Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1962
If a Man Answers
Buy If a Man Answers now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'If a Man Answers' is a 1962 American romantic comedy film directed by Henry Levin and stars then real-life husband-and-wife Bobby Darin and Sandra Dee. It was produced by Ross Hunter Productions, Inc, shot in Eastman color, and distributed by Universal-International. The screenplay was written by Richard Morris from a novel by Winifred Wolfe.
Plot
Chantal Stacy (Sandra Dee) is the daughter of Germaine Stacy (Micheline Presle), a former French showgirl, and John Stacy (John Lund), a conservative Boston antiques dealer, who met in Paris. Chantal was the product of their "souffl-and-beans romance." Her father worries about her French side leading her into pregnancy before her Boston side finds a husband; a foghorn sounds every time a man gets too close to her.
Her father gets a promotion and the family moves to New York City. Chantal gets picked up on Fifth Avenue by Eugene "Gene" Wright (Bobby Darin), a photographer who invites her to model for him. During Chantal's first shoot, her father shows up to the set, punches Gene, after seeing the skimpy outfit Chantal is modeling in, and takes his daughter home. Chantal admits to her mother that she likes Gene and wants to continue modeling for him without John's interference; with her mother's advice, she marries Gene. However, now that she is his wife, Gene refuses to let Chantal model, effectively making her a housewife.
Shortly after their marriage, Chantal's college friend Tina (Stefanie Powers) arrives in New York. A spoiled rich girl, she goes after Gene, and he responds positively to Tina's flirting tactics, making Chantal starts to become nervous about her marriage. When Chantal is at a loss, her mother gives her a book on "How To Train Man's Best Friend" and advises Chantal that many men aren't treated as well as pets. She begins to use the dog-training techniques from the book on her husband and to her delight, the results are astounding. Germaine later explains that the book was not really for Chantel to train her husband to obey her like a dog but rather, it has been teaching her how to live with her husband.
Tina continues to stir up trouble, by admitting in a drunken stupor that she is desperately lonely and envious of Chantal's marriage and telling Gene about the dog-training book. In response, Chantal's mother suggests another trick she used to keep her father interested: taking a lover. Chantal is shocked at first, but Germaine says that her lover, "Robert Swan," was only imaginary. She kept up the act by sending herself flowers and having her girlfriends call and hang up "if a man answers" the phone, resulting in making her husband jealous. All of this is confirmed when the girls ask John about his accounts. Before Chantal leaves to go home to try out these techniques, her mother tells her that whenever Gene confronts her, she needs to respond honestly; this would make him wonder if his wife is really telling the truth about having an affair (despite being told all about the trick, John still genuinely wonders if Robert Swan exists).
All of this seems to work, after Chantal periodically sends herself two-dozen white roses and has her mom call in and click the receiver when Gene picks up the phone. Eventually, Gene goes to the florist to track down Robert Swan. Chantel goes to explain the entire situation, but Gene still pleads with her to end her affair, making her wonder why her mother's old tactics did not turn out as planned. To add to her confusion, Gene actually invites a "Robert Swan" (Cesar Romero) to dinner and then asks him to move in and share Chantal in a polyandrous relationship. Chantal, in disbelief, phones her mother about the situation. Shocked, Chantal's mother and father come over to meet the fantasy man that has been sprung to life. Her father's suspicions that Robert Swan is a living person all the more real.
After snooping around Swan's luggage and some thought, Chantal realizes Swan is actually Gene's father, Adam Wright, acting the role of her (and her mother's former) lover. She and her mother decide to play along, turning the tables on the men for a few moments. Germaine finds out from John that he, Gene, and Adam were all in on the "Swan" act from the very beginning, to which she "admits defeat" and commends her husband for "being loyal to his sex." In the end, they all reconcile, and it is revealed that Chantal is pregnant, just as Chantal's mother suspected.
Cast
*Sandra Dee as Chantal "Chouchou/Charlotte/Charlie" Stacy
*Bobby Darin as Eugene "Gene" Wright
*Micheline Presle as Germaine Stacy
*John Lund as John Stacy
*Cesar Romero as Robert Swan/Adam Wright
*Stefanie Powers as Tina
*Christopher Knight as Richard
*Ted Thorpe as the florist
*Roger Bacon as Messenger
*John Bleifer as Mr. Riordan, the Tobacconist
*Pamela Searle as Model
*Warrene Ott as Rita
*Dani Lynn as Bunny
*Charlene Holt as Lisa, Model
*Gloria Camacho as Model
*Edmay Van Dyke as Model
*Rosalee Calvert as Model
Production
The film was based on a novel by Winifred Wolfe published in 1961. The 'New York Times' called it "too cute to be clever."Maman Calls the Turn: IF A MAN ANSWERS. By Winifred Wolfe, 261 pp. New York: Doubleday & Co. $3.95.
By BEVERLY GRUNWALD. New York Times 21 May 1961: BR39. Film rights were bought by Universal. In March 1961 producer Ross Hunter assigned Richard Morris to write the script. Morris had never written a script before and was best known for doing the lyrics on 'The Unsinkable Molly Brown'.More TV Notables Grabbed for Films Los Angeles Times 31 Mar 1961: B7.
In August 1961 Hunter announced the film would star Nancy Kwan, Claudette Collbert and David Niven.NEW YORK LURES MOVIE PRODUCER: Ross Hunter to Work Here on Films and a Musical
By EUGENE ARCHER. New York Times19 Aug 1961: 10. In October Tammy Grimes was being discussed for the star.'Chapman Report' Lengthens Roster Los Angeles Times 2 Oct 1961: C13. However, the lead role eventually went to Sandra Dee who made it after the birth of her child.Looking at Hollywood: Sandra Gets Glamor Treatment in Next Film
Hopper, Hedda. Chicago Daily Tribune 11 Nov 1961: 17. By December Dee's co star was Bobby Darin.FILMLAND EVENTS: Second Property Purchased by King
Los Angeles Times 11 Dec 1961: C15.
Reception
Philip K. Scheuer criticized the score in a review for the 'Los Angeles Times'.Scheuer, Philip K. "'If a Man Answers' Teams Dee, Darin: Young Marrieds Depicted; 'I Love Louisa' Up for Liz." 'Los Angeles Times'. 18 Oct 1962: C17. Via Proquest.
A. H. Weiler, in a review for the 'New York Times', stated, "'If a Man Answers' is an airy antic that would not hurt a dog but appears to be fashioned for the young in mind as well as the young in heart."Weiler, A. H. "Sandra Dee and Bobby Darin in 'If a Man Answers'." New York Times. 22 Nov 1962: 51. Via Proquest.
Cast
The rle of the Model was played by real-life beauty queen Pamela Searle. In 1959 she was crowned Miss.England, and later came in third in the Miss Universe contest.
Awards
This comedy was nominated for a Golden Globe for Best Motion Picture (Comedy) and Best Supporting Actor (Cesar Romero). It was also nominated for a Golden Laurel for Top Female Comedy Performance (Sandra Dee).
Home media availability
Universal first released the film on DVD on August 3, 2004. It was re-released on February 7, 2017, as part of Universal's '4-Movie Laugh Pack' DVD series, being packaged with 3 other films starring Sandra Dee ('That Funny Feeling', 'Tammy Tell Me True', and 'Tammy and the Doctor').
References
Buy If a Man Answers now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1962