Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1988
Rattle and Hum
Buy Rattle and Hum now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Rattle and Hum' is a hybrid live/studio album by Irish rock band U2, and a companion rockumentary film directed by Phil Joanou. The album was produced by Jimmy Iovine and was released on 10 October 1988, while the film was distributed by Paramount Pictures and was released on 27 October 1988. Following the breakthrough success of the band's previous studio album, 'The Joshua Tree', the 'Rattle and Hum' project captures their continued experiences with American roots music on the Joshua Tree Tour, further incorporating elements of blues rock, folk rock, and gospel music into their sound. A collection of new studio tracks, live performances, and cover songs, the project includes recordings at Sun Studio in Memphis and collaborations with Bob Dylan, B.B. King, and Harlem's New Voices of Freedom gospel choir.
Although 'Rattle and Hum' was intended to represent the band paying tribute to rock legends, some critics accused U2 of trying to place themselves amongst the ranks of these artists. Critical reception to both the album and the film was mixed; one 'Rolling Stone' editor spoke of the album's "excitement", another described it as "misguided and bombastic". The film grossed just $8.6 million, but the album was a commercial success, reaching number one in several countries and selling 14 million copies. The lead single "Desire" became the band's first UK number-one song while reaching number three in the US.McGee (2008), p. 119 Facing creative stagnation and a critical backlash to 'Rattle and Hum', U2 reinvented themselves in the 1990s through a new musical direction and public image.
History
While in Hartford during the 1987 The Joshua Tree Tour, U2 met film director Phil Joanou who made an unsolicited pitch to the band to make a feature-length documentary about the tour. Joanou suggested they hire Martin Scorsese, Jonathan Demme, or George Miller to direct the film. Joanou met the band again in Dublin to discuss the plans and again in France in September before the band chose him as director. The movie was originally titled 'U2 in the Americas' and the band planned to film in Chicago and Buenos Aires later in the year.McGee (2008), pp. 105, 109 It was later decided that the Chicago venue was not suitable, and instead U2 used the McNichols Sports Arena in Denver to film. Following the success of 'Live at Red Rocks: Under a Blood Red Sky', which had been filmed in Denver four years earlier, the band hoped that "lightning might strike twice". With production problems and estimated costs of $1.2 million the band cancelled the plans for December concerts in South America. At the suggestions of concert promoter Barry Fey, the band instead booked Sun Devil Stadium at Arizona State University in Tempe, Arizona, the same city where the Joshua Tree tour began.McGee (2008), p. 112
The movie is a rockumentary, which was initially financed by the band and intended to be screened in a small number of cinemas as an independent film. After going over budget, the film was bought by Paramount Pictures and released in theatres in 1988, before arriving on video in 1989. It was produced by Michael Hamlyn and directed by Joanou. Paul Wasserman served as the publicist. It incorporates live footage with studio outtakes and band interviews. The album is a mix of live material and new studio recordings that furthers the band's experimentation with American music styles and recognises many of their musical influences. It was produced by Jimmy Iovine and also released in 1988.
The title, 'Rattle and Hum', is taken from a lyric from "Bullet the Blue Sky", the fourth track on 'The Joshua Tree'. The image used for the album cover and movie poster, depicting Bono shining a spotlight on Edge as he plays, was inspired by a scene in the live performance of "Bullet the Blue Sky" recorded in the film and album, but was recreated in a stills studio and photographed by Anton Corbijn.Scrimgeour (2004), p. 273 Several vinyl copies have the message "We Love You A.L.K." etched into side one, a reference to the band's production manager Anne Louise Kelly, who would be the subject of another secret dedication message on several CD copies of the band's later album, 'Pop'.
Studio recordings
Bono said "Hawkmoon 269" was in part as a tribute to writer Sam Shepard, who had released a book entitled 'Hawk Moon'. Bono also said that the band mixed the song 269 times. This was thought to be a joke for years until it was confirmed by guitarist the Edge in 'U2 by U2', who said that they spent three weeks mixing the song. He also contradicted Bono's assertion about Shepard, saying that Hawkmoon is a place in Rapid City, South Dakota, in the midwestern United States.McCormick (2006), p. 203
"Angel of Harlem" is a horn-filled tribute to Billie Holiday. The bass-heavy "God Part II" is a sequel of sorts to John Lennon's "God".
The lead single, "Desire", sports a Bo Diddley beat. During the Joshua Tree tour, in mid-November 1987, Bono and Bob Dylan met in Los Angeles; together they wrote a song called "Prisoner of Love" which later became "Love Rescue Me". Dylan sang lead vocals on the original recording, a version which Bono called "astonishing", but Dylan later asked U2 not to use it citing commitments to The Traveling Wilburys.McGee (2008), p. 114 The live performance of "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" (recorded with a full church choir) is a gospel song. "When Love Comes to Town" is a blues rocker featuring B.B. King on guitar and vocals.
U2 recorded "Angel of Harlem", "Love Rescue Me" and "When Love Comes to Town" at Sun Studio in Memphis, Tennessee, where Elvis Presley, Roy Orbison, Johnny Cash and many others also recorded. They also recorded an unreleased version of "She's a Mystery to Me" and Woody Guthrie's "Jesus Christ", which appeared on 'Folkways: A Vision Shared'. The band started writing "Heartland", in 1984 during 'The Unforgettable Fire' sessions, and it was worked on during 'The Joshua Tree' sessions.McGee (2008), p. 93 All of the studio tracks apart from "Heartland" were performed in concert on the Lovetown Tour, which began almost a year after 'Rattle and Hum's release.
In addition to the nine studio tracks that comprised one half of the double album, a number of additional recordings from the 'Rattle and Hum' sessions would be released on various singles and side projects. "Hallelujah Here She Comes" was released as a B-side to "Desire", and "A Room at the Heartbreak Hotel" was released as a B-side to "Angel of Harlem." Covers were released as B-sides for the rest of the singlesan abbreviated cover of Patti Smith's "Dancing Barefoot" would be released as a B-side to "When Love Comes to Town" (the full version would see release on the 12" version of the single and on CD on the 1994 soundtrack album to 'Threesome'), while "Unchained Melody" and "Everlasting Love" would be released as the B-sides to "All I Want Is You." A cover of "Fortunate Son" recorded with Maria McKee would not be released until 1992's "Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses" single; a version of the soul classic "Everybody Loves a Winner" by William Bell, also recorded with McKee, would eventually be released on the 20th anniversary edition of 'Achtung Baby'.
Studio versions of "She's a Mystery to Me" (a Bono/Edge composition that would eventually be recorded and released by Roy Orbison), Bruce Cockburn's "If I Had a Rocket Launcher", Percy Sledge's "Warm and Tender Love", and "Can't Help Falling in Love With You", while recorded, have yet to be released. (A solo Bono cover of the Elvis Presley classic would be released on 1992's 'Honeymoon in Vegas' album, however.) A cover of the Woody Guthrie song "Jesus Christ" was also recorded during these sessions for eventual inclusion on the cover album 'Folkways: A Vision Shared'. Lastly, a cover of "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" was recorded and released for the first 'A Very Special Christmas' album, released at the end of 1987.
Live performances
in November 1987.
The band chose to film the black-and-white footage over two nights at Denver's McNichols Sports Arena on 7 and 8 November 1987. They chose the city following the success of their 'U2 Live at Red Rocks: Under a Blood Red Sky' video which was filmed in Red Rocks Amphitheatre near Denver in 1983. The Edge said, "We thought lightning might strike twice". The first night's performance disappointed the group, with Bono finding that the cameras infringed on his ability to play to the crowd. The second Denver show was far more successful and seven songs from the show are used in the film, and three on the album.
Hours before the second Denver performance, an IRA bomb killed eleven people at a Remembrance Day ceremony in the Northern Irish town of Enniskillen (see Remembrance Day Bombing). During a performance of "Sunday Bloody Sunday", which appears on the film, Bono condemned the violence in a furious mid-song rant in which he yelled, "Fuck the revolution!" The performance was so powerful that the band said they were not sure the song should have been used in the film. After watching the film, they considered not playing the song on future tours.McGee (2008), p. 113
Colour outdoor concert footage is from the band's Tempe, Arizona shows on 19 and 20 December 1987. Tickets were sold for US$5 each and both nights sold out within days. The set was different each night with the band throwing in some rarely performed songs, including "Out of Control", "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)", "One Tree Hill", and "Mothers of the Disappeared". For the latter, all four members played at the front of the stage, each under a large spotlight.
The album opens with a live cover of the Beatles' "Helter Skelter". Its inclusion on the album was intended by the band to reflect the confusion of The Joshua Tree Tour and their new-found superstar status. Bono opens "Helter Skelter" with this statement: "This is a song Charles Manson stole from the Beatles. We're stealing it back".Graham (2004), p. 36
The album contains a live version of Bob Dylan's "All Along the Watchtower". The performance is from the band's impromptu "Save the Yuppies" concert in Justin Herman Plaza in San Francisco, California on 11 November 1987. The video intersperses the performance of the song with footage from the band's performance of "Pride" from the same show, during which Bono spray-painted "Rock and Roll Stops the Traffic" on the Vaillancourt Fountain. This caused a bit of controversy, and ultimately, the band paid to repair the damage and publicly apologised for the incident. The phrase "Rock and Roll Stops the Traffic" reappeared 18 years later in the video "All Because of You" when an unnamed fan appeared with the sign at 1:55 in the video. It also reappeared in February 2009, when the band played on the rooftop of the BBC Radio studios in Langham Place.
Dennis Bell, director of New York gospel choir The New Voices of Freedom, recorded a demo of a gospel version of "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For".McGee (2008), p. 104 While in Glasgow in late July during the Joshua Tree Tour, Rob Partridge of Island Records played the demo for the band.McGee (2008), p. 109 In late September, U2 rehearsed with Bell's choir in a Harlem church, and a few days later they performed the song together at U2's Madison Square Garden concert. Footage of the rehearsal is featured in the movie, while the Madison Square Garden performance appears on the album.McGee (2008), pp. 110111 After the church rehearsal, U2 walked around the Harlem neighbourhood where they came across blues duo, Satan and Adam, playing in the street. A 40-second clip of them playing their composition, "Freedom for My People", appears on both the movie and the album.McGee (2008), p. 111
During "Silver and Gold", Bono explains that the song is an attack on apartheid. "The Star Spangled Banner" is an excerpt of Jimi Hendrix's famous Woodstock performance in 1969. The noise of the crowd was sampled extensively by The KLF for 'the Stadium House Trilogy' of singles on their 1991 album 'The White Room'.
Alternative live concert footage captured for the film in other cities during the 1987 tour (but ultimately not used for the final cut of the film) included:
*Foxboro, Massachusetts, Foxboro Stadium, 22 September 1987
*Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, JFK Stadium, 25 September 1987
*New York, NY, Madison Square Garden, 28 September 1987
*Long Island, New York, Rehearsals on a beach, 19 October 1987
*Boston, Massachusetts, Boston Garden, 18 September 1987 (color footage)
Reception
Album
The album divided critics when it was released in 1988. Some reviewers panned it, feeling that U2 were making a deliberate and pretentious attempt at rock and roll renown. Jon Pareles of 'The New York Times' called it a "mess" that exuded "sincere egomania", and said the "band's self-importance got in the way" of their ambition for the album. He said it was plagued by the group's "attempts to grab every mantle in the Rock-and-Roll Hall of Fame" and that each one was "embarrassing in a different way". David Stubbs of 'Melody Maker' said that 'Rattle and Hum' "lacks cohesion" and "is musically, stylistically confused". He criticised Bono's "reverential nods to the great white heroes of rock" and the band's "homages to the bluesmen and gospel greats". Thom Duffy of the 'Orlando Sentinel' said that 'Rattle and Hum' is "greatly in need of a focal point" and "often sounds like an over-reaching attempt to claim chunks of pop history as [U2's] own story". He believed the group had "merely celebrated its own ascension into the pop history books... and little more". Tom Carson from 'The Village Voice' called it an "awful record" by "almost any rock-and-roll fan's standards", and said the group's failure did not "sound attributable to pretensions so much as to monumental know-nothingism". Fellow 'Village Voice' critic Robert Christgau was more complimentary, calling the record "looser and faster than anything they've recorded since their first live mini-LP". David Browne of the 'New York Daily News' said the album's "scope and disjointedness" recalled double albums such as 'Exile on Main St.' or 'The Beatles', but that until it aged as well as those records, "'Rattle and Hum' just prattles and numbs". Andrew Means of 'The Arizona Republic' thought the album was "no substitute" for the "exhilaration and conviction" of the Joshua Tree Tour. He believed that Bono's passion on record was not "quite as mesmerizing as it is on stage" and that the group's new material did not "add significantly" to their message or image. Lynden Barber of 'The Sydney Morning Herald' called it "an ambitious project, and the result is almost inevitably a mixed bag". He lamented the songs that presented the band's Christianity "as a fait accompli", as well as their proclivity for "jams around a couple of chords substituting themselves for considered song-writing". A reviewer for Knight-Ridder News said, "this double-album boondoggle manages to make the band sound like quintessential overreachers".
Writing in 'Rolling Stone', Anthony DeCurtis said that the record succeeded at capping U2's rise to stardom "on a raucous, celebratory note", finding it to be "most enjoyable when the band relaxes and allows itself to stretch without self-consciously reaching for the stars". DeCurtis ultimately deemed it a "tad calculated in its supposed spontaneity" and said it demonstrated "U2's force but devot[ed] too little attention to the band's vision". In a rave review for the 'Los Angeles Times', Robert Hilburn called 'Rattle and Hum' a "frequently remarkable album" that more than matched 'The Joshua Tree', and he credited U2 for reviving the "idealism and craft of [rock's] finest moments". J. D. Considine of 'The Baltimore Sun' said that the album's songs "draw upon every musical strength U2 has developed over the years" and that the "sheer muscular physicality of its sound" set 'Rattle and Hum' apart from its predecessors. He said that despite the record being "occasionally pretentious", the group "never seems out of its depth" amongst the guest artists. Jay Cocks of 'Time' said, "U2 has never sounded better or bolder", calling 'Rattle and Hum': "the best live rock album ever made. The record, in every sense, of their lives". 'Hot Press' reviewer Bill Graham said it was U2's "most ambitious record" yet, while John Mackie of 'The Vancouver Sun' said it "should consolidate the band's stature as the Beatles of the late '80s". Cliff Radel of 'The Cincinnati Enquirer' said that 'Rattle and Hum' "proves the achievements of the band's previous album... were no accident", and that it demonstrated the group's ability to create "highly charged songs in the studio and on stage". In the UK, Robin Denselow of 'The Guardian' said that "the whole sounds far greater than the sum of the decidedly variable parts". The review found the cover songs to be the weakest material but judged 'Rattle and Hum' overall to be a "solid, versatile piece of work" that "leaves much of the best until last". Stuart Baillie of 'NME' gave it a positive 8/10 review. Contentiously, his review replaced a much more negative 4/10 review by Mark Sinker, in which he described it as "the worst album by a major band in years". It was pulled by 'NME' editor Alan Lewis, as it was feared that criticism of U2 would affect the magazine's circulation; Sinker resigned in protest.
At the end of 1988, 'Rattle and Hum' was voted the 21st-best album of the year in the Pazz & Jop, an annual poll of American critics published by 'The Village Voice'. In other critics' lists of the year's top albums, it was ranked number one by 'HUMO', second by the 'Los Angeles Times' and 'Hot Press', 17th by 'OOR', 23rd by 'NME', and 47th by 'Sounds'.
Film
According to a 'USA Today' survey of reviews at the time of the film's release, 'Rattle and Hum' had an average review score of 64/100. According to review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes, the film has a contemporary "Certified Fresh" rating of 67%. Roger Ebert panned the film as a "mess", saying the concert footage was poorly lit and did not show the audience enough, and that the band being "deliberately inarticulate" in interview segments was "not cute". His review partner Gene Siskel was more complimentary, praising the group's performance with the Harlem gospel choir as "powerful and emotional" and calling Bono's statements during "Sunday Bloody Sunday" the film's highlight. Hal Hinson of 'The Washington Post' called the film "an exercise in rock 'n' roll hagiography" and "a fanzine on celluloid", and said that despite its "stunning look", the film came across as "stagy and overproduced". He said that the band's "attempts to place themselves in the rock continuum are fairly strenuous and more than a little presumptuous". Joyce Millman of the 'San Francisco Examiner' described it as a "tediously pious and self-important" film that "successfully captured everything the faithful love, and we pagans loathe, about the biggest band of the '80s". She said the film "does nothing to pierce the band's vagueness" and that they were upstaged by B.B. King and the Harlem gospel choir. Millman judged that the cinematography's "gargantuan pomposity... perhaps unintentionally" personified "the essence of U2". Gary Graff of the 'Detroit Free Press' called the film "a conceptual mess that lacks focus and flow", and said that it neither chronicles the band's breakout success of 1987 adequately nor offers additional insight into the band. He said that "many of the individual components of [the film] are excellent" but that Joanou failed to tie them together. Carrie Rickey of 'The Philadelphia Inquirer' said, "Self-indulgent to the point of absurdity, 'U2 Rattle and Hum' might be the silliest concert film ever made." She said it compared unfavourably to other concert movies due to its lack of narrative, and that Joanou's reverence for U2 bordered on "unintentional hilarity", adding, "Rob Reiner and company couldn't do a 'Spinal Tap' on this; 'Rattle and Hum' is already a parody." Joanou himself called the picture "pretentious".Gardner (1994)Michael MacCambridge of the 'Austin American-Statesman' disagreed with the film's detractors, calling it a "very good and at times excellent concert movie" whose "studied avoidance of drifting into self-parody" distinguished it from predecessors and headed off comparisons to 'This Is Spinal Tap'. MacCambridge enjoyed the black-and-white footage of the band "in the middle of becoming legend" and their scenes with B.B. King and the Harlem gospel choir, but thought the switch to colour footage interrupted the film's "pace and momentum". David Silverman of the 'Chicago Tribune' said that Joanou "steadily brings the viewer into a relationship with the band and brings an understanding to the new music", while "provid[ing] an innovative, fast-paced insight" to U2. Silverman praised the documentary scenes with the individual band members and the "beautiful artistic" performance footage, and said the director "succeeded in bringing U2 to the screen in a creative, introspective and exciting film that will add to the legend and preserve the integrity of the decade's most influential contribution to rock". Barbara Jaeger of 'The Record' called it a "moving, beautifully photographed look at the group" that properly captured the energy of their live performances. She said, "If there is to be a standard against which future rock movies will be judged, 'U2 Rattle and Hum' is it." Mackie of 'The Vancouver Sun' said that despite the film offering "few insights into the individual members, the live footage is nothing short of brilliant." He described Bono's speech during "Sunday Bloody Sunday" as a "raw, emotional moment, a spontaneous outburst that crystalizes the powerful message of peace and love that U2 preach". Michael Wilmington of the 'Los Angeles Times' said the film "records some savagely compelling live performances" and offers proof of why "this unlikely band... are often ranked by critics as the world's best". He thought that despite Joanou not setting the proper context for the film or conducting an engaging interview with U2, "he matches the impassioned sounds with spectacular visuals".
Commercial performance
Despite the criticism, 'Rattle and Hum' was a strong seller, continuing U2's burgeoning commercial success. It hit number one on the US 'Billboard' 200 albums chart, remaining at the top spot for six weeks; it was the first number-one double album in the US since Bruce Springsteen's 'The River' in 1980.McGee (2008), p. 120 'Rattle and Hum' also reached number one in the UK and Australian charts. In the UK, it sold 360,000 copies in its first week, making it the fastest-selling album at that point (a record it held until the release of Oasis's 'Be Here Now' in 1997). Lifetime sales for the album have surpassed 14 million copies.Stokes (2005), p. 78
Legacy
In 1989, while at a press tour in Sydney, Australia (where U2 were touring with B.B. King and working on demos for the follow-up album 'Achtung Baby'), Bono stated, "making movies: that's the nonsense of rock & roll", which 'Rolling Stone' magazine claimed was almost an apology for the film. "Playing shows is the reason we're here", he added. Despite their commercial popularity, the group were dissatisfied creatively; Bono believed they were musically unprepared for their success, while Mullen said, "We were the biggest, but we weren't the best." By the Lovetown Tour, they had become bored with playing their greatest hits.Flanagan (1996), p. 4 U2 believe that audiences misunderstood the group's collaboration with King on 'Rattle and Hum' and the Lovetown Tour, and they described it as "an excursion down a dead-end street".Flanagan (1996), pp. 25, 2728McCormick (2006), p. 213 Towards the end of the Lovetown Tour, Bono announced on-stage that it was "the end of something for U2", and that "we have to go away and ... dream it all up again". The band subsequently reinvented themselves in the 1990s, incorporating alternative rock, electronic dance music, and industrial music into their sound, and adopting a more ironic, flippant image by which they embraced the "rock star" identity they struggled with in the 1980s.
Track listing
Album
Film
Personnel
*Bono lead vocals, guitars, harmonica
*The Edge guitars, keyboards, backing vocals, lead vocals on "Van Diemen's Land"
*Adam Clayton bass guitar
*Larry Mullen Jr. drums, percussion
'Guest performers'
*Bob Dylan Hammond organ on "Hawkmoon 269", backing vocals on "Love Rescue Me"
*The New Voices of Freedom gospel choir on "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For"
**George Pendergrass, Dorothy Terrell vocal soloists
*Joey Miskulin organ on "Angel of Harlem"
*The Memphis Horns horns on "Angel of Harlem" and "Love Rescue Me"
*B.B. King guest vocals and lead guitar on "When Love Comes to Town"
*Billie Barnum, Carolyn Willis, and Edna Wright backing vocals on "Hawkmoon 269"
*Rebecca Evans Russell, Phyllis Duncan, Helen Duncan backing vocals on "When Love Comes to Town"
*Brian Eno keyboards on "Heartland"
*Benmont Tench Hammond organ on "All I Want Is You"
*Van Dyke Parks string arrangement on "All I Want Is You"
'Additional musicians (field recordings and tapes)'
*Satan and Adam (Sterling Magee and Adam Gussow) vocals, guitar, percussion, and harmonica on "Freedom for My People" (sourced from field recording)
*Jimi Hendrix electric guitar on "The Star Spangled Banner" (sourced from 'Woodstock: Music from the Original Soundtrack and More' as played through U2's concert PA system)
Charts
Weekly charts
Year-end charts
Song charts
{| class="wikitable"!rowspan="2"|Year
!rowspan="2"|Song
!colspan="7"|Peak
|-
!width="50"|AUS
!width="50"|CAN
!width="50"|IRE
Note: U2 must be searched manually
!width="50"|NZ
!width="50"|UK
Note: U2 must be searched manually.
!width="50"|US Hot 100
Note: Songs must be searched manually
!width="50"|US Main Rock
|-
|rowspan="3"|1988
|"Desire"
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|3
|align="center"|1
|-
|"Angel of Harlem"
|align="center"|18
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|3
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|9
|align="center"|14
|align="center"|1
|-
|"God Part II"
|align="center"|
|align="center"|
|align="center"|
|align="center"|
|align="center"|
|align="center"|
|align="center"|8
|-
|rowspan="2"|1989
|"When Love Comes to Town"
|align="center"|23
|align="center"|41
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|4
|align="center"|6
|align="center"|68
|align="center"|2
|-
|"All I Want Is You"
|align="center"|2
|align="center"|67
|align="center"|1
|align="center"|2
|align="center"|4
|align="center"|83
|align="center"|13
|-
|align="center" colspan="9" style="font-size: 8pt"| "" denotes a release that did not chart.
|-
|}
Certifications and sales
Album
Film
References
'Footnotes'
'Bibliography'
*
*
*
*
*
Buy Rattle and Hum now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1988