Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2012
Zero Dark Thirty
Buy Zero Dark Thirty now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
{{Infobox film
| name = Zero Dark Thirty
| image = ZeroDarkThirty2012Poster.jpg
| alt =
| caption =
| director = Kathryn Bigelow
| writer = Mark Boal
| producer =
| starring =
| cinematography = Greig Fraser
| editing =
| music = Alexandre Desplat
| studio =
| distributor =
| released =
| runtime = 157 minutes
| country = United States
| language = English
| budget = $4052.5 million
| gross = $132.8 million
}}
'Zero Dark Thirty' is a 2012 American thriller film directed by Kathryn Bigelow and written by Mark Boal. The film dramatizes the nearly decade-long international manhunt for Osama bin Laden, leader of terrorist network Al-Qaeda, after the September 11 attacks. This search leads to the discovery of his compound in Pakistan and the military raid where bin Laden was killed on May 2, 2011.
Jessica Chastain stars as Maya, a fictional CIA intelligence analyst, with Jason Clarke, Joel Edgerton, Reda Kateb, Mark Strong, James Gandolfini, Kyle Chandler, Stephen Dillane, Chris Pratt, dgar Ramrez, Fares Fares, Jennifer Ehle, John Barrowman, Mark Duplass, Harold Perrineau, and Frank Grillo in supporting roles.[http://www.screendaily.com/festivals/cannes/cannes-film-market/upi-takes-territories-on-kathryn-bigelows-zero-dark-thirty/5041885.article "UPI takes territories on Kathryn Bigelow's 'Zero Dark Thirty'"] ; 'Screen Daily;' May 15, 2012. It was produced by Boal, Bigelow, and Megan Ellison, and independently financed by Ellison's Annapurna Pictures. The film premiered in Los Angeles on December 10, 2012, and had its wide release on January 11, 2013.
'Zero Dark Thirty' received critical acclaim for its acting, direction, screenplay and editing, and was a box office success, grossing $132 million worldwide. It appeared on 95 critics' top ten lists of 2012. It was also nominated in five categories at the 85th Academy Awards: Best Picture, Best Actress for Chastain, Best Original Screenplay, Best Film Editing, and Best Sound Editing, which it won in a tie with 'Skyfall'. It earned Golden Globe Award nominations for Best Motion Picture Drama, Best Director, Best Screenplay, and Best Actress in a Motion Picture Drama for Chastain, who won.
The film's depiction of torture (so-called "enhanced interrogation techniques") generated controversy. Some critics, in light of the interrogations being depicted as gaining reliable, useful, and accurate information, considered the scenes pro-torture propaganda. Former interim acting director of the CIA Michael Morell felt that the film created the false impression that torture was key to finding bin Laden. Others described it as an anti-torture exposure of interrogation practices.
Republican Congressman Peter T. King charged that the filmmakers were given improper access to classified materials, which they denied. An unreleased draft of a report prepared by the Inspector General and published in June 2013 by the Project On Government Oversight stated that former CIA Director Leon Panetta discussed classified information during an awards ceremony for the United States Navy SEALs team that carried out the raid on the bin Laden compound. Unbeknownst to Panetta, screenwriter Boal was among the 1,300 present during the ceremony.
Plot
Maya Harris is a CIA analyst tasked with finding the al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden. In 2003, she is stationed at the U.S. embassy in Pakistan. She and CIA officer Dan Fuller attend the black site interrogations of Ammar (Reda Kateb), a detainee with suspected links to several of the hijackers in the September 11 attacks and who is subjected to approved torture interrogation techniques. Ammar provides unreliable information on a suspected attack in Saudi Arabia, but reveals the name of the personal courier for bin Laden, Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti. Other detainee intelligence connects courier traffic by Abu Ahmed between Abu Faraj al-Libbi and bin Laden. In 2005, Faraj denies knowing about a courier named Abu Ahmed; Maya interprets this as an attempt by Faraj to conceal the importance of Abu Ahmed.
In 2009, Maya's fellow officer and friend Jessica travels to a US base in Afghanistan to meet a Jordanian doctor, highly placed in al-Qaeda, who has offered to become a US spy for $25 million. Instead, he turns out to be a triple agent loyal to al-Qaeda, and Jessica is killed, along with several other CIA officers, when he detonates a suicide vest in what will come to be known as the Camp Chapman attack, the worst attack on CIA personnel in 25 years.
Thomas, an analyst who linked the Abu Ahmed lead, shares with Maya an interrogation of a Jordanian detainee claiming to have buried Abu Ahmed in 2001. Maya learns what the CIA was told five years earlier: Ibrahim Sayeed traveled under the name of Abu Ahmed al-Kuwaiti. Realizing her lead may be alive, Maya contacts Dan, now a senior officer at the CIA headquarters. She speculates that the CIA's photograph of Ahmed is that of his brother, Habeeb, who was killed in Afghanistan. Maya says that their beards and native clothes make the brothers look alike, explaining the account of Ahmed's "death" in 2001.
A Kuwaiti prince trades the phone number of Sayeed's mother to Dan for a Lamborghini Gallardo Bicolore. Maya and her CIA team in Pakistan use electronic methods to eventually pinpoint a caller in a moving vehicle who exhibits behaviors that delay confirmation of his identity (which Maya calls tradecraft, thus confirming that the subject is likely a senior courier). They track the vehicle to a large urban compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan. After gunmen attack Maya while she is in her vehicle, she is recalled to Washington, D.C. as her cover is believed blown.
The CIA puts the compound under surveillance, but obtains no conclusive identification of bin Laden. The President's National Security Advisor tasks the CIA with creating a plan to capture or kill bin Laden. Before briefing President Barack Obama, the CIA director holds a meeting of his senior officers, who estimate that bin Laden is 6080% likely to be in the compound. Maya, also in the meeting, places her confidence at 100%.
On May 2, 2011, the 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment flies two stealth helicopters from Afghanistan into Pakistan with members of DEVGRU and the CIA's Special Activities Division to raid the compound. The SEALs gain entry and kill a number of people in the compound, including a man whom they believe is bin Laden. At a U.S. base in Jalalabad, Afghanistan, Maya confirms the identity of the corpse.
She boards a military transport back to the U.S., the sole passenger. She is asked where she wants to go and begins to cry.
Cast
'CIA'
* Jessica Chastain as Maya Harris, a CIA intelligence analyst
* Jason Clarke as Dan Fuller, a CIA intelligence officer
* Jennifer Ehle as Jessica Karley, a senior CIA analyst
* Mark Strong as George Panetta, a senior CIA supervisor
* Kyle Chandler as Joseph Bradley, Islamabad CIA Station Chief
* James Gandolfini as CIA Director
* Harold Perrineau as Jack Fuller, a CIA analyst
* Mark Duplass as Steve Bradley, a CIA analyst
* Fredric Lehne as Fred "The Wolf" Guerrero, a CIA section chief
* John Barrowman as Jeremy Karley, a CIA executive
* Jessie Collins as Debbie Stone, a CIA analyst
* dgar Ramrez as Larry Handley, a CIA SAD/SOG operative
* Fares Fares as Hakim, a CIA SAD/SOG operative
* Scott Adkins as John Simmons, a CIA SAD/SOG operative
* Jeremy Strong as Thomas, a CIA analyst
'US Navy'
* Joel Edgerton as Patrick Grayston, DEVGRU (SEAL Team 6) team leader
* Chris Pratt as Justin Lenihan, DEVGRU operator.
* Callan Mulvey as Saber Till, DEVGRU operator.
* Taylor Kinney as Jared Bradley, DEVGRU operator
* Mike Colter as Mike, DEVGRU operator
* Frank Grillo as DEVGRU Commanding officer
* Christopher Stanley as JSOC Commander Vice Admiral Bill McRaven
'Other'
* Stephen Dillane as National Security Advisor Tom Donilon
* Mark Valley as C-130 pilot
* John Schwab as Deputy National Security Advisor
* Reda Kateb as Ammar, a terrorist who is tortured for information
* Homayoun Ershadi as Hassan Ghul
* Yoav Levi as Abu Farraj al-Libbi
* Ricky Sekhon as Osama bin Laden, leader and founder of Al Qaeda
Production
Titles
The film's working title was 'For God and Country'.[http://insidemovies.ew.com/2012/08/28/zero-dark-thirty-documents/ No conspiracy: New documents explain Pentagon, CIA cooperation on 'Zero Dark Thirty'] ; 'Entertainment Weekly'; August 28, 2012. The title 'Zero Dark Thirty' was officially confirmed at the end of the film's teaser trailer.[https://www.azcentral.com/thingstodo/movies/articles/20120806bin-laden-movie-trailer-zero-dark-thirty.html Bin Laden movie trailer is out; filmmakers are talking]; azcentral.com; August 6, 2012. Bigelow has explained that "it's a military term for 30 minutes after midnight, and it refers also to the darkness and secrecy that cloaked the entire decade-long mission."Writing
Bigelow and Boal had initially worked on and finished a screenplay centered on the December 2001 Battle of Tora Bora, and the long, unsuccessful efforts to find Osama bin Laden in the region. The two were about to begin filming when news broke that bin Laden had been killed.They immediately shelved the film they had been working on and redirected their focus, essentially starting from scratch. "But a lot of the homework I'd done for the first script and a lot of the contacts I made, carried over," Boal remarked during an interview with 'Entertainment Weekly'. He added, "The years I had spent talking to military and intelligence operators involved in counter-terrorism was helpful in both projects. Some of the sourcing I had developed long, long ago continued to be helpful for this version."
Along with painstakingly recreating the historic night-vision raid on the Abbottabad compound, the script and the film stress the little-reported role of the tenacious young female CIA officer who tracked down Osama bin Laden. Screenwriter Boal said that while researching for the film, "I heard through the grapevine that women played a big role in the CIA in general and in this team. I heard that a woman was there on the night of the raid as one of the CIA's liaison officers on the ground and that was the start of it." He then turned up stories about a young case officer who was recruited out of college, who had spent her entire career chasing bin Laden. Maya's tough-minded, monomaniacal persona, Boal said, is "based on a real person, but she also represents the work of a lot of other women." In December 2014 Jane Mayer of 'The New Yorker' wrote that "Maya" was modeled in part after CIA officer Alfreda Frances Bikowsky.
Filming
'Zero Dark Thirty' producers built a real compound in Jordan, based on what they could learn (from diagrams and reporting) about the building where the CIAs pursuit ended. The production designerJeremy Hindle, who had never made a feature film beforewas responsible for making the building as real as possible. The cinder blocks with which the building was made, for example, were distressed so that they didnt look new. Parts of the film were shot at PEC University of Technology in Chandigarh, India. Some parts of Chandigarh were designed to look like Lahore and Abbottabad in Pakistan, where Osama bin Laden was found and killed on May 2, 2011. Parts of the film were shot in Mani Majra. Local members of right wing parties protested, expressing anti-bin Laden and anti-Pakistan sentiments as they objected to Pakistani locations being portrayed on Indian soil.For a lone scene shot in Poland, the city of Gdask was reportedly offended for depicting it as a location for the CIA's clandestine and dark operations.
National security expert Peter Bergen, who reviewed an early cut of the film as an unpaid adviser, said at the time that the film's torture scenes "were overwrought". Boal said they were "toned down" in the final cut.
Music
Alexandre Desplat composed and conducted the film's score. The score, performed by the London Symphony Orchestra, was released as a soundtrack album by Madison Gate Records on December 19, 2012.Marketing
Electronic Arts promoted 'Zero Dark Thirty' in its video game 'Medal of Honor: Warfighter' by offering downloadable maps of locations depicted in the film. Additional maps for the game were made available on December 19, to coincide with the film's initial release. Electronic Arts donates $1 to nonprofit organizations that support veterans for each 'Zero Dark Thirty' map pack sold.[https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/cotown/la-et-ct-medal-honor-zero-dark-thirty-20120910,0,5940242.story 'Zero Dark Thirty' to be promoted in 'Medal of Honor' video game] ; 'Los Angeles Times'; September 10, 2012.
Release
Critical response
's performance garnered critical acclaim and she received her second Academy Award & BAFTA nomination and her third SAG nomination. She also received her first Golden Globe award for her performance in this film.On Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 91% based on 302 reviews, with an average rating of 8.60/10. The website's critical consensus reads, "Gripping, suspenseful, and brilliantly crafted, 'Zero Dark Thirty' dramatizes the hunt for Osama bin Laden with intelligence and an eye for detail." On Metacritic the film has a weighted average score of 95 out of 100, based on 46 critics, indicating "universal acclaim". It was the site's best-reviewed film of 2012. Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "A" on an A+ to F scale.
'New York Times' critic Manohla Dargis, who designated the film a 'New York Times' critics' pick, said that the film "shows the dark side of that war. It shows the unspeakable and lets us decide if the death of Bin Laden was worth the price we paid."
Richard Corliss's review in 'Time' magazine called it "a fine" movie and "a police procedural on the grand scale", saying it "blows 'Argo' out of the water". Calling 'Zero Dark Thirty' "a milestone in post-Sept. 11 cinema", critic A. O. Scott of 'The New York Times' listed the film at number six of the top 10 films of 2012.
'The New Yorker' film critic David Denby lauded the filmmakers for their approach. "The virtue of 'Zero Dark Thirty'," wrote Denby, "is that it pays close attention to the way life does work; it combines ruthlessness and humanity in a manner that is paradoxical and disconcerting yet satisfying as art." But Denby faulted the filmmakers for getting lodged on the divide between fact and fiction.
Roger Ebert of the 'Chicago Sun-Times' gave the film three stars out of four. He believed the "opening scenes are not great filmmaking", but Ebert thought 'Zero Dark Thirty' eventually proved itself with the quiet determination of Chastain's performance and a gripping portrayal of the behind-the-scenes detail that led to bin Laden's death.
Top ten lists
'Zero Dark Thirty' was listed on many critics' top ten lists. According to Metacritic the film appeared on 95 critics' top ten lists of 2012, 17 of which placed the film at No. 1.* 1st Richard Roeper
* 1st David Denby, 'The New Yorker' (tied with 'Lincoln')
* 1st Lisa Schwarzbaum, 'Entertainment Weekly'
* 1st Michael Phillips, 'Chicago Tribune'
* 1st Ann Hornaday, 'The Washington Post'
* 1st Scott Foundas, 'Village Voice'
* 1st Mary Pols, 'Time'
* 1st David Edelstein, 'New York'
* 1st Peter Knegt & Nigel M. Smith, 'Indiewire'
* 1st Christopher Orr, 'The Atlantic'
* 1st Keith Phipps, 'The A.V. Club'
* 2nd Peter Travers, 'Rolling Stone'
* 2nd Eric Kohn, 'Indiewire'
* 2nd Stephanie Zacharek, Film.com
* 2nd Joshua Rothkopf, 'Time Out New York'
* 2nd A.A. Dowd and Ben Kenigsberg, 'Time Out Chicago'
* 2nd Noel Murray, 'The A.V. Club'
* 2nd Gregory Ellwood, 'Hitfix'
* 2nd Scott Mantz, 'Access Hollywood'
* 2nd James Berardinelli, 'Reelviews'
* 3rd Stephen Holden, 'The New York Times'
* 3rd Ty Burr, 'The Boston Globe'
* 3rd Betsy Sharkey, 'Los Angeles Times'
* 3rd Mick LaSalle, 'San Francisco Chronicle'
* 3rd Elizabeth Weitzman, 'New York Daily News'
* 3rd Bill Goodykoontz, 'The Arizona Republic'
* 3rd Lou Lumenick, 'New York Post'
* 3rd Anne Thompson & Caryn James, 'IndieWire'
* 3rd Tasha Robinson, 'The A.V. Club'
* 4th Andrew O'Hehir, 'Salon.com'
* 4th Glenn Kenny, 'MSN Movies'
* 4th Marlow Stern, 'The Daily Beast'
* 5th Owen Gleiberman, 'Entertainment Weekly'
* 5th - Christy Lemire, Associated Press
* 5th Drew McWeeny, 'HitFix'
* 5th Todd McCarthy, 'The Hollywood Reporter'
* 5th Kyle Smith, 'New York Post'
* 6th Richard Corliss, 'Time'
* 6th A.O. Scott, 'The New York Times'
* 7th Kevin Jagernauth, 'IndieWire'
* 7th Lisa Kennedy, 'The Denver Post'
* 7th Alison Willmore, 'The A.V. Club'
* 8th Scott Tobias, 'The A.V. Club'
* 9th Keith Uhlich, 'Time Out New York'
* 9th Joe Neumaier, 'New York Daily News'
* 10th Steven Rea, 'The Philadelphia Inquirer'
* 10th Dana Stevens, 'Slate'
* Top 10 (ranked alphabetically) Richard Lawson, 'The Atlantic'
* Top 10 (listed alphabetically) Manohla Dargis, 'The New York Times'
* Top 10 (ranked alphabetically) Calvin Wilson, 'St. Louis Post-Dispatch'
* Top 10 (listed alphabetically) Joe Morgenstern, 'The Wall Street Journal'
* Best of 2012 (listed alphabetically, not ranked) Kenneth Turan, 'Los Angeles Times'
In 2016, 'Zero Dark Thirty' was voted the 57th greatest film to be released since 2000 in a critics' poll conducted by the BBC.
Box office
The limited release of 'Zero Dark Thirty' grossed $417,150 in the United States and Canada in only five theaters. A wide release followed on January 11.'Entertainment Weekly' wrote, "The controversial Oscar contender easily topped the chart in its first weekend of wide release with $24.4 million." 'Zero Dark Thirty' grossed $95,720,716 in the U.S. and Canada, along with $37,100,000 in other countries, for a worldwide total of $132,820,716. It was the top-grossing film of its wide release premiere weekend.
Accolades
'Zero Dark Thirty' was nominated for five Academy Awards at the 85th Academy Awards: Best Picture,
Best Actress, Best Original Screenplay, Best Sound Editing and Best Film Editing. Paul N. J. Ottosson won the Academy Award for Best Sound Editing, tying with 'Skyfall'. This was only the sixth tie in Academy Awards history, and the first since 1994. 'Zero Dark Thirty' was nominated for four Golden Globe Awards at the 70th Golden Globe Awards, including Best Motion Picture Drama, Best Director, Best Screenplay, with Chastain winning Best Actress Motion Picture Drama.
The Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association's award for Best Director was given to Bigelow, the second time the honor has gone to a woman (the first also being Bigelow for 'The Hurt Locker'). The film swept critics groups' awards for Best Director and Best Picture including the Washington D.C., New York Film Critics Online, Chicago and Boston film critics associations.
Home media
'Zero Dark Thirty' was released on DVD and Blu-ray Disc on March 26, 2013.Prequel
Writer Boal has stated his interest in making the original film on the 2001 Tora Bora hunt for bin Laden that he and Bigelow conceived. That finished screenplay had been set aside after bin Laden was killed in 2011 to focus on what became 'Zero Dark Thirty.' "I love reporting, so being on a big story is really exciting to me," said Boal, a former war journalist, of his scramble to write a new script after the event. "But nobody likes to throw out two years of work."[http://insidemovies.ew.com/2012/11/21/zero-dark-thirty-bin-laden-movie/ "'Zero Dark Thirty' Bin Laden Movie"], 'Inside Movies', November 21, 2012.
Historical accuracy
'Zero Dark Thirty' has received criticism for historical inaccuracy. Former Assistant Secretary of Defense Graham T. Allison has opined that the film is inaccurate in three important regards: the overstatement of the positive role of torture, the understatement of the role of the Obama administration, and the portrayal of the efforts as being driven by one agent battling against the CIA "system".
Steve Coll criticized the early depictions in the film that portrayed it as "journalism" with the use of composite characters. He took issue with the film's using the names of historical figures and details of their lives for characters, such as using details for "Ammar" to suggest that he was Ali Abdul Aziz Ali, whose 'nom de guerre' was Ammar al-Baluchi. Coll said the facts about him were different from what was portrayed in the film, which suggests the detainee will never leave the black site. Al-Baluchi was transferred to Guantanamo in 2006 for a military tribunal.
It was also criticized for its stereotypical portrayal of Pakistan as well as the inaccurate portrayal of Pakistani nationals speaking Arabic instead of Urdu and other regional languages, and locals wearing obsolete headgear.
Controversies
Allegations of partisanship
Partisan political controversy related to the film arose before shooting began.[http://insidemovies.ew.com/2012/08/06/zero-dark-thirty-first-look/ "Obama not in 'Zero Dark Thirty' thriller about hunt for Osama bin Laden"] ; 'Entertainment Weekly;' August 6, 2012. Opponents of the Obama Administration charged that 'Zero Dark Thirty' was scheduled for an October release just before the November presidential election to support his re-election. Sony denied that politics was a factor in release scheduling and said the date was the best available spot for an action-thriller in a crowded lineup. The film's screenwriter added, "the president is not depicted in the movie. He's just not in the movie."[http://security.blogs.cnn.com/2012/08/07/first-look-at-the-osama-bin-laden-movie/ "First look at the Osama bin Laden movie"] ; CNN; August 7, 2012.The distributor Columbia Pictures, sensitive to political perceptions, considered rescheduling the film release for as late as early 2013. It set a limited-release date for December 19, 2012, well after the election and rendering moot any alleged political conflict.[https://archive.today/20130119014059/http://www.chicagotribune.com/entertainment/sns-rt-us-zerodarkthirty-ciabre87s1et-20120829,0,5339438.story "Government communicated with "Zero Dark Thirty" makers"]; 'Chicago Tribune'; August 29, 2012.[https://www.ign.com/articles/2011/10/20/bin-laden-movie-gets-pushed-back "Bin Laden Movie Gets Pushed Back"] ; IGN Entertainment; October 20, 2011.[http://mediadecoder.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/10/19/release-date-of-bin-laden-film-may-change/ "Release Date of Bin Laden Film May Change"] ; 'New York Times'; October 19, 2011. The nationwide release date was pushed back to January 11, 2013, moving it out of the crowded Christmas period and closer to the Academy Awards. After the film's limited release, given the controversy related to the film's depiction of torture and its role in gaining critical information, 'The New York Times' columnist Frank Bruni concluded that the film is "a far, far cry from the rousing piece of pro-Obama propaganda that some conservatives feared it would be". Two months later, the paper's columnist Roger Cohen wrote that the film was "a courageous work that is disturbing in the way that art should be". Cohen disagreed with Steve Coll's critique of the screenwriter's stated effort not to "play fast and loose with history", writing that "Boal has honored those words". Cohen ended with a note about a Timothy Garton Ash analysis of George Orwell mixing fact and "invented" stories in 'Down and Out in Paris and London' as further support for Boal's method.Cohen, Roger, [https://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/12/opinion/global/roger-cohen-why-zero-dark-thirty-works.html?_r=0 "Why 'Zero Dark Thirty' Works"] , 'The New York Times', February 11, 2013. Retrieved February 12, 2013.
Allegations of improper access to classified information
Several Republican sources charged the Obama Administration of improperly providing Bigelow and her team access to classified information during their research for the film. These charges, along with charges of other leaks to the media, became a prevalent election season talking point by conservatives. The Republican national convention party platform even claimed Obama "has tolerated publicizing the details of the operation to kill the leader of Al Qaeda." No release of these details has been proven according to the 'Navy Times'.[http://www.navytimes.com/news/2012/08/ap-special-operators-tell-anti-obama-groups-zip-it-082112/ "Special Operators to Anti-Obama Groups: Zip It"]; AP News, 'Navy Times'; August 22, 2012.The Republican congressman Peter T. King requested that the CIA and the U.S. Defense Department investigate if classified information was inappropriately released; both departments said they would look into it. The CIA responded to Congressman King writing, "the protection of national security equities including the preservation of our ability to conduct effective counterterrorism operations is the decisive factor in determining how the CIA engages with filmmakers and the media as a whole."[http://homeland.house.gov/sites/homeland.house.gov/files/documents/pdf/110811_CIA_Letter.pdf "Letter from the CIA to King re: possible leaks"] ; House website; November 8, 2011.
The conservative watchdog group Judicial Watch publicized CIA and U.S. Defense Department documents obtained through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, and alleged that "unusual access to agency information" was granted to the filmmakers. An examination of the documents showed no evidence that classified information was leaked to the filmmakers. In addition, CIA records did not show any involvement by the White House in relation to the filmmakers. The filmmakers have said they were not given access to classified details about Osama bin Laden's killing. In 2012, Judicial Watch released an article stating the Obama Administration admitted that the information provided to the production team could pose an "unnecessary security and counterintelligence risk" if the information were to be released to the public. Judicial Watch also found emails containing information on five CIA and military operatives that were involved in the Bin Laden operations. These emails were provided to the filmmakers, as was later confirmed by the Obama Administration in a sworn declaration.
In January 2013, Reuters reported that the United States Senate Select Committee on Intelligence would review the contacts between the CIA and the filmmakers to find out whether Bigelow and Boal had inappropriate access to classified information. In February, Reuters reported that the inquiry had been dropped.
In June 2013, information was released in regards to an unreleased U.S. Defense Department Inspector General's office report. It stated that in June 2011, while giving a speech at a CIA Headquarters event honoring the people involved in the Osama Bin Laden raid, CIA Director Leon Panetta disclosed information classified as "Secret" and "Top Secret" regarding personnel involved in the raid on the Bin Laden compound. He identified the unit that conducted the raid as well as naming the ground commander that was in charge. Panetta also revealed DoD information during his speech that was classified as "Top Secret." Unknown to him, screenwriter Mark Boal was among the around 1300 present during the ceremony.
Allegations of pro-torture stance
The film has been both criticized and praised for its handling of its subject matter, including the portrayal of the harsh "enhanced interrogation techniques", commonly classified as torture. The use of these techniques was long kept secret by the Bush administration. (See Torture Memos, The Torture Report.) Glenn Greenwald, in 'The Guardian', stated that the film takes a pro-torture stance, describing it as "pernicious propaganda" and stating that it "presents torture as its CIA proponents and administrators see it: as a dirty, ugly business that is necessary to protect America." Critic Frank Bruni concluded that the film appears to suggest "No waterboarding, no Bin Laden". Jesse David Fox writes that the film "doesn't explicitly say that torture caught bin Laden, but in portraying torture as one part of the successful search, it can be read that way." Emily Bazelon said, "The filmmakers didn't set out to be Bush-Cheney apologists", but "they adopted a close-to-the-ground point of view, and perhaps they're in denial about how far down the path to condoning torture this led them."
Journalist Michael Wolff slammed the film as a "nasty piece of pulp and propaganda" and Bigelow as a "fetishist and sadist" for distorting history with a pro-torture viewpoint. Wolff disputed the efficacy of torture and the claim that it contributed to the discovery of bin Laden. In an open letter, social critic and feminist Naomi Wolf criticized Bigelow for claiming the film was "part documentary" and speculated over the reasons for Bigelow's "amoral compromising" of film-making, suggesting that the more pro-military a film, the easier it is to acquire Pentagon support for scenes involving expensive, futuristic military equipment. Wolf likened Bigelow to the acclaimed director and propagandist for the Nazi regime Leni Riefenstahl, saying: "Like Riefenstahl, you are a great artist. But now you will be remembered forever as torture's handmaiden." Author Karen J. Greenberg wrote that "Bigelow has bought in, hook, line, and sinker, to the ethos of the Bush administration and its apologists" and called the film "the perfect piece of propaganda, with all the appeal that naked brutality, fear, and revenge can bring". Peter Maass of 'The Atlantic' said the film "represents a troubling new frontier of government-embedded filmmaking".
Jane Mayer of 'The New Yorker', who has published 'The Dark Side', a book about the use of torture during the Bush administration, criticized the film, saying that Bigelow was
milk[ing] the U.S. torture program for drama while sidestepping the political and ethical debate that it provoked ... [By] excising the moral debate that raged over the interrogation program during the Bush years, the film also seems to accept almost without question that the CIA's 'enhanced interrogation techniques' played a key role in enabling the agency to identify the courier who unwittingly led them to bin Laden.
Author Greg Mitchell wrote that "the film's depiction of torture helping to get bin Laden is muddled at best but the overall impression by the end, for most viewers, probably will be: Yes, torture played an important (if not the key) role." Filmmaker Alex Gibney called the film a "stylistic masterwork" but criticized the "irresponsible and inaccurate" depiction of torture, writing:
there is no cinematic evidence in the film that EITs led to false informationlies that were swallowed whole because of the misplaced confidence in the efficacy of torture. Most students of this subject admit that torture can lead to the truth. But what Boal/Bigelow fail to show is how often the CIA deluded itself into believing that torture was a magic bullet, with disastrous results.
Philosopher Slavoj iek, in an article for 'The Guardian', criticized what he perceived as a "normalization" of torture in the film, arguing that the mere neutrality on an issue many see as revolting is already a type of endorsement 'per se'. iek proposed that if a similar film were made about a brutal rape or the Holocaust, such a movie would "embody a deeply immoral fascination with its topic, or it would count on the obscene neutrality of its style to engender dismay and horror in spectators." iek further panned Bigelow's stance of coldly presenting the issue in a rational manner, instead of being dogmatically rejected as a repulsive, unethical proposition.
Journalist Steve Coll, who has written on foreign policy, national security and the bin Laden family, criticized the filmmakers for saying the film was "journalistic", which implies that it is based in fact. At the same time, they claimed artistic license, which he described "as an excuse for shoddy reporting about a subject as important as whether torture had a vital part in the search for bin Laden". Coll wrote that "arguably, the film's degree of emphasis on torture's significance goes beyond what even the most die-hard defenders of the CIA interrogation regime ... have argued", as he said it was shown as critical at several points.
U.S. Senator John McCain, who was tortured during his time as a prisoner of war in North Vietnam, said that the film left him sick "because it's wrong". In a speech in the Senate, he said, "Not only did the use of enhanced interrogation techniques on Khalid Sheikh Mohammed not provide us with key leads on bin Laden's courier, Abu Ahmed, it actually produced false and misleading information." McCain and fellow senators Dianne Feinstein and Carl Levin sent a critical letter to Michael Lynton, chairman of the film's distributor, Sony Pictures Entertainment, stating, "[W]ith the release of 'Zero Dark Thirty', the filmmakers and your production studio are perpetuating the myth that torture is effective. You have a social and moral obligation to get the facts right."
Michael Morell, the CIA's acting director, sent a public letter on December 21, 2012, to the agency's employees, which said that 'Zero Dark Thirty'
takes significant artistic license, while portraying itself as being historically accurate ... [The film] creates the strong impression that the enhanced interrogation techniques that were part of our former detention and interrogation program were the key to finding . That impression is false. ... [T]he truth is that multiple streams of intelligence led CIA analysts to conclude that was hiding in Abbottabad. Some came from detainees subjected to enhanced techniques, but there were many other sources as well. And, importantly, whether enhanced interrogation techniques were the only timely and effective way to obtain information from those detainees, as the film suggests, is a matter of debate that cannot and never will be definitively resolved.
'The Huffington Post' writer G. Roger Denson countered this, saying that the filmmakers were being made scapegoats for information openly admitted by government and intelligence officials. Denson said that Leon Panetta, three days after Osama bin Laden's death, seemed to say that waterboarding was a means of extracting reliable and crucial information in the hunt for bin Laden. Denson noted Panetta speaking as the CIA chief in May 2011, saying that "enhanced interrogation techniques were used to extract information that led to the mission's success". Panetta said waterboarding was among the techniques used. In a 'Huffington Post' article written a week later, Denson cited other statements from Bush government officials saying that torture had yielded information to locate bin Laden.
National security reporter Spencer Ackerman said the film "does not present torture as a silver bullet that led to bin Laden; it presents torture as the ignorant alternative to that silver bullet". Critic Glenn Kenny said that he "saw a movie that subverted a lot of expectations concerning viewer identification and empathy" and that "rather than endorsing the barbarity, the picture makes the viewer in a sense complicit with it", which is "[a] whole other can of worms". Writer Andrew Sullivan said, "the movie is not an apology for torture, as so many have said, and as I have worried about. It is an 'exposure' of torture. It removes any doubt that war criminals ran this country for seven years". Filmmaker Michael Moore similarly said, "I left the movie thinking it made an incredible statement against torture", and noted that the film showed the abject brutality of torture.[https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/25/michael-moore-zero-dark-thirty-torture_n_2552123.html Michael Moore On 'Zero Dark Thirty' & Torture: Movie Doesn't Condone Enhanced Interrogation] ; Huffington Post; January 25, 2013. Critic Andrew O'Hehir said that the filmmaker's position on torture in the film is ambiguous, and creative choices were made and the film poses "excellent questions for us to ask ourselves, arguably defining questions of the age, and I think the longer you look at them the thornier they get".
Screenwriter Boal described the pro-torture accusations as "preposterous", stating that "it's just misreading the film to say that it shows torture leading to the information about bin Laden", while director Bigelow added: "Do I wish [torture] was not part of that history? Yes. But it was." In February 2013 in 'The Wall Street Journal', Boal responded to the Senate critics, being quoted as saying "[D]oes that mean they can use the movie as a political platform to talk about what they've been wanting to talk about for years and years and years? Do I think that Feinstein used the movie as a publicity tool to get a conversation going about her report? I believe it, ..." referring to the intelligence committee's report on enhanced interrogations. He also said the senators' letter showed they were still concerned about public opinion supporting the effectiveness of torture and didn't want the movie reinforcing that. Boal said, though, "I don't think that [effectiveness] issue has really been resolved" if there is a suspect with possible knowledge of imminent attack who will not talk.Kaminsky, Matthew, [https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887324162304578306292338216514?mod=WSJ_hpp_sections_opinion "The Art and Politics of 'Zero Dark Thirty'"] , 'The Wall Street Journal', February 15, 2013. Retrieved February 18, 2013.
In an interview with 'Time' magazine, Bigelow said: "I'm proud of the movie, and I stand behind it completely. I think that it's a deeply moral movie that questions the use of force. It questions what was done in the name of finding bin Laden."
Objections over the use of recordings of 9/11 victims
An extensive clip of the phone call to headquarters from Betty Ong, a flight attendant on one of the hijacked American Airlines planes, was used in the beginning of the film without attribution. Ong's family requested that, if the film won any awards, the filmmakers apologize at the Academy Awards ceremony for using the clip without getting her heirs' consent. Her family also asked that the film's U.S. distributors make a charitable donation in Ong's name, and should go on record that the Ong family does not endorse the use of torture, which is depicted in the film during the search for Osama bin Laden. Neither the filmmakers nor the U.S. distributors ever heeded any of the Ong family's requests.Mary and Frank Fetchet, parents of Brad Fetchet, who worked on the 89th floor of the World Trade Center's south tower, criticized the filmmakers for using a recording of their son's voicemail without permission. The recording has previously been heard in broadcast TV news reports and in testimony for the 9/11 Commission.
See also
* List of films featuring the United States Navy SEALs
* Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden
* 'No Easy Day: The Firsthand Account of the Mission that Killed Osama bin Laden'
Notes
References
Further reading
* "[http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1302/24/fzgps.01.html FAREED ZAKARIA GPS The Myth of America's Social Mobility; How Accurate is 'Zero Dark Thirty'?; Interview with Neil deGrasse Tyson; Internal Iranian Politics]." (transcript) CNN. February 24, 2013
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20121231034901/http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/12/28/why-zero-dark-thirty-divides-the-media-in-half Why Zero Dark Thirty divides the media in half] (December 18, 2012), Alissa Quart, 'Reuters.' "The thriller 'Zero Dark Thirty' exposed a wide gap between film critics and their counterparts in politics."
*
Buy Zero Dark Thirty now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2012