Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1958
Lafayette Escadrille (film)
Buy Lafayette Escadrille (film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Lafayette Escadrille', also known as 'C'est la Guerre', 'Hell Bent for Glory' (UK) and 'With You in My Arms', is a 1958 American war film produced by Warner Bros. It stars Tab Hunter and Etchika Choureau and features David Janssen and Will Hutchins, as well as Clint Eastwood, in an early supporting role. It was the final film in the career of director William A. Wellman and is based on his original story.
Plot
Thad Walker (Tab Hunter), a spoiled, rich kid from Boston, who had gotten in serious trouble with the law, fled to France to join the French Foreign Legion in World War I. In Paris, with companions, "Duke" Sinclair (David Janssen), Dave Putnam (Will Hutchins), Tom Hitchcock (Jody McCrea) and Bill Wellman (William Wellman Jr.), the boys stop at a bar and learn of the recent formation of the Lafayette Escadrille made up of American volunteer pilots who fly for France. The group of expatriates join up and learn to fly on training aircraft before becoming combat pilots.
While off duty, Walker meets and falls in love with Rene Beaulieu (Etchika Choureau), a common streetwalker with some sensitivity; she quits the oldest profession and takes a job, reforming for her American lover's sake. Walker's father beat him, and he resents any kind of authority. When a strutting, arrogant French officer (Marcel Dalio), irritated by the young man's inability to understand commands in French, strikes him, he knocks the officer to the ground, a very serious offense. Before he can be jailed, his pals smuggle Walker out of camp. He then spends a great deal of time hiding in Paris in his sweetheart's apartment. His friends continue with their training while Walker works for the Madam (Veola Vonn), hoping to make enough money to run away to South America with his girlfriend.
Later, the now veteran pilots he had befriended come to the bar and Walker realizes he still wants to redeem himself. Convincing an American general that he is sincere, when the United States enters the war, he joins the American Air Service. Walker finally is able to fly a mission with the Lafayette Escadrille, where he proves to be a superb fighter pilot. Returning to Paris, Walker asks his friends to join him as he weds Rene.
Cast
* Tab Hunter as Thad Walker
* Etchika Choureau as Rene Beaulieu
* Marcel Dalio as Drill Sergeant
* David Janssen as "Duke" Sinclair
* Paul Fix as U.S. General
* Veola Vonn as The Madam
* Will Hutchins as Dave Putnam
* Clint Eastwood as George Moseley
* Robert Hover as Dave Judd
* Tom Laughlin as Arthur Blumenthal
* Brett Halsey as Frank Baylies
* Henry Nakamura as Jimmy
* Maurice Marsac as Sgt. Parris
* Raymond Bailey as Amos J. Walker
* William Wellman Jr. as Bill/William A. Wellman
* Jody McCrea as Tom Hitchcock
* Denny Devine as Lawrence "Red" Scanlon
* Ralph Guldahl as Dudley Tucker
* Sam Boghosian as Booth
'Cast notes:'
* The roles of "Duke" Sinclair (Reginald "Duke" Sinclaire), Dave Judd (Edward David Judd), Arthur Blumenthal and Frank Baylies (Frank Leamon Baylies) were also based by Wellman on actual members of the Escadrille
* Craig Hill's uncredited role as Lufberry, based on Raoul Gervais Lufbery, is essentially a walk-on role.
Production
Relying on his own World War I service, Wellman wrote the original story, based on the actual exploits of a friend from the war years.Wellman 1918, p. 1. Earning himself the nickname "Wild Bill", Wellman was first an ambulance driver in the Norton-Harjes Ambulance Corps, then joined the French Foreign Legion.Curtiss, Thomas Quinn. [http://www.iht.com/articles/1994/02/09/cine.php "The Film Career of William Wellman." ]'International Herald Tribune' (iht.com), February 9, 1994. Retrieved: March 12, 2012. On December 3, 1917, assigned as the first American fighter pilot to join N.87 'escadrille' in the Lafayette Flying Corps, Wellman went on to score three recorded "kills", along with five probables and to receive the Croix de Guerre with two palms.Silke 1980, p. 57.
Although he considered 'Lafayette Escadrille' a "personal project", the studio did not give Wellman the budget he demanded and continued to interfere with the project, to the extent that the decisions on starring roles, title, ending and other important aspects of the production were taken out of his hands,Parish 1990, p. 244. including the title of the film: Wellman's original title was 'C'est la Guerre' which the studio, despite his objections, changed to 'Lafayette Escadrille'.Wellman 1974, p. 36. In casting, Wellman wanted Paul Newman and Clint Eastwood as the leads; studio head Jack L. Warner refused, and substituted teen idol Tab Hunter and David Janssen, with Eastwood moved to a minor role.Erickson, Glenn. [http://www.dvdtalk.com/dvdsavant/s3751lafa.html "Lafayette Escadrille Remastered Edition, Warner Archive Collection."] 'DVD Savant,' January 14, 2012. Retrieved: March 12, 2012. Warner also insisted Wellman make 'Darby's Rangers' as a condition of financing 'Lafayette Escadrille'.Nat Segaloff, 'Final Cuts: The Last Films of 50 Great Directors', Bear Manor Media 2013 p 312314
The use of mocked-up Nieuport 28 and Thomas-Morse Scout fighters along with other period aircraft such as one real Fokker D.VII and the ubiquitous Travelair "Wichita Fokkers" were "lifted" from Wellman's earlier 1938 production, 'Men with Wings', an early color feature also directed by Wellman.[http://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title/83315/Men-with-Wings/notes.html "Notes: Men with Wings (1938)."] 'Turner Classic Movies.' Retrieved: March 14, 2012. Principal photography took place primarily at the Hancock Santa Maria, California airport. Hollywood stunt pilot Paul Mantz, built a number of Blriot XI "Penguin" clipped-wing and full span training aircraft, used in the training sequences.Hardwick and Schnepf 1989, p. 58.
According to information in the Warner Bros. Archive, the original scriptwith the tragic ending in which Walker dies in combat and Rene commits suicidewas written by Paul Fix. A later script, dated October 1956 and attributed to A. Fleischman (with story credit to Wellman) has the happy ending. Shooting took place October 19 to December 8, 1956.
Reception
" Memorial Arch
In the original cut of the film Tab Hunter's character died at the end. However this was poorly received at previews and a new ending was shot in AprilMay 1957 where he lived.
While the aviation scenes in 'Lafayette Escadrille' were well received (William Clothier filmed the spectacular aerial sequences, evocative of those he shot in Wellman's earlier silent classic 'Wings'), critics said the film falls far short of the classic status of the 1928 Oscar winner. The flying sequences were not enough to overcome a mediocre story and flat acting, aspects roundly panned by critics. Howard Thompson, reviewer for 'The New York Times' called it a "flapdoodle" in his blistering review.Thompson, Howard. [https://movies.nytimes.com/movie/review?res=9F03EFD71E30E73BBC4152DFB2668383649EDE " 'Hell Bent For Glory' (1958) Western and 'Lafayette Escadrille' Open."] 'The New York Times', April 19, 1958.'Variety' echoed other reviews, noting, "What could have been an reasonably good actioneer ... has been badly marred by a flat predictability in plot, intrusion of an inept and, at times, ludicrously irrelevant romance and some quite dreadful dialog.'Parish 1990, p. 245.
The 'Lafayette Escadrille ' was also totally disowned by those still alive who had flown as part of the fabled Lafayette Escadrille and the Lafayette Flying Corps, who were understandably upset at their portrayal, including Wellman who insisted that his producer's credit be removed. This was to be William Wellman's last directorial effort; it had started out to be a paean to his memories of the storied squadron, but ended up a target for insults, accusations and lawsuits, not the least of which were directed against Jack Warner and Warner Brothers Studios for their heavy-handed interference.Nixon, Rob. [http://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title/80725/Lafayette-Escadrille/articles.html "Lafayette Escadrille (1958)."] 'Turner Classic Movies.' Retrieved: March 12, 2012. The film was shelved for two years, partly because of the wrangling between the two Hollywood heavyweights. TCM.com reports that a modern source suggests that the delay was at least partly due to the studios hopes that Hunter would succeed as a singer. So a "pollyanna" ending grafted into the film.Hunter and Muller 2005, pp. 179180. Wellman was "heartbroken" with his treatment at the hands of Jack L. Warner, and kept his word that 'Lafayette Escadrille' would be his last film.Wellman 2006, p. xvi.
See also
* 'The Legion of the Condemned' (1928)
* 'Flyboys' (2006)
References
'Explanatory notes'
'Citations'
'Bibliography'
* Hardwick, Jack and Ed Schnepf. "A Viewer's Guide to Aviation Movies". 'The Making of the Great Aviation Films,' General Aviation Series, Volume 2, 1989.
* Hunter, Tab and Eddie Muller. 'Tab Hunter Confidential: The Making of a Movie Star'. New York: Algonquin Books, 2005. .
* Parish, James Robert. 'The Great Combat Pictures: Twentieth-Century Warfare on the Screen.' Metuchen, New Jersey: The Scarecrow Press, 1990. .
* Silke, James R. "Fists, Dames & Wings." 'Air Progress Aviation Review', Volume 4, No. 4, October 1980.
* Thompson, Frank T. 'William A. Wellman' (Filmmakers Series). Metuchen, New Jersey: Scarecrow Press, 1983. .
* Wellman, William A. 'Go, Get 'em! The True Adventures of an American Aviator of the Lafayette Flying Corps.' Boston: The Page Company, 1918.
* Wellman, William A. 'A Short Time for Insanity: An Autobiography'. New York: Hawthorn Books, 1974. .
* Wellman, William Jr. 'The Man And His Wings: William A. Wellman and the Making of the First Best Picture'. New York: Praeger Publishers, 2006. .
Buy Lafayette Escadrille (film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1958