Home | Songs By Year | Songs from 1994
Brokenhearted (Brandy song)
Buy Brokenhearted (Brandy song) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the song. And once you've experienced the song, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
"'Brokenhearted'" is a song by American recording artist Brandy Norwood. It was written and produced by Kipper Jones and Keith Crouch for her self-titled debut studio album, 'Brandy' (1994). Requested by then Atlantic Records head Sylvia Rhone, the song was developed late into the production of the album. Pressured to meet Rhone's deadline for 'Brandy', Kipper suffered from a case of writer's block during the early writing process but eventually came up with the idea for a sweet, morose R&B ballad that deals with the aches of a teenager's first heartbreak.
A re-recorded duet version of the song featuring additional vocals from Boyz II Men singer Wanya Morris and produced by Danish production duo Soulshock and Karlin, was released as the album's fourth and final single in August 1995. Music critics were divided on whether the remix improved on the album version. On the charts, "Brokenhearted" peaked inside the top 10 in New Zealand and on the US 'Billboard' Hot 100, becoming Norwood's third domestic top ten hit. It has since been certified Gold in United States by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA).
A music video depicting Norwood daydreaming about doing a duet with Morris inside a big mansion was directed by Hype Williams and filmed inside the Oheka Castle on the North Shore of Long Island in July 1995. At the 1996 MTV Video Music Awards, "Brokenhearted" received a nomination in the Best Cinematography in a Video category. Norwood and Morris performed their version on numerous occasions, including the 1996 'Billboard' Music Awards, 'The Oprah Winfrey Show' and on several other televised appearances.
Background
"Brokenhearted" was written and produced by Keith Crouch and Kipper Jones. Requested by then Atlantic Records head Sylvia Rhone after hearing their work on "I Wanna Be Down" and "Baby," Kipper suffered from a case of writer's block during the early writing process. Crouch used a Roland TD-77 unit to simulate the wind and harpsichord-type sounds as well as a Yamaha TG77 synthesizer workstation to produce the upright bass sounds on the balad. Inspired by singer Prince's song "Condition of the Heart" (1985) with its "little nuances and the little sounds and effects," he blended the bass with a lead synth line, playing it an octave lower than what had initially planned to craft a sound that he described as "like outer space a little bit." The album version of "Brokenhearted" was recorded in a single take; Norwood remembered during the release of 'The Best of Brandy' in 2005: "There's a funny story behind the recording of that song! I really wanted to go to Six Flags but the producers kept saying, only after you finish recording!' I sang my heart out [...] I wanted to go to Six Flags so bad! You can hear the passion in my voice!"
The idea for a duet version of "Brokenhearted" originally came up while Norwood was on a two-month stint as the opening act on all-male vocal harmony group Boyz II Men's national tour in early 1995. Both artists were on the airplane on the way to another city, when band member Wanya Morris got his hands on a copy of Brandy's debut album: "I was listening to her album on the plane and I was like, 'Yo, we should do a duet of 'Brokenhearted'," Wanya told 'MTV News' the following year. Atlantic Records consulted Danish record producers Soulshock and Karlin to record a new version of the song with both singers at Boyz II Men's studio in Philadelphia. In a 2020 interview, Carsten Schack commented on the process: "Wanya and Brandy went into the studio together and they had a good connection. We just caught that moment when she was singing. She was another one with an amazing tone. I think our approach was to take the remixes very seriously and trying to make it better than the original."
Critical reception
A review for 'Vibe', Lela Olds wrote that "whether listening to the album version or the remix featuring then-boyfriend and Boyz II Men member Wanya Morris, you have no choice but to get your fingers snapping when listening to "Brokenhearted"." 'Billboard's Larry Flick remarked that the song "drops the tempo to a spare ballad pace, giving the tempo ingenue the space to stretch and explore the soulful parameters of her voice." He found that the duet version with Morris "adds muscle to its already considerable programming power. Will waft over several formats like a cool, refreshing breeze." Flick's 'Billboard' colleague Chris Williams felt that "the album rendition has more of a thump to it, though it's still stripped down and minimalist. This is a teenager singing about how life goes on post-breakup. But the lyrics are so grown, they could've easily been sung by artists like Tamia or Deborah Cox."
Rylee Jackson, writing for 'The Nevada Sagebrush', called "Brokenhearted" another "example of a song with an excellent remix that has continued to be more relevant than the original. Featuring Boyz II Men lead singer Wanya Morris, the track is the typical somber R&B slow jam, but also depicts the positive side of heartbreak [...]." 'Oprah Daily's Grant Rindnerfelt wrote that "Brandy said that she wasn't feeling particularly inspired the day she recorded "Brokenhearted," but you'd have a hard time telling as she stretches into her upper and lower registers with conviction and bounces off the booming, soulful piano." In his review for 'Entertainment Weekly', Dimitri Ehrlich wrote: "Featuring saccharine sentiments set to turgid arrangements, the seamlessly produced, soulless ballad "Brokenhearted" is something like Lawrence Welk meets Mary J. Blige. If you wanna be down, as Brandy's first hit proclaimed, a teaming with Milquetoast crooner Wanya Morris [...] is the wrong way to go."
Music video
on Long Island.
Norwood reunited with Hype Williams, director of her previous videos for "I Wanna Be Down (Human Rhythm Hip Hop Remix)" and "Baby," to film a visual for "Brokenhearted." Filming took place inside the Oheka Castle, a mansion located on the North Shore of Long Island, in West Hills, New York. Much of the scenes were filmed on the estate's third and fourth floor before their restoration several years later. Norwood and Morris who each shot their scenes separately, do not appear in any sequence together in the video though "Brokenhearted" blends several of their scenes.
The music video begins with shots of a large tree and Norwood laying on a blanket in a field. When asked about the treatment of the video, Norwood told 'MTV News' during the shooting: "It's basically a dream, because of course this is not reality. I can't afford a mansion right now, so it's like I fall asleep and I dream about doing a duet with Wanya and I'm in this big mansion wearing these grown clothes, big beautiful Whitney Houstontype clothes." At the 1996 MTV Video Music Awards, "Brokenhearted"s director of photography Martin Coppen was nominated for Best Cinematography in a Video but lost to Declan Quinn for his work on the video for The Smashing Pumpkins's "Tonight, Tonight" (1995).
Track listings
All tracks written by Keith Crouch and Kipper Jones.
{{tracklist
| headline = Cassette single
| extra_column = Producer(s)
| title1 = Brokenhearted
| note1 = Soulpower Mix
| extra1 =
| length1 = 4:49
| title2 = Brokenhearted
| note2 = LP Version
| extra2 = Crouch
| length2 = 5:52
}}
{{tracklist
| headline = CD single
| extra_column = Producer(s)
| title1 = Brokenhearted
| note1 = Soulpower Mix
| extra1 =
| length1 = 4:49
| title2 = Brokenhearted
| note2 = Soulpower Groove Mix
| extra2 =
| length2 = 4:47
| title3 = Brokenhearted
| note3 = Acoustic Mix
| extra3 = Crouch
| length3 = 5:18
| title4 = Brokenhearted
| note4 = LP Version
| extra4 = Crouch
| length4 = 5:52
}}
'Notes'
* denotes additional producer
Credits and personnel
Credits adapted from the liner notes of 'Brandy'.
*Keith Crouch producer, recording, writer
*Sherree Ford-Payne backing vocals
*Brian Gardner mastering
*Kipper Jones writer
*Booker T. Jones mixing
*Brandy Norwood backing vocals, lead vocals
Charts
Weekly charts
Year-end charts
Certifications
Release history
References
Buy Brokenhearted (Brandy song) now from Amazon
<-- Return to songs from 1994