of 'Prefix Magazine' who called the video "super-simplistic, albeit effective." A writer of 'OK!' compared the video with Will Smiths work in 'The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air' adding that Beyonc "has gone back to video basics." A writer of 'The Huffington Post' called the video a "fresh take on a New Edition classic" and concluded that it was a "lot more simple than it sounds." Lisa Potter of 'Marie Claire' also praised the energy and Beyonc's figure in the video, writing, "The pregnant superstar puts on another energetic performance during the video, showing off her fabulous figure in a skimpy black leotard complete with a military fetish cap and Isabel Marant sneakers, before changing into a series of tailored suits." Jenna Hally Rubenstein of MTV Buzzworthy wrote that the video was similar to Michael Jackson's 'Dangerous' era adding, "While some might say the basic concept of Beyonc's 'Love on Top' video is too straightforward, we actually think it's amazing just let Beyonc sing, dance, look fuhLAWless and wear a cute hat! What else do you people need?!" Maura Johnston of 'The Village Voice' described the video as a direct homage to New Edition's "If It Isn't Love" but added that when the song's key changes start, "Beyonc and her posse of backup dancers get a bit brassier and fancier". She further wrote that the video was something that Phil Collins "would be proud" of.Comparing the video with works by Stevie Wonder, Matthew Perpetua of 'Rolling Stone' wrote, "compared to the over-the-top sensory overload of 'Countdown, ' the 'Love on Top' clip is very simple and straightforward, with the singer performing with backup singers and dancers in a spare room. Still, she changes wardrobe with every key change as the song reaches its euphoric climax." Similarly, Leah Collins of 'Dose' magazine wrote, "New jack swing dance moves and costume changes are pretty much the focus of this one. [...] Still, Beyonce reveals a talent we never knew she had: the ability to switch costumes every time she switches keys. (This, it turns out, is a good thing. That pantsless African dictator look in the first scene? Maybe we're the only ones, but we're not really feeling Idi Amin-chic this season.)" Georgette Cline of 'The Boombox' found similarities between the video for "Love On Top" and the earlier videos that Beyonc made with Destiny's Child while Sarah Anne Hughes of 'The Washington Post' called the video fancy and an "obvious homage to New Edition's 'If It Isn't Love.'" A more mixed review was given by Amanda Dobbins of 'New York' magazine who wrote that "The video will do nothing to silence Beyonc plagiarism or baby bump conspiracy theorists; the first half borrows from an old New Edition video, and the entire thing was clearly filmed before her bump began to show." However, she added, "Still, Vulture salutes any artistic undertaking that requires a costume change with every key change." The video was nominated in the category for Video of the Year at the 2012 BET Awards and in the category for Best Female Video at the 2012 MTV Video Music Awards. It won Best Dance Performance at the 2012 Soul Train Music Awards.
Live performances
Beyonc performed "Love On Top" live for the first time on August 14, 2011, during her residency show 4 Intimate Nights with Beyonc held at Roseland Ballroom in New York City. Wearing a gold dress, she performed the song in front of 3,500 people, backed by her all-female band and her backing singers, the Mamas. For the performance, "Love On Top" was given an "uptempo overhaul" and eventually got everyone "moving to the catchy [synthesizers]", as stated by Mike Wass of Idolator. Wass also wrote that "Love On Top" was one of the highlights of the concert. Jon Caramanica of 'The New York Times' gave Beyonc critical acclaim, favoring performances of "underdog tracks" such as "Party" and "Love On Top". Jody Rosen of 'Rolling Stone' also complimented Beyonc's performance of the song, commending how she turned "the groovy 'Love on Top' into a vintage soul showcase, dropping on bended knee to unleash melismas at the top of her vocal range." Jozen Cummings of 'The Wall Street Journal' commented that "the focus was on her voice [on] 'Love on Top' [...] she changes key four times impressive on the album but even more so in person." Yolanda Sangweni of 'Essence' magazine stated that the fact that Beyonc goes through four key changes is "quite a feat for any singer." The live performance was later included on the DVD 'Live at Roseland: Elements of 4' which chronicled the concert. It premiered online and released on the iTunes Store on January 11, 2012.
in 2013
In May 2012, Beyonc performed "Love On Top" during her residency show Revel Presents: Beyonc Live in Atlantic City. Beyonc started singing the song by saying, "Atlantic City, snap your fingers". According to Maura Johnston of 'The Village Voice', the crowd "sang the chorus of 'Love on Top' and even... tried its endlessly modulating key-change while Beyonc watched with bemusement and delight". Chuck Darrow of 'The Philadelphia Inquirer' was positive about the performance of the song during the concert, saying, "As for the music, Beyonce kept the needle in the red zone for much of the show, dealing primarily in such full-throttle, groove-intensive signature tracks as 'Love on Top'". Tris McCall of New Jersey On-Line noted that she "made the most of each modulation and break" while performing the song. Rebecca Thomas of MTV News was also positive about the performance, writing, "Without missing a step of the New Edition-inspired choreography, B powered through the song's modulations in an extended vocal showcase." The performance of "Love On Top" on the concert was later included on the concert film 'Live in Atlantic City' (2013).
Beyonc sang the chorus of the song a cappella during the opening of her Super Bowl XLVII halftime show performance. In 2013 and 2014, the song was part of the set list of Beyonc's The Mrs. Carter Show World Tour. On May 8, 2013, while performing the song in Manchester, she held her microphone out to a random audience member, which turned out to be British singer Joe McElderry, who sang a line of the song through the microphone. An a cappella version of the song was performed in 2016 as part of the setlist of The Formation World Tour.
Video Music Awards performance
At the 2011 MTV Video Music Awards, Beyonc performed "Love On Top" after having said on the black carpet about an hour before going on stage that she would be making an announcement. Before beginning her live performance, she said to the audience: "Tonight I want you to stand up on your feet, I want you to feel the love that's growing inside of me", giving a hint about the news that she had alluded to on the black carpet. She took the stage in "a purple spangly tuxedo jacket, black pants and white tuxedo shirt, still rocking her fierce six-inch heels of old, pregnant or not", as stated by Gil Kaufman of MTV News. As she performed, her blond hair blowing in the wind, and backed by six dancers wearing similar shimmering tuxes, Beyonc gave new meaning to the lyrics: "Now everybody asks me why I'm smiling out from ear to ear." She kept her dancing to a minimum for most of the song as she held onto the microphone stand while singing "Love On Top". Eventually making her way to the extended lip in front of the stage and throwing down, she encouraged the audience to put their hands together. Beyonc ended the performance by dropping the microphone, opening her jacket, rubbing her belly, and thus announcing her pregnancy to the world.Describing Beyonc as "a veteran on the VMA stage", Kaufman wrote that "the audience was clearly feeling the love also" and praised how she "[got] a bit wild as she brought the tune home with some of her signature." Staff members of the AOL's 'The Boombox' commented that the lyrics of the song "felt especially meaningful" to announce her pregnancy to the world. Staff members of 'Rolling Stone' called the performance "spectacular" while Todd Martens of the 'Los Angeles Times' called it "rousing". Claire Suddath of 'Time' magazine commented that "this offering from the reigning queen of pop music is relatively toned down and yet she still looked and sounded better than nearly everyone else at the awards." Similarly, Darren Franich of 'Entertainment Weekly' wrote that "If you had to pick one defining moment, it would have to be Beyonc's baby bump. The diva's rendition of 'Love on Top' might not have been her best VMA performance ever, but there's no denying the sheer electricity in the room when she ended her set by proudly revealing her pregnant tummy." A critic of 'Essence' magazine concluded that "[Beyonc's] performance of 'Love on Top' at the 2011 VMAs [...] will surely be one of the year's most memorable pop culture moments." The writers of MTV News placed the performance at number 4 on their list of Best Live MTV Performances of 2011. It was stated that Beyonc was in "typical Sasha Fierce fashion" while the performance was described as "ebullient". Erika Ramirez of 'Billboard' magazine put the performance at number two on her list of "Beyonce's 5 Biggest TV Performances" adding that it was "one of the most memorable TV moments of her career". Dan Hyman from 'Rolling Stone' listed the performance and Beyonc's announcement of her pregnancy at number 17 on the list of "The 24 Wildest Moments in VMA History", while 'Billboard' listed it at number 7 on its list of "MTV VMAs' 10 Best Performances Ever" in 2013.
Cover versions
On March 18, 2012, the girls on the Australian talent show 'Young Talent Time' team opened the show with a performance of "Love On Top", while the boys performed as backing vocalists. Diana Rouvas performed the song on 'The Voice' (Australia) on May 21, 2012. Michelle Graffin of 'The Age' called it the "song of the night", writing that Rouvas was "so good she can wrestle 'Love on Top' from Beyonc's iron grip and transform it into a smokey nightclub number worthy of the young Liza Minnelli". Rouvas' version of "Love On Top" peaked at number 22 on the Australian Singles Chart on June 3, 2012. On September 17, 2012, Nathaniel Willemse performed "Love On Top" during the first live show of the fourth season of 'The X Factor' in Australia. A writer for Take 40 Australia called it a "smooth performance". On February 22, 2013, Novita Dewi performed "Love On Top" during the first gala show of the first season of 'X Factor Indonesia'.
Amber Holcomb, a contestant of the 12th season of 'American Idol' covered the song on April 10, 2013, during an episode of the show. Brian Mansfield of 'USA Today' praised her performance writing that she was "comfortable and confident and happy" but added that the high melody of the song "puts a little strain on her voice toward the end". That was somewhat echoed by Bobby Olivier of 'The Star-Ledger' who noted that the performance was "pitchy, but a lot of fun". However, he wrote that Holcomb "seemed to struggle a little with keeping up with the melody" and that her version was different from the original, but concluded that it was a solid performance. On April 8, 2013, Zendaya and Val Chmerkovskiy performed a samba dance to the song during the 16th season of the American show 'Dancing with the Stars'. Morissette and Penelope Matanguihan performed the song on the first season of 'The Voice of the Philippines' on June 23 and July 14, 2013, respectively. In 2018 Dami Im released a version on her album 'I Hear a Song'. On February 9, 2017, Peck Palitchoke, a contestant of The Mask Singer Thailand (season 1) under the kangaroo mask, performed "Love On Top". In August 2020, the cast of 'Pitch Perfect' performed a cover of the song and was part of a charity for Unicef, from the COVID-19 pandemic and the explosion of Beirut.
Credits and personnel
Credits to the song were adapted from '4's liner notes.
*Beyonc Knowles vocals, producer, songwriter
*Alex Asher trombone
*Nikki Glaspie drums
*Serban Ghenea mixer
*John Hanes mix engineer
*Cole Kamen-Green trumpet
*Terius "The-Dream" Nash songwriter
*Drew Sayers tenor, baritone saxophone
*Phil Seaford mix engineer assistant
*Robert "R.T." Taylor guitar
*Shea Taylor producer, songwriter, alto saxophone
*Pat Thrall guitar
*Nick Videen tenor, alto saxophone
*Johnny Butler tenor, baritone saxophone
*Pete Wolford engineer assistant
*Scott Barnett engineer assistant
*Josiah Woodson trumpet
*Jordan "DJ Swivel" Young engineer
Charts
Weekly charts
{|class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"|-
! scope="col"| Chart (201112)
! scope="col"| Peak
position
|-
!scope="row"| Australian Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|20
|-
!scope="row"| Australian Urban Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|4
|-
!scope="row"| Belgian Tip Chart (Flanders)
| style="text-align:center;"|3
|-
!scope="row"| Belgian Tip Chart (Wallonia)
| style="text-align:center;"|2
|-
! scope="row"| Brazilian Hot 100 Airplay
| style="text-align:center;"|74
|-
!scope="row"| Canadian Hot 100
| style="text-align:center;"|65
|-
!scope="row"| French Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|83
|-
!scope="row"|Global Dance Songs ('Billboard')
| style="text-align:center;"|26
|-
!scope="row"| Hungarian Singles Chart
|align="center"|3
|-
!scope="row"| Irish Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|21
|-
!scope="row"| Italian FIMI Singles Chart
|style="text-align:center;"|18
|-
!scope="row"|Italian 'M&D' Singles Chart 'Set "Tipo" on "Singoli". Then, in the "Titolo" field, search "Love on top".'
|style="text-align:center;"|16
|-
!scope="row"| Japan Hot 100
| style="text-align:center;"|85
|-
! scope="row"|Mexico Ingles Airplay ('Billboard')
| style="text-align:center;"| 32
|-
!scope="row"| Mexico Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|34
|-
! scope="row"| Netherlands (Dutch Tip Chart)
| style="text-align:center;"|23
|-
! scope="row"| Netherlands (Single Top 100)
| style="text-align:center;"|61
|-
!scope="row"| New Zealand Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|14
|-
!scope="row"| Slovak Airplay Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|38
|-
!scope="row"| South Africa Airplay Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|8
|-
!scope="row"| South Korea International Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|3
|-
!scope="row"| UK Singles Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|13
|-
!scope="row"| UK R&B Chart
| style="text-align:center;"|6
|-
!scope="row"| US 'Billboard' Hot 100
|style="text-align:center;"|20
|-
!scope="row"| US Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs
| style="text-align:center;"|1
|-
!scope="row"| US Hot Dance Club Songs
| style="text-align:center;"|1
|-
!scope="row"| US Rhythmic Top 40 Note: Need Login.
| style="text-align:center;"|23
|}
Year-end charts
Certifications
Release history
See also
* List of number-one R&B singles of 2012 (U.S.)
* List of number-one dance singles of 2012 (U.S.)
References
Buy Love On Top now from Amazon
<-- Return to songs from 2011