Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2011
Tomboy (2011 film)
Buy Tomboy (2011 film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Tomboy' is a 2011 French drama film written and directed by Cline Sciamma. The story follows a 10-year-old gender non-conforming girl, Laure, who moves to a new neighborhood during the summer holiday and experiments with her gender presentation, adopting the name Mickal. The film opened to positive reviews, with critics praising the directing and the performers, particularly Zo Hran as the lead.
'Tomboy' was released on DVD-Video and Blu-ray in the United Kingdom on 5 March 2012, and in the United States on 5 June 2012.
Plot
Laure is a 10-year-old whose family moves to a new address in Paris. Laure sees a group of boys playing outside the window and goes to play with them, but they disappear quickly. Instead, Laure meets Lisa, a neighborhood girl. Lisa assumes that Laure is a boy and asks for Laure's name. After a moment's thought, Laure comes up with the male name "Mickal". Lisa then introduces Mickal/Laure to the rest of the neighborhood children, stating that Mickal is the new kid in the apartment complex. Mickal becomes friends with Lisa and the boys, playing soccer with them. When invited to go swimming, Mickal cuts a one-piece swimsuit into male swim briefs, and makes a clay penis to put inside.
Over time, Lisa and Mickal become closer, and Lisa eventually kisses Mickal. Mickal also becomes increasingly accepted by the group of boys. One day while playing, Lisa makes up Mickal's face and comments: "You look good as a girl." Mickal goes home hiding her face under a hoodie, but Laure's mother says she likes it, encouraging her to be more like a girl.
When Lisa comes by the apartment to look for Mickal, she runs into Laure's precocious six-year-old sister Jeanne instead. The conversation makes Jeanne realize that Laure has been presenting as a boy. Jeanne confronts Laure and wants to tell their parents, but when Laure promises to take her along on all of Laure's outings for the rest of the summer, she quickly becomes happy to have a big brother, which she says is "way better" than having a big sister. She also helps cut Mickal's hair to be more boyish, and promises to keep Mickal's secret.
After Mickal has a fight with one of the boys for pushing Jeanne, the boy and his mother come to Mickal's door to tell Mickal's mother about her son's bad behavior. Laure's mother is quick to understand and plays along, but after the visitors have left, she scolds Laure for "pretending to be a boy". Jeanne understands Laure's predicament and does her best to support her sibling emotionally. Laure's mother forces Laure to wear a dress and takes Laure to the apartment of the boy that Laure hit, and also to Lisa's apartment. Lisa is stunned to see Mickal in a dress and runs off without a word.
Deeply embarrassed, Laure goes to the woods. After a time there, Laure takes off the blue dress, leaving on a tank top and boy-style shorts. Walking away from the discarded dress, Mickal sees the other children in the distance. Mickal can hear them talking, speculating about whether Mickal is a girl or not. When they spot Mickal, the boys chase and capture Mickal and say they're going to see if Mickal's really a girl. Lisa stands up to them and tells them to leave Mickal alone. But when they tell Lisa: "You kissed him. If it's a girl, that's disgusting, isn't it?" Lisa agrees and reluctantly looks in Mickal's shorts, with Mickal in tears but letting her. Lisa is shocked. The boys and Lisa leave while Mickal remains in the woods, devastated.
Later, it is seen that Laure's mother has given birth to a baby boy. The family spend time together at home, with Laure not wanting to go outside. However, Laure sees Lisa waiting outside the window, and goes out to see her. After a long silence, Lisa quietly asks for Laure's name. "My name is Laure", Laure responds, and smiles a little.
Cast
*Zo Hran as Laure/Mickal
*Malonn Lvana as Jeanne, Laure's sister
*Jeanne Disson as Lisa
*Sophie Cattani as Laure's mother
*Mathieu Demy as Laure's father
Interpretations
The film has been described as being about a girl who pretends to be a boy or, alternatively, about a transgender boy. Film critic Roger Ebert said "If you think you're looking at a boy, you see one. If a girl, then that's what you see."
Cline Sciamma, the writer and director, said "I made it with several layers, so that a transexual person can say 'that was my childhood' and so that a heterosexual woman can also say it." She also said the "movie is ambiguous about Mickal's feelings for Lisa. It plays with the confusion."
The scene of the nakedness of Laure and the revelation resulting from it, is pivotal and Zo Hran knew from the script that she would have to shoot naked. Her parents were present at the time of filming and this intense moment could only exist in the image with their consent in view of the filmed sequence.
Reception
'Tomboy' earned positive reviews. Earning 96% certified fresh on Rotten Tomatoes with a consensus saying, "In tune with the emotion and tribulations of childhood, 'Tomboy' is a charming movie that treats its main subject with warmth and heart." Roger Ebert of the 'Chicago Sun-Times' gave 3.5 out of 4 stars, commenting that 'Tomboy' is "tender and affectionate". In 2017, it was ranked by IndieWire as "the third best lesbian movie of all time". Autostraddle called it "excellent".
Awards
*Jury Award at the 2011 Teddy Awards, given for the best film with LGBT themes at the Berlin film festival.*Golden Duke, the main prize of the official competition of the 2011 Odessa International Film Festival.
*Audience Award at the 2011 San Francisco Frameline Gay & Lesbian Film Festival.
*Best Feature Film at the 2011 Philadelphia QFest Lesbian and Gay Film Festival.
*Competition at the 2011 Torino Lesbian and Gay Film Festival.
*Nominated for the GLAAD Media Award as Outstanding Film Limited Release.
*Hran won the Jury Award for Best Performance at the 2011 NewFest Film Festival.
*Hran was nominated for the Young Artist Award as Best Leading Young Performer in an International Feature Film.
*Prix Jacques Prvert du Scnario for Best Original Screenplay in 2012
See also
* '3 Generations' (2015)
* 'Ma vie en rose' (1997)
* List of LGBT films directed by women
* Childhood gender nonconformity
* Tomboy
References
Buy Tomboy (2011 film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2011