Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1998


Talk of Angels

Buy Talk of Angels now from Amazon

First, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.

Wikipedia article




'Talk of Angels' is a film directed in 1996 by Nick Hamm, but not released by its production company, Miramax, until 1998.

Based on the 1936 novel 'Mary Lavelle' by Kate O'Brien, which was banned in Ireland when first published, with a script co-written by Ann Guedes and Frank McGuinness, 'Talk Of Angels' tells the story of a young Irish governess who travels to Spain in the mid-1930s to teach English to the young daughters of a prominent family. Over the course of the film, she becomes drawn to the family's married eldest son, and their affair unfolds with the increasing violence associated with the early days of the Spanish Civil War as a backdrop.

Cast



* Polly Walker Mary Lavelle

* Vincent Perez Francisco Areavaga

* Franco Nero Dr. Vicente Areavaga

* Marisa Paredes Doa Consuelo

* Leire Berrocal Milagros

* Penlope Cruz Pilar

* Frances McDormand Conlon

* Ruth McCabe O'Toole

* Francisco Rabal Don Jorge

* Ariadna Gil Beatriz

* Rossy de Palma Elena

* Britta Smith Duggan

* Anita Reeves Harty

* Veronica Duffy Keogh

* Jorge de Juan Jaime

* Ellea Ratier Leonor

* Angelina Llongueras Ana

* Jaume Valls Pablo

* Jose Sacristan Carlos

* Oscar Higares Matador

* Tusse Silberg Aunt Cristina

* Jose Manuel Ortigosa Singing Boy

Reception



The film received mostly unfavorable comparisons to 'Casablanca', 'Dr. Zhivago', 'The Garden of the Finzi-Continis,' 'Jane Eyre', 'Gone With the Wind', and 'The Leopard'.

'Entertainment Weekly' described it as "Casablanca-derived" but called the main characters "blandly pretty" and "pretty bland".

The 'LA Times' argued that "Walker remains the primary distraction" and that "the sum, as they all too often say, is not quite that of the parts. And "Talk of Angels" unfortunately exists in that romance-novel realm in which political concerns are mere adornments for the treacle-dripping issues of the heart."

'The New York Times' noted that "'Talk of Angels' is the third and weakest movie to be released this year in which the central character is a beautiful, charming, clever, wise young governess who becomes romantically entangled with someone in her employer's family," and complained that it was "so badly butchered in the cutting room that crucial dramatic confrontations are strangely missing."

'Variety' said in its review that "As the would-be lovers, Walker and Perez are individually charismatic and undeniably attractive, but together they generate about as much heat as Lake Placid in February", continuing that "'Talk of Angels' doesn't use the politics of war to create tension between the lovers; it's as if the war were irrelevant to their personal drama."

The 'New York Daily News' was favorable, calling it "a romantic, intelligent Jane Eyre-like story" and said that "director Nick Hamm makes a worthy feature debut, backed by a solid cast."

'Boxoffice' wrote that it "is an undeniably beautiful and often seductive tale of colliding cultural sensibilities and ferocious passions" but that "the passions depicted on-screen are fairly tepid ones, playing more like a dime novel than the meaningful epic the filmmakers intended."

'Film4's summary was that it was "elevated above the ordinary by strong performances and a vivacious feel".

References




Buy Talk of Angels now from Amazon

<-- Return to movies from 1998



This work is released under CC-BY-SA. Some or all of this content attributed to http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1107198422.