Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1954
A Star Is Born (1954 film)
Buy A Star Is Born (1954 film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
{{Infobox film
| name = A Star Is Born
| image = A Star Is Born (1954 film poster).jpg
| alt =
| caption = Theatrical release poster
| director = George Cukor
| producer = Sidney Luft
| screenplay = Moss Hart
| based_on =
| story =
| starring =
| music = Ray Heindorf
| cinematography = Sam Leavitt
| editing = Folmar Blangsted
| studio = Transcona Enterprises
| distributor = Warner Bros. Pictures
| released =
| runtime =
| country = United States
| language = English
| budget = $5 million
| gross = $6 million (US/Canada rentals)
}}
'A Star Is Born' is a 1954 American musical drama film directed by George Cukor, written by Moss Hart, and starring Judy Garland and James Mason. Hart's screenplay is an adaptation of the original 1937 film, based on the original screenplay by Robert Carson, Dorothy Parker and Alan Campbell, and from the same story by William A. Wellman and Carson, with uncredited input from six additional writersDavid O. Selznick, Ben Hecht, Ring Lardner Jr., John Lee Mahin, Budd Schulberg and Adela Rogers St. Johns.
Garland had not made a film since she had negotiated release from her MGM contract soon after filming began on 'Royal Wedding' in 1950, and 'Star' was promoted heavily as her comeback. For her performance, Garland was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Actress, but lost to Grace Kelly for 'The Country Girl'.
It was the second of four official adaptations of 'A Star Is Born', with the first in 1937 starring Janet Gaynor and Fredric March, the third in 1976 starring Barbra Streisand and Kris Kristofferson, and the fourth in 2018 starring Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper.
In 2000, the 1954 film was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant." The film ranked #43 on the American Film Institute's 100 Years...100 Passions list in 2002 and #7 on its list of greatest musicals in 2006. The song "The Man That Got Away" was ranked #11 on AFI's list of 100 top songs in films.
Plot
Esther Blodgett is a talented aspiring singer with a band, and Norman Maine is a former matine idol whose career is beginning to decline. When he arrives intoxicated at a function at the Shrine Auditorium, studio publicist Matt Libby attempts to keep him offstage. After an angry exchange, Norman rushes away and bursts onto a stage where an orchestra is performing. Blodgett takes him by the hand and pretends he is part of the act, thereby turning a potentially embarrassing and disruptive moment into an opportunity for the audience to greet Norman with applause.
Realizing that Esther has saved him from public humiliation, Norman thanks her and draws a heart on the wall with her lipstick. He invites her to dinner, and later watches her perform in an after-hours club. He recognizes her impressive talent, urges her to follow her dream, and convinces her she can break into movies. Esther is surprised that someone of Norman's stature sees something special in her. He offers her a screen test and advises her to "sleep on it", promising to call her the next day. Esther tells Danny McGuire, her bandmate, that she is quitting their upcoming gig to pursue movies in L.A. Thinking she is crazy, he tries to talk her out of it, but Esther is determined. Norman is called away early in the morning to filming and then falls ill. He attempts to get a message to Esther but cannot remember her address. When she does not hear from him, she suspects he was insincere. Not disheartened, she takes jobs as a carhop and TV commercial singer to make ends meet, convinced she can make it with or without Norman.
Norman tries to find Esther, who has had to move from her apartment. Then he hears her singing on a television commercial and tracks her down. Studio head Oliver Niles believes Esther is just a passing fancy for the actor, but casts her in a small film role. The studio arbitrarily changes her name to Vicki Lester, which she finds out when she tries to pick up her paycheck. When Norman finally gets Niles to hear "Vicki" sing, he is impressed and she is cast in an important musical film, making her a huge success. Her relationship with Norman flourishes, and they wed.
As Vicki's career continues to flourish, Norman finds himself unemployed and going downhill fastan alcoholic in a tough new film business with no tolerance for alcoholics. Norman arrives, late and drunk, in the middle of Vicki's Oscar acceptance speech. He interrupts her speech, rambling and pacing back and forth in front of her. While begging for work from the assembled and embarrassed Hollywood community, he accidentally strikes Vicki in the face.
Vicki continues working and tells Oliver that Norman has entered a sanitarium. After supporting him for so long, she worries about the effect of Norman's alcoholism on her, while acknowledging that he is trying very hard to overcome his addiction. Niles is amenable to offering Norman work, a gesture for which Vicki is grateful, thinking this may be just the boost her husband needs. At the racetrack, Norman runs into Libby, who taunts him and accuses him of living on Vicki's earnings. The resulting fight prompts Norman to go on a drinking binge; he is eventually arrested for being drunk and disorderly and receives ninety days in the city jail. Vicki bails him out and brings him home, where they are joined by Niles. Norman goes to bed but overhears Vicki telling Niles she will give up her career to take care of him. He also hears Oliver say that Norman ruined his own career with his drinking. Finally realizing what he has done to himself, Vicki, his career, and the people around him, Norman leaves his bed, tells Vicki cheerfully that he is going to go for a swim, walks into the ocean, and drowns himself.
At Norman's funeral, Vicki is mobbed by reporters and insensitive fans. Despondent, Vicki becomes a recluse and refuses to see anyone. Finally, her old bandmate Danny convinces her she needs to attend a charity function because she constitutes the only good work Norman did and which he died trying to save. At the Shrine Auditorium, she notices the heart Norman drew on the wall on the night they met and for a moment seems to lose her composure. When she arrives on stage, the master of ceremonies tells her the event is being broadcast worldwide, and asks her to say a few words to her fans. She says, "Hello, everybody. This is Mrs. Norman Maine", which prompts the crowd into a standing ovation.
Cast
Production
In December 1952, George Cukor was approached by Sid Luft, who proposed the director helm a musical remake of the 1937 film 'A Star Is Born', with his then wife Judy Garland in the lead role. Garland previously had portrayed Vicki Lester in a December 1942 Lux Radio Theater broadcast with Walter Pidgeon, and she and Luft, along with several associates, had formed Transcona Enterprises specifically to produce the project on screen. Cukor had declined to direct the original film because it was too similar to his 1932 work 'What Price Hollywood?', but the opportunity to direct his first Technicolor film and first musical film, work with screenwriter Moss Hart, and especially with Garland, appealed to him, and he accepted. It was Garland's first film since leaving MGM.
Getting the updated film to the screen proved to be a challenge. Cukor wanted Cary Grant, whom he had directed three times before, for the male lead, and went so far as to read the entire script with him. Grant, while agreeing it was the role of a lifetime, was more interested in traveling with wife Betsy Drake, and steadfastly refused the role (he also turned down 'Roman Holiday' and 'Sabrina').Jaynes, Barbara Grant; Trachtenberg, Robert. [http://www.tcm.com/thismonth/article/?cid=76185 'Cary Grant: A Class Apart']. Burbank, California: Turner Classic Movies (TCM) and Turner Entertainment. 2004. He was also concerned about Garland's reputation for unreliability; Cukor never forgave Grant for declining the role. The director then suggested either Humphrey Bogart or Frank Sinatra for the part, but Jack L. Warner rejected both. Garland suggested John Hodiak (with whom she had previously worked in 'The Harvey Girls' eight years earlier) for the part, but Hodiak was unavailable at the time. Stewart Granger was the frontrunner for a time, but withdrew when he was unable to adjust to Cukor's habit of acting scenes as a form of direction.
Ultimately, James Mason was signed, and filming began on October 12, 1953. As the months passed, Cukor was forced to deal not only with constant script changes but an unstable leading lady, who was plagued by chemical dependencies, significant weight fluctuations, illnesses, and hypochondria. After considerable footage had been shot, studio executives decided the film should be the first Warner Brothers motion picture to use CinemaScope, necessitating everything be scrapped and filmed again.
In March 1954, a rough cut still missing several musical numbers was assembled, and Cukor had mixed feelings about it. When the last scene was filmed in the early morning hours of July 28, 1954, Cukor had already departed the production and was unwinding in Europe. The long "Born in a Trunk" sequence was added after Cukor had left, supervised by Garland's professional mentor Roger Edens.
The first test screening the following month ran to 196 minutes, and despite ecstatic feedback from the audience, Cukor and editor Folmar Blangsted trimmed it to 182 minutes for its New York premiere in October. The reviews were excellent, but Warner executives, concerned the running time would limit the number of daily showings, made drastic cuts without Cukor, who had departed for India to scout locations for 'Bhowani Junction'. At its final running time of 154 minutes, the film lost two major musical numbers and crucial dramatic scenes; Cukor called it "very painful" to watch.
'A Star Is Born' cost more than $5 million to produce, making it one of the more expensive films made in Hollywood at that time.
Release
On October 22, 1954, it was reported that Warner Bros. had removed 27 minutes from the film, and the new version would be sent back to theaters on November 1.
1983 restoration
In October 1981, an Academy tribute to Ira Gershwin was held, in which the musical number "The Man That Got Away" was screened. Following the ceremony, academy president Fay Kinan expressed interest in the removed footage. By courtesy of Warner Bros. studio chairman Robert A. Daly, film preservationist Ronald Haver was granted access into the studio's film vaults. Alongside archivist Don Woodruff and editor Craig Holt, Haver located four minutes of the missing thirty minutes inside a storage facility that belonged to film librarian Merle Ray Harlin, who had been recently convicted of grand theft of motion pictures.Pollock, Dave (August 6, 1983). [https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/633668126/ "More Films Identified in TV Studio Librarian's Cache"]. 'Los Angeles Times'. Part II, p. 4 via Newspapers.com. Retrieved December 9, 2020. Over the course of six months, Haver located more missing scenes, including two complete musical numbers: "Here's What I'm Here For" and "Lose That Long Face". Additionally, the film's stereophonic soundtrack had been found inside the Burbank sound library. However, seven to eight minutes of matching footage to some of the film's dramatic scenes was never located. Rather than scrap these scenes, a choice was made to intersperse the soundtrack with filtered production stills of these sequences, assembled from the archives.On July 7, 1983, the reconstructed version (with a runtime of 176 minutes) was screened at the Radio City Music Hall. Those in attendance included James Mason and Garland's daughters Liza Minnelli and Lorna Luft. Cukor had died the night before a special screening of the film was held at the Samuel Goldwyn Theater on January 24, 1983. In the spring of 1984, the restored film was re-issued and shown at the Ziegfeld Theatre in New York City; for this engagement, an outtake of Garland's performing "The Man That Got Away" in a different costume and hairstyle was included. The same year, when PBS was producing its documentary for 'Great Performances', 'Judy Garland: The Concert Years', another small piece of footage was found and shown for the first time in the program: Garland singing "When My Sugar Walks Down the Street", which was deleted from the "Born in a Trunk" sequence.
Home media
Warner Home Video released the 176-minute 1983 "restored" version on DVD in letterbox widescreen format on September 19, 2000. The film was digitally remastered from original CinemaScope elements for superior picture clarity and optimal audio vitality and features a remastered English audio soundtrack in Dolby Digital 5.1 and subtitles in English and French. Bonus features include the network telecast of the Hollywood premiere at the Pantages Theatre on September 29, 1954; highlights from the post-premiere party at the Cocoanut Grove; three alternative filmings of "The Man That Got Away" with additional original recording session music; a short musical sequence that appeared in a test screening but was deleted before the film's official premiere, "When My Sugar Walks Down the Street" (which was to be part of the extended "Born in a Trunk" sequence); and the theatrical trailers for this, the 1937 original, and the 1976 remake.On June 22, 2010, Warner Home Video released the film on Blu-ray and DVD. The release also included supplemental features such as alternate takes, deleted scenes, excerpts from Garland's audio recording sessions, a collectible book of rare photos, press materials, and an essay by film historian John Fricke.
Warner Archive Collection reissued the Blu-ray and DVD on May 14, 2019.
Reception
Box office
During its initial release, 'A Star is Born' earned $6 million in North American distributor rentals. However, despite its huge popularity, the film failed to make a profit for Warner Brothers due to its excessive cost.Critical reaction
The film received critical acclaim; on the review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 98% based on 40 reviews, with an average rating of 8.1/10. The site's critical consensus reads "'A Star Is Born' is a movie of grand scope and intimate moments, featuring Judy Garland's possibly greatest performance."
Bosley Crowther of 'The New York Times' wrote the film was "one of the grandest heartbreak dramas that has drenched the screen in years." He also added: "The whole thing runs for three hours, and during this extraordinary time a remarkable range of entertainment is developed upon the screen...No one surpasses Mr. Cukor at handling this sort of thing, and he gets performances from Miss Garland and Mr. Mason that make the heart flutter and bleed."
Abel Green, reviewing for 'Variety', felt the "casting is ideal; the direction sure; the basic ingredients honest and convincing all the way. Miss Garland glitters with that stardust which in the plot the wastrel star James Mason recognizes." 'Harrison's Reports' wrote that "...in addition to being a powerful human-interest drama that frequently tugs at the heartstrings, the picture is studded with nice touches of comedy and vastly entertaining musical interludes that are well-placed and do not interfere with the progress of the story." The paper also applauded Garland's performance, writing she "has never appeared to better advantage than she does in this film; she not only makes the most of her exceptional musical talents, but also endears herself to the audience with her highly sympathetic portrayal of a wholesome young woman..."
'Time' wrote that Garland "gives what is just about the greatest one-woman show in modern movie history". Jack Moffitt of 'The Hollywood Reporter' described the film as "the perfect blend of drama and musicalof cinematic art and popular entertainment". He furthermore felt "the entire success of the picture depends upon the fact that Judy really has it. Her song styling is as individual and arresting as Ethel Merman's. And, as the picture progresses, she proves it in one smash number after another." Similarly, 'Newsweek' wrote that the film is "best classified as a thrilling personal triumph for Judy Garland...As an actress, Miss Garland is more than adequate. As a mime and comedienne she is even better. But as a singer she can handle anything from torch songs and blues to ballads. In more ways than one, the picture is hers".
Accolades
When the Oscar for Best Actress went to Grace Kelly instead of Garland, Groucho Marx sent Garland a telegram reading: "Dear Judy, this is the biggest robbery since Brink's".Soundtrack releases
The soundtrack has never been out of print. It was originally released by Columbia Records in 1954 in 10-inch 78 rpm and 12-inch rpm editions, and also on 7-inch 45 rpm records.
In 1988, Columbia released the soundtrack on compact disc, taking the overture and the main musical numbers directly from the film's stereo soundtrack due to the fact no stereo pre-recordings for the soundtrack master existed for this number.
In 2004, in commemoration of the film's 50th anniversary, Columbia, Legacy Recordings, and Sony Music Soundtrax released a nearly complete, digitally-remastered, expanded edition of the soundtrack. Due to the lack of a complete multitrack version of all songs and score from the film, the CD includes a mix of monaural and stereo elements in order to make as complete a soundtrack as possible.
Because some of the songs were not complete on the film soundtrack, as well as the fact that many of the original music stems had been lost or destroyed subsequent to original mono mixdown, numbers such as "Here's What I'm Here For" and "Lose That Long Face" are taken from the original mono LP masters.
Other numbers such as "Gotta Have Me Go with You" are mostly in stereo, save for brief sections where the mono soundtrack album master was used in order to remove various endemic plot-related sound effects from the track. All of the instrumental tracks are in mono as well due to the fact that the original elements have been lost or destroyed.
The 2004 soundtrack also includes three vocal outtakes an alternative vocal for the reprise of "It's a New World" that Esther sings while Norman goes for his final swim; "When My Sugar Walks Down the Street", which was intended to be part of the "Born in a Trunk" sequence, but was deleted for time constraints; and "The Trinidad Coconut Oil Shampoo Commercial", which was taken from the only surviving recording of the complete track, a very worn acetate artist reference disc.
In addition, much of the instrumental portion of the 2004 soundtrack contains partial or whole outtakes. This CD also sees the first CD release of the complete version of "Gotta Have Me Go with You" with the full introduction, as well as "The Man That Got Away" with an expanded introduction not used in the original film.
The original Columbia 1954 mono vinyl version of the soundtrack has been released on CD in Britain by Prism Leisure and is available for digital download. This version includes bonus tracks of Judy Garland's Decca recordings of songs from other films.
1954 soundtrack release
*"Gotta Have Me Go with You" (Harold Arlen and Ira Gershwin)*"The Man That Got Away" (Arlen and Gershwin)
*"Born in a Trunk" (Roger Edens (music) and Leonard Gershe (lyrics))Gershe received sole credit due to a contractual issue. [http://www.jgdb.com/star.htm Personal letter from Gershe to Jim Johnson]
* "Swanee" (George Gershwin)
* "I'll Get By" (Roy Turk and Fred E. Ahlert)
* "You Took Advantage of Me" (Lorenz Hart and Richard Rodgers)
* "The Black Bottom" (Perry Bradford)
* "The Peanut Vendor" (Moiss Simons)
* "My Melancholy Baby" (Ernie Burnett and George A. Norton)
* "Here's What I'm Here For" (Arlen and Gershwin)
* "It's a New World" (Arlen and Gershwin)
* "Someone at Last" (Arlen and Gershwin)
* "Lose That Long Face" (Arlen and Gershwin)
1988 soundtrack release
* "Overture"* "Gotta Have Me Go with You"
* "The Man That Got Away"
* "Born in a Trunk" Medley
* "Here's What I'm Here For"
* "It's a New World"
* "Someone at Last"
* "Lose That Long Face"
2004 soundtrack release
* "Overture"
* "Night of the Stars" (Instrumental)
* "Gotta Have Me Go with You"
* "Norman at Home" (Instrumental)
* "Passion Oriental" (Instrumental)
* "The Man That Got Away"
* "Cheatin' on Me" (Instrumental)
* "I'm Quitting The Band" (Instrumental)
* "The Man That Got Away" (Instrumental)
* "Esther in the Boarding House" (Instrumental)
* "Oliver Niles Studio" (Instrumental)
* "Esther's Awful Makeup" (Instrumental)
* "First Day in the Studio" (Instrumental)
* "Born in a Trunk" Medley
* "Easy Come, Easy Go" (Instrumental)
* "Here's What I'm Here For"
* "The Honeymoon" (Instrumental)
* "It's a New World"
* "Someone at Last"
* "Lose That Long Face"
* "Norman Overhears the Conversation" (Instrumental)
* "It's a New World" (Alternate Take)
* "The Last Swim" (Instrumental)
* "Finale"/"End Credits" (Instrumental)
'Bonus Tracks'
* "When My Sugar Walks Down the Street"
* "The Trinidad Coconut Oil Shampoo"
2005 soundtrack release
* "Gotta Have Me Go with You"* "The Man That Got Away"
* "Born In a Trunk Medley"
* "Here's What I'm Here For"
* "It's a New World"
* "Someone at Last"
* "Lose That Long Face"
'Bonus Tracks (Judy Garland studio recordings for Decca Records)'
* "Over the Rainbow" (recorded July 28, 1939)
* "I'm Nobody's Baby" (recorded April 10, 1940)
* "For Me and My Gal" (with Gene Kelly) (recorded July 26, 1942)
* "When You Wore a Tulip (And I Wore a Big Red Rose)" (with Gene Kelly) (recorded July 26, 1942)
* "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" (recorded April 20, 1944)
* "The Boy Next Door" (recorded April 20, 1944)
* "The Trolley Song" (recorded April 20, 1944)
* "Meet Me in St. Louis" (recorded April 21, 1944)
* "On the Atchison, Topeka, and the Santa Fe" (with The Merry Macs) (recorded July 7, 1945)
Remakes
The original film is in the public domain.
* A second remake of 'A Star Is Born' was released in 1976, with Kris Kristofferson and Barbra Streisand.
* 'Aashiqui 2' is a 2013 Bollywood remake, starring Aditya Roy Kapur and Shraddha Kapoor.
* In 2016, a third remake was announced, directed by Bradley Cooper, starring alongside Lady Gaga, who composed new music for the film. The 2018 adaptation was released to critical acclaim on October 5, 2018.
All four official iterations have been nominated for at least four Academy Awards.
See also
* List of American films of 1954
* List of films cut over the director's opposition
Notes
References
Further reading
**
Buy A Star Is Born (1954 film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1954