Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2005
Battle in Heaven
Buy Battle in Heaven now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Battle in Heaven' is a 2005 Mexican-French-German film. It is the second feature film by director Carlos Reygadas who previously directed the Mexican film 'Japn'. It was entered into the 2005 Cannes Film Festival. Reygadas has said about this film: "its my problem child, and therefore the film of mine I love the most."
Plot
Marcos (Marcos Hernndez) is a working class man in Mexico, employed by "the general." Marcos learns that the baby that he and his wife kidnapped for ransom had accidentally died. The remainder of the film follows a despondent Marcos, seemingly haunted by the moral and/or legal implications of his actions.
Marcos stands next to his wife Berta (Berta Ruiz) at the subway as she sells clocks and sweets at a stand. He travels to the airport to meet the "general's" upper-middle class daughter, Ana (Anapola Mushkadiz) whom he has known since she was a child. Ana orders Marcos to take her to the "boutique" where she works in the sex trade. While driving, Marcos is very distracted, and at one point stalls the car. Ana recognizes that something is wrong, but Marcos claims he's distracted only because of his wife's supposed ill health.
Ana invites Marcos into the "boutique" so that he can have sex with one of her "friends." Marcos is apparently not aroused by the "friend." The friend tells Ana that Marcos would prefer her instead. Ana goes to talk to Marcos, and reminds him that they have known each other since her childhood. Marcos then reveals that he and his wife kidnapped a baby but the baby died before they could collect any ransom. Ana seems to remain composed at hearing this news.
Back home, Marcos has sex with his wife, Berta. They seem united in their sorrow regarding the dead baby. Marcos tells Berta that he told Ana about the kidnapped baby, indicating that the confession brought him relief. Berta, upset, demands that he make sure that "the princess" does not tell anyone. The next day, Marcos visits Ana. She seems annoyed by his visit, but drives him to her place where they have sex. Ana advises Marcos to turn himself in to the police.
Marcos, Berta, their son, and a few friends (including the mother of the dead baby, who does not know who took her child, nor that it has died) go out to the countryside. Marcos tells Berta that he is going to turn himself in. She asks him to wait until after the pilgrimage (which is in honor of the Lady of Guadalupe), an event that Marcos had earlier shown disdain for. Marcos seems to agree with his wife. Marcos' mental state seems to worsen. Instead of driving back with his party, he treks through the countryside. He reaches a peak with Christian crosses, overlooking a valley. Marcos buries his face in his hands.
Marcos visits Ana at her home. He tells her that he will turn himself into the police that day. She gives him a goodbye kiss. Marcos leaves the apartment. He pees his pants, goes back to the apartment and fatally stabs Ana.
The police become aware of both the attack on Ana and the death of the baby, and are in search for Marcos. Marcos seems to have joined the pilgrimage to the Basilica, at first on foot, and then on his knees. Someone places a hood over his face, but Marcos continues to hobble forward. The hood becomes increasingly stained with blood as he makes his way into the Basilica during the church service.
Eventually the pilgrims are gone, and the Basilica is vacant. The police allow Berta to go in to see her husband. She touches him on the head and he collapses.
Cast
* Marcos Hernndez - Marcos
* Anapola Mushkadiz - Ana
* Bertha Ruiz - Marcos' Wife
* David Bornstein - Jaime
* Rosalinda Ramirez - Viky
* El Abuelo - Chief of Police
* Brenda Angulo - Madame
* El Mago - Preacher
* Francisco 'El Gato' Martnez - Gas Station Attendant
* Diego Martnez Vignatti - Soccer Player
* Alejandro Mayar - Police Inspector
* Chavo Nava - Neurotic Conductor
* Estela Tamariz - Ines
Production
Like Robert Bresson, Reygadas prefers to use non-professional actors,Jason Wood, "Carlos Reygadas" in 'Talking movies: contemporary world filmmakers in interview' London : Wallflower Press (2006) p. 189 while occasionally recycling one (Hernndez had a small part as a chauffeur in 'Japn'). Unlike Bresson, Reygadas puts explicit sex scenes in his films. The sex scene between Hernndez and Ruiz was simulated at Ruiz's husband's request, according to Reygadas on an interview included on the DVD.
Casually, in a scene when Marcos is masturbating in front of the TV screen, he's watching a football league match between Pachuca CF and Atlante F.C., valid for the Primera Divisin de Mxico Apertura 2003, which ended with a draw & no goals scored.
Anapola Mushkadiz said that a prosthetic penis was used in the fellatio scenes with Marcos Hernndez.
Critical reception
Jonathan Romney says that "To a degree, Battle in Heaven might seem like another warmed-over example of a familiar movie myth: a fairly repellent no-hoper redeemed by hot sex with a quasi-virginal prostitute," but that "it's finally hard to know whether Reygadas takes his transcendental, religious theme seriously, or is deriding it outright - or even deriding us for taking it seriously."Jonathan Romney, "[https://web.archive.org/web/20090912031041/http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/films/reviews/battle-in-heaven-18-512918.html Battle in Heaven (18)]" 'The Independent' Sunday, 30 October 2005
Lisa Schwarzbaum gives the film a grade of D+. "Between those two attention grabbers on a theme of flagpoles, languorously performed and indifferently observed, Mexican filmmaker/provocateur Carlos Reygadas pitches his own fight for the aesthetic tolerances of viewers, goading us to react to images about which he himself studiously offers no opinion." Schwarzbaum finds that "for all the 'shock' of the movie's clinical carnality, this battle is lost."Lisa Schwarzbaum, "[http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,1159767,00.html Movie Review: Battle in Heaven (2006)]" 'Entertainment Weekly' Posted Feb 15, 2006
'Battle in Heaven' was later voted one of the 30 best films of its decade in a poll for 'Sight & Sound'. It was also ranked by Michael Atkinson of 'The Village Voice' as the fifth greatest film since 2000 in BBC's 2016 poll.
Awards
* Rio de Janeiro International Film Festival, FIPRESCI Prize
References
Buy Battle in Heaven now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2005