Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2000
In the Light of the Moon
Buy In the Light of the Moon now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'In the Light of the Moon' (also known as 'Ed Gein') is a 2000 horror film directed by Chuck Parello, and written by Stephen Johnston. It is based on the crimes of Ed Gein, an American murderer who killed at least two women in Plainfield, Wisconsin during the 1950s. It stars Steve Railsback as Gein, and Carrie Snodgress as Gein's domineering, fundamentalist mother, Augusta.
Plot
Growing up on a farm in rural Wisconsin, Ed Gein is abused by both his Christian fundamentalist mother, Augusta, and his alcoholic father, George. George dies of a heart attack in 1940, and four years later, Ed kills his older brother, Henry, in a fit of rage after Henry insults Augusta. Ed makes it look like Henry died in a brush fire, and lives alone with Augusta until she dies of a stroke in 1945. Ed becomes depressed after his mother's death, and lets the family farm become squalid and dilapidated, with the exception of Augusta's room, which is sealed off by Ed.
Living off of agricultural subsidies and the money that he makes from leasing land and babysitting children, the increasingly unstable Ed spends his plentiful free time making nightly excursions to the Plainfield Cemetery. Ed digs up recently deceased elderly women, who he makes futile attempts at reviving before decorating his home with pieces of them, at one point passing "shrunken heads" off as gifts from a cousin in the Philippines. The townspeople regard Ed as nothing more than a harmless eccentric with a morbid sense of humor, and an unusual interest in graphic literature about crime, headhunting cannibal tribes, and Nazism.
Ed begins suffering from hallucinations of Augusta, who commands him to kill "sinful" women, starting with a tavern owner named Mary Hogan. Ed shoots Mary and takes her to his farm, where he leaves her bound to a bed until she dies, at which point Ed butchers her body, consuming some of it, and using the rest to add to his crudely-designed "woman suit." Ed's delusions worsen, and he becomes convinced that Mary's death has resurrected Augusta, who implores Ed to kill a hardware store owner named Collette Marshall. Ed shoots Collette and brings her body back to his farm before having dinner with the Andersons, a neighboring family who he surprises with "Venison steaks."
Colette's employee, Brian, returns from a hunting trip to find the unmanned store full of blood, and calls 911. Having always disliked Ed, Brian suspects him of being involved in Mary and Collette's disappearances, and races to Ed's farm, followed by Sheriff Jim Stillwell. After finding Collette's decapitated and "dressed out" body hanging in Ed's barn, an enraged Brian tracks Ed down to the Anderson residence, but is talked out of shooting Ed by Sheriff Stillwell, who arrests Ed.
The film ends with a nonlinear montage that consists of the police uncovering evidence in Ed's home, interviews with Ed after he was diagnosed as schizophrenic and placed in a psychiatric hospital, and scenes in which Ed tries to keep his urges in check through prayer and rituals, and others in which he exhumes corpses, only to rebury them after snapping out of a Fugue state. An intertitle states that Ed was buried next to his mother after dying of respiratory failure in 1984.
Cast
Release
'Ed Gein' premiered in America, in a single theater in Los Angeles, on May 4, 2001. On its opening weekend, the film grossed $5,708, and by May 11 had grossed $11,821.
Home media
'Ed Gein' was released on VHS by Millennium on July 24, 2001. That same year, the film was released on DVD by both First Look Home Entertainment on June 24 and Tartan Video on November 29. On April 22, 2003 it was re-released by First Look as part of a three-disk box set which included 'Dahmer' and 'Ted Bundy'. That same day, it was released as a single-feature by Velocity Home Entertainment. It was last released in 2005 by both Prism and First Look on February 14 and August 26, respectively.
Reception
On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 10% based on , with a weighted average rating of 4.1/10.
Ain't It Cool News praised Steve Railsback's performance as Gein, and concluded, "'Ed Gein' is not must-see but it's a lot better than I thought it would be. I would recommend a rental to the curious horror or true crime fans out there looking for something sort of along the lines of 'Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer', but tamer, but at the same time a lot sicker." 'Time Out' found the film to be "a surprisingly sober response to a potentially salacious subject" and wrote, "As with the best scenes of 'Deranged', the conjunction of colourful case history, odd impulses, gallows humour, low budget austerity and genuinely grotesque iconography produces a felicitous and engaging variant of American Gothic."
In a review written for AllMovie, Richard Gilliam commended the film's historical accuracy, production design, and "low-key" approach to its source material, but also found it to be lacking in style, writing, "The problem with the authenticity here is that the filmmakers have managed to authentically capture the dull, boring parts of life in 1950s rural Wisconsin. 'Ed Gein' is so under-the-top that what should be compelling merely becomes unpleasant." Nathan Rabin of 'The A.V. Club' had a lukewarm response to the film, writing, "Half character study, half exploitation film, 'Ed Gein' is most effective when it focuses on Gein's halting attempts to connect with his neighbors, who treat him with the polite but decided distance of an adult dealing with a misbehaving but well-intentioned child. Where the film falters is in its attempts to explain away Gein's madness with a massive dose of pop psychology."
While 'The Guardian's' Philip French offered praise to Railsback's performance as Gein, he found the film itself to be "a generally unsensational chunk of bizarre Americana" that "adds little to our understanding of the man." Fellow 'Guardian' reviewer Peter Bradshaw had a similar response to the film, writing, "Really, it's the same old pulpy, paranoid voyeuristic stuff, and Ed's fear and hatred of women is never that edifying. It's well acted, and effectively put together, but there is an insurmountable problem: gloomy, grave-robbing, body-chopping old Ed is, in the end, just a little bit of a bore." Kevin Thomas of the 'Los Angeles Times' afforded the film moderate praise, commending the performances, the atmosphere, and the historical accuracy, but went on to write, "'Ed Gein' resists cheap humor in favor of moments that are inherently darkly comic, and tries for a seriousness of purpose, yet is at times awkward and under-inspired, creating a question as to whether so gloomy and repugnant a tale was worth telling simply for its own sake."
Neil Smith of the BBC called the film "gross and repellent" and awarded it a score of 2/5, writing, "Parello's stated intention is to explore the psychology of his twisted protagonist, but the result has all the hallmarks of a low-budget exploitationer, right down to its B movie leads Steve Railsback and Carrie Snodgress. Would it be too much to expect some thought or consideration for Gein's victims? Evidently so, given Hollywood's depressing habit of turning serial killers into cult heroes." 'Variety's' Robert Koehler gave 'Ed Gein' a wholly negative review, deriding it for being both lackluster and "a disappointingly mild re-creation of true events."
Chuck Parello and Steve Railsback won Best Film and Best Actor, respectively, at the 2000 Sitges Film Festival.
See also
* 'The Hillside Strangler', another true crime film directed by Chuck Parello and written by Stephen Johnston
References
Buy In the Light of the Moon now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2000