Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1983
Hanna K.
Buy Hanna K. now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Hanna K.' is a 1983 American drama film directed by Costa-Gavras, starring Jill Clayburgh and Gabriel Byrne. The film was an attempt to depict the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in human terms.Cheryl A. Rubenberg. "Israel and the American National Interest, A Critical Examination". University of Illinois Press, 1986. . p 340
Plot
'Hanna K.' is the story of Hanna Kaufman, a child of Holocaust survivors and an American-Jewish immigrant to Israel, who is a court-appointed lawyer assigned to defend a Palestinian, Salim Bakri, accused of terrorism and infiltration. Salim claims that he was trying to regain possession of his family house. Hanna saves him from a jail sentence, but he is deported to Jordan. Salim eventually returns, is jailed for illegal immigration, and he again asks for her services. Hanna investigates the story and discovered that Salim's family home is now a tourist attraction in Kafr Rimon, a settlement built and lived in by Russian Jews. Bakri's former village of Kufr Rumaneh has disappeared except for a few stones and trees.
The state's attorneys offer Hanna a deal: if she drops the proceedings, they will arrange for Salim to become a South African citizen, and he can then return to Israel and try to get his property back. Hanna is confronted with the fact that one legacy of the Holocaust was the dispossession of the Palestinians while her colleagues attempt to persuade her of the merits of the arrangement for Salim with the argument that Israel must be "defended" even if Palestinians are denied their rights.Edward Saids review of 'Hanna K.', 'The Village Voice', Oct. 11, 1983, p. 45
Reception and controversy
Pro-Israeli groups were concerned about the film's sympathetic depiction of the Palestinian issue. An internal memorandum was circulated by a B'nai B'rith advising members about arguments which can be made against the film.Cheryl A. Rubenberg, p341
'Hanna K.' opened in several American cities and played for a short time to negative reviews, and then was abruptly pulled from circulation by the American distributor of the film. Costa Gavras personally advertised the film in 'The New York Times' at a cost of $50,000. Universal forbade him to use ads prepared for the film.
Vincent Canby of 'The New York Times' called it a "large, soggy dud" with ill-drawn characters and "dopey dialogue." Edward Said said in a 'Village Voice' review that "as a political as well as cinematic intervention, then 'Hanna K.' is a statement of a great and, I believe, lasting significance."
Legacy
In her 1986 book 'Israel and the American National Interest, A Critical Examination' Cheryl A. Rubenberg said that the film was a departure from the entertainment industry's traditionally sympathetic stance, as found in films and television docudramas such as 'Exodus', 'The Chosen', 'A Woman Called Golda', and 'Entebbe.'
References
Buy Hanna K. now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1983