Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1997
Comedian Harmonists (film)
Buy Comedian Harmonists (film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Comedian Harmonists' (English title: 'The Harmonists') is a 1997 German film, directed by Joseph Vilsmaier, about the popular German vocal group the Comedian Harmonists of the 1920s and 1930s. The film was supported by the German and Austrian film fund.
Plot
In 1927, unemployed German-Jewish actor Harry Frommermann is inspired by the American group The Revelers to create a German group of the same format. He holds auditions and signs on four additional singers and a pianist. Naming themselves the "Comedian Harmonists", they meet international fame and popularity. However, they eventually run into trouble when the Nazis come to power, as half the group is Jewish.
Cast
* Ben Becker as Robert Biberti
* Heino Ferch as Roman Cycowski
* Ulrich Noethen as Harry Frommermann
* Heinrich Schafmeister as Erich A. Collin
* Max Tidof as Ari Leschnikoff
* Kai Wiesinger as Erwin Bootz
* Meret Becker as Erna Eggstein
* Katja Riemann as Mary Cycowski
* Noemi Fischer as Chantal, Collin's girl friend
* Dana Vvrov as Ursula Bootz
* Otto Sander as Bruno Levy
* Michaela Rosen as Ramona, brothel madame
* Gnter Lamprecht as Erik Charell
* Grard Samaan as Roman's father
* Rolf Hoppe as Gauleiter Streicher
* Jrgen Schornagel as Reichsmusikdirektor
* Rudolf Wessely as Mr. Grnbaum
* Susi Nicoletti as Mrs. Grnbaum
* Giora Feidman as clarinet player
* Kathie Lindner as wardrobe mistress
* Trude Ackermann as Robert's mother
Reception
'Comedian Harmonists' succeeded in Europe and was the highest-grossing German film of 1998 with a gross of over $16 million. U.S. President Bill Clinton told critic Roger Ebert it was among his favorite films of the year, although the movie did not get widespread release, hence reception in the United States.
Bernd Reinhardt of the World Socialist Web Site called it "an exciting film which is well worth seeing and which pays proper attention to the sextet's music." He also remarked on the film's attention to historical detail and the importance of its theme of musical internationalism.
Awards and nominations
At the 1998 German Film Awards, 'Comedian Harmonists' won the awards for Best Fiction Film, Best Editing (for Peter R. Adam), Best Actor (for Ulrich Noethen), Best Supporting Actress (for Meret Becker), and Best Production Design (for Rolf Zehetbauer). Joseph Vilsmaier was nominated for Best Direction, losing to Wim Wenders for 'The End of Violence'.
At the 1998 Bavarian Film Awards Joseph Vilsmaier won the awards for Best Director. Ben Becker, Heino Ferch, Ulrich Noethen, Heinrich Schafmeister, Max Tidof and Kai Wiesinger won a Special Prize
Vilsmaier was nominated for Best Cinematographer for 'Comedian Harmonists' at the 1998 European Film Awards.
American version
The U.S. Miramax release contains at least one difference from the original: in the original, there is a scene, when the Harmonists arrive in New York and perform in front of the U.S. Navy, where the camera singles out one African American navy man who is visibly enjoying the music, until he gets a stinging look of rebuke from a superior officer. This segment was cut from the American release.
Legacy
The film led to the writing of a musical play, 'Veronika, der Lenz ist da Die Comedian Harmonists', which opened at the 'Komdie' on the Kurfrstendamm in Berlin on 19 December 1997. When this production closed, the actors who had played the original sextet formed themselves into a new group called the Berlin Comedian Harmonists,[http://prairiehome.publicradio.org/features/hodgepodge/20010300_europe/guests_berlin.html Guests for March 3, 2001 (Berlin)] at prairiehome.publicradio.org, accessed 4 February 2012 which is still in existence in 2021.
Notes
Buy Comedian Harmonists (film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1997