Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2016
The Human Surge
Buy The Human Surge now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'The Human Surge' is a 2016 experimental film directed, written, photographed and edited by the Argentine director Eduardo Williams. It is Williams' first feature film, after a number of shorts. 'The Human Surge' is divided into three separate narrative and geographical segments: the first in Buenos Aires, the second in Maputo, and the third in Bohol.
Each segment follows a handful of characters, who are often seen loitering or moving between spaces, such as workplace and home. The segments are linked with diegetic bridges. Williams has stated that he wanted to explore the sensation and feelings related to aimlessness and travel, and thereby "create a rhythm between excitement and boredom or surprise and depression."Gustavo Beck, "[https://mubi.com/notebook/posts/embracing-uncertainty-an-interview-with-eduardo-williams Embracing Uncertainty: An Interview with Eduardo Williams]," 'MUBI', August 8, 2016. The characters depicted in the three segments are invariably poor, restless and on the search for connection with other human beings.
The film premiered at the Locarno Film Festival in 2016, where it won the Golden Leopard - Filmmakers of the Present. It was subsequently released at film festivals in Toronto and New York to critical acclaim. Comparisons have been made to other filmmakers working in the slow cinema subgenre, where emphasis is made on the durational aspect of the moving image, rather than its narrative qualities.
Synopsis
In Buenos Aires, the 25-year-old Exe is seen waking up and getting dressed in his apartment. He wades waist-deep through a flooded neighbourhood to arrive at his workplace, a supermarket, only to be fired from his position. He subsequently spends time with his friends and family, loitering with the former in urban spaces and visiting online sex chat rooms. They perform sex acts, like fellatio, on each other in front of a web camera for virtual payment.
The movie moves on to the next segment through the window of a Chaturbate website, in which a group of African teenagers in Maputo, Mozambique are also seen engaging in cybersex for money. The Mozambique characters are also unemployed and empoverished, and perambulate through the streets between odd jobs and social events.
One character is found urinating on an anthill, which functions as a diegetic segue to the film's third segment, when the camera follows ants moving into the earth, before finally arriving at a hand holding a smartphone in a jungle somewhere in the Philippines. The film subsequently follows a couple of characters bathing together and walking through the jungle, in particular one woman looking to charge her cellphone. Finally, the film moves into a technological factory in Bohol, where tablet computers are made on an assembly line. The last words are spoken by a machine, repeatedly saying "Okay."
Production
Williams had made six short films before his feature debut 'The Human Surge', in which he had experimented with different video formats and textures.Ela Bittencourt, "[https://www.filmcomment.com/blog/interview-eduardo-williams/ Interview: Eduardo Williams]," 'Film Comment', October 5, 2016. In the short films 'Pude ver in Puma' (eng. 'Could See a Puma', 2011)[https://vimeo.com/54110254 'Pude ver un Puma'], Universidad del Cine (Vimeo), accessed August 14, 2017. and 'Ti qun ri!' (eng. 'I forgot!', 2014), he and his usual cinematographers Joaquin Neira and Julien Guillery experimented with various aesthetic strategiesnotably the use of long, handheld tracking shots (often described as "floating" and "restless"), amateur photography, as well as elliptical storytellingwhich they also used in 'The Human Surge'.Nick Pinkerton, "[https://www.artforum.com/film/id=66957 Mountain Out of an Anthill]," 'Artforum', February 3, 2017.
For 'The Human Surge', Williams used three different video formats, one for each segment: the Argentine segment was shot on 16 mm film, the Mozambique part with a Blackmagic pocket camerasubsequently recaptured in Super 16 from a computer monitor, and the final Philippine sequence on a digital RED camera.Andra Picard, "[http://metrograph.com/edition/article/44/aboard-the-human-express Aboard the Human Express]," 'Metrograph', March 1, 2017.Mark Peranson, "[https://www.locarnoinlosangeles.com/thehumansurge The Human Surge]," Locarno Festival in Los Angeles, accessed August 14, 2017.
: . "[https://pardo.ch/pardo/pardo-live/today-at-festival/2016/day-6/cdp-el-auge-del-humano.html El auge del humano]," PardoLive, August 8, 2016.
: . "[http://cinema-scope.com/columns/cinema-scope-68-editors-note/ Cinema Scope 68 Editor's Note]," 'Cinema Scope' 68, 2016. In the Mozambique segment, Williams operated the camera himself, considering it "so small," whereas in the two other segments he was helped by several assistants.
In his first short films, Williams had regularly employed a domestic Argentine setting. However, in the latest shorts'That I'm Falling?' (2013) and 'I forgot!' (2014)he opted for different locales, Sierra Leone and Vietnam, respectively. Having travelled abroad only very rarely as a young man, Williams was struck by the beauty of foreign languages, and wanted to use them in a filmic context. He eventually also discovering a charm in his own vernacular, spoken Spanish.
Analysis
The film has been analysed for its commonalities with other entries in Williams' oeuvre, most notably the themes of alienation in the internet age, and how modern technology creates distance between people.
Picking up on the theme of internet psychology, critic Nick Pinkerton noted the film's ambition in addressing "the enormous cognitive earthquake represented by the internet's colonization of daily life". He considered the transition into the anthill to be reminiscent of David Lynch's 'Blue Velvet', where in the opening scene the camera similarly dives "beneath the manicured lawn".
Several critics have found certain organizational elements within the film and, by extension, Williams' oeuvre. Leo Goldsmith of 'Cinema Scope' has called Williams' work a "cinema of vectors", noting the constant geographical and ontological displacement throughout his films. Ambulatory passages are frequent in Williams' cinema, where (often young) characters are seen moving through dilapidated apartments, supermarkets, areas of urban decay, jungles, rocky hillsides and caves. The novelty in 'The Human Surge' lies in its movement from literal/concrete places (anthill) to abstract/figurative places (internet).
In the final segment, Williams wanted to address the "illusion of escape", by moving to the natural, verdant greens of the Filipino jungle, only to pull back into a machine-filled factory, which he found to be a "very strange" and "very digital place".P. M. Cicchetti, "[http://reverseshot.org/archive/entry/2261/eduardo_human_surge An Interview with The Human Surge's Eduardo Williams]," 'Reverse Shot' (Museum of the Moving Image), March 2, 2017.
Serbo-Croatian filmmaker Iva Radivojevic compared Williams' film to Lucrecia Martel's 'La Cinaga' (2001, eng. 'The Swamp'). Beyond both being feature debuts from Argentinian filmmakers, Radivojevic found 'The Human Surge' to be starting "in a kind of swamp" and sharing a "mystical quality" with Martel's film, causing the spectator to be "injected into a kind of vacuum of time"."[https://mubi.com/notebook/posts/notebook-s-9th-writers-poll-fantasy-double-features-of-2016 Notebook's 9th Writers Poll: Fantasy Double Features of 2016]," 'MUBI', December 28, 2016.
Reception
'The Human Surge' premiered at the Locarno Film Festival to critical acclaim. It won the main prize in the section "Filmmakers of the Present" at the festival, the jury of which included Italian 'giallo' director Dario Argento.Leo Goldsmith, "[http://cinema-scope.com/features/human-surge-eduardo-williams-argentinabrazilportugal-wavelengths/ The Wanderer: Eduardo Williams The Human Surge]," 'Cinema Scope' 68, TIFF 2016.Zach Lewis, "[http://www.bkmag.com/2016/10/05/nyff-2016-human-surge/ #NYFF 2016: 'The Human Surge']," 'Brooklyn Magazine', October 5, 2016.
When the movie was shown at the Maryland Film Festival, programmer Eric Allen Hatch invoked the genre called 'slow cinema', citing filmmakers such as Andrei Tarkovsky, Lisandro Alonso, Harmony Korine and Gus van Sant, who also use the camera to depict the passing of time through the frame.Eric Allen Hatch, "[http://mdfilmfest.com/film/the-human-surge/ The Human Surge]," Maryland Film Festival, accessed August 14, 2017. In an interview with the director for 'Filmmaker Magazine', critic Vadim Rizov picked up on that theme, and considered Hungarian filmmaker Bla Tarr as an important influence on the film's long tracking shots, which follows characters moving through space. He also mentioned van Sant, finding the handheld camera to be suggestive of "the physical foot leather fueling the camerawork."Vadim Rizov, "[http://filmmakermagazine.com/101211-the-art-of-walking-2/#.WZH6q7puLIU The Art of Walking: Eduardo Williams on 'The Human Surge']," 'Filmmaker Magazine', January 18, 2017.
Nick Pinkerton of 'Artforum' lauded Williams for delivering a film "without an instruction manual meant to clear up any potential confusion." He was also impressed by the "bucolic natural beauty" of the film, finding the experience of watching it to be "a headlong dive into the rich, knotty, sticky undergrowth amid a proliferation of tidy, well-lit paths".
Some critics were less enthusiastic about the film. Jessica Kiang panned the film for 'Variety', claiming that while Williams' "formal rigor is to be admired", the humans in the film are "little more than microbes in the petri dish [of the filmmakers'] "formalist experiment." Kiang concluded that the film is, "a victim of its own effectiveness: It's rigorous, rarefied, and utterly remote".Jessica Kiang, "[https://variety.com/2017/film/reviews/the-human-surge-review-1201982599/ Film Review: The Human Surge (2017)]," 'Variety.com', February 9, 2017. Carson Lund of 'Slant Magazine' was also critical of the feature, considering it to be easily mistaken for "a particularly interminable YouTube video".Carson Lund, "[https://www.slantmagazine.com/film/review/the-human-surge The Human Surge]," 'Slant Magazine', February 24, 2017.
The film was listed on several best-of-the-year lists for both 2016 and 2017, due to different release dates."[http://sensesofcinema.com/2017/world-poll/world-poll-2016-part-1/ World Poll 2016 Part 1]," 'Senses of Cinema' 81, January 2017.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2017/world-poll/world-poll-2016-part-2/ World Poll 2016 Part 2]," 'Senses of Cinema' 81, January 2017.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2017/world-poll/world-poll-2016-part-3/ World Poll 2016 Part 3]," 'Senses of Cinema' 81, January 2017.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2017/world-poll/world-poll-2016-part-5/ World Poll 2016 Part 5]," 'Senses of Cinema' 81, January 2017.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2017/world-poll/world-poll-2016-part-6/ World Poll 2016 Part 6]," 'Senses of Cinema' 81, January 2017.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2018/world-poll/world-poll-2017-part-1/ World Poll 2017 Part 1]," 'Senses of Cinema' 85, January 2018.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2018/world-poll/world-poll-2017-part-2/ World Poll 2017 Part 2]," 'Senses of Cinema' 85, January 2018.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2018/world-poll/world-poll-2017-part-3/ World Poll 2017 Part 3]," 'Senses of Cinema' 85, January 2018.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2018/world-poll/world-poll-2017-part-4/ World Poll 2017 Part 4]," 'Senses of Cinema' 85, January 2018.
* "[http://sensesofcinema.com/2018/world-poll/world-poll-2017-part-6/ World Poll 2017 Part 6]," 'Senses of Cinema' 85, January 2018. It was considered the second best film of 2017 by the online film magazine 'Reverse Shot', a publication of the Museum of the Moving Image in New York. Editor Jeff Reichert noted its "shape-shifting" qualities and compared it to the works of Thai directors Apichatpong Weerasethakul and Anocha Suwichakornpong (the latter's 'By the Time It Gets Dark' was listed as number 8 on the same list), which he lauded for "allowing themselves to do whatever, whenever they please." He concluded his entry by calling 'The Human Surge' "the most laid-back movie of grand ambition to come along in some time.""[http://reverseshot.org/series/entry/2400/best_2017 Reverse Shot's Best of 2017]," 'Reverse Shot', January 1, 2018.
References
Buy The Human Surge now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2016