Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1952
Hiawatha (1952 film)
Buy Hiawatha (1952 film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Hiawatha' is a 1952 American Western film based on the 1855 epic poem 'The Song of Hiawatha' by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, centering on Native Americans in pre-Columbian times. Directed by Kurt Neumann, with stars Vincent Edwards and Yvette Dugay, it became the final feature produced by the low-budget Monogram Pictures, a mainstay of Hollywood's Poverty Row.[https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0044705/trivia IMDb notes on 'Hiawatha']
Plot
Hiawatha, a member of the Ojibway tribe, is on a peace mission to the Dakotah tribe. He meets and falls in love with Minnehaha. The romance is obstructed by a threatened war between the two tribes, instigated by a hot-headed Ojibway tribe member. The war is averted and Hiawatha learns that he is actually the long-missing son of the Dakotah chief.[http://onceuponatimeinawestern.com/hiawatha-1952/ Franklin, Mark. "Hiawatha (1952)" ('Once Upon a Time in a Western', June 26, 2016)]
Cast
* Vince Edwards as Hiawatha (as Vincent Edwards)
* Yvette Dugay as Minnehaha
* Keith Larsen as Pau Pukkeewis
* Engene Iglesias as Chibiabos (as Gene Iglesias)
* Armando Silvestre as Kwasind
* Michael Tolan as Ajawac
* Ian MacDonald as Chief Megissogwon
* Katherine Emery as Nokomis
* Morris Ankrum as Iagoo
* Stephen Chase as Lakku
* Stuart Randall as Mudjekeewis
Accusations of Communist propaganda
'Hiawatha's original production planning schedule, in early 1950, was reported by 'Time' magazine in September to have been put on hold due to the main character being a proponent of pacifism and speaking dialog "too close, for current U.S. taste, to the Communist 'peace' line".[http://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title/26801/Hiawatha/notes.html Turner Classic Movies notes regarding 'Hiawatha'] At the same time, the Los Angeles newspaper 'Illustrated Daily News', whose publisher, Manchester Boddy, was in the midst of an ultimately losing campaign for nomination as a strongly anti-Communist candidate in the California United States Senate election, published an interview with Monogram Pictures president Steve Broidy who stated that, "because of the tremendous influence that the motion picture industry exerts internationally, producers are being extremely cautious in preventing any subject matter to reach the screen which might possibly be interpreted as Communistic propaganda to even the slightest degree. The 'Hiawatha' screenplay, written by a scenarist whose Americanism is unquestioned, still left us with the feeling that Communistic elements might conceivably misinterpret the theme of our picture, despite its American origin, and that is why we have postponed its production."
'Variety' reported in January 1951 that 'Hiawatha' resumed production, with Broidy quoted as explaining that "the avalanche of editorial comment which greeted our announcement convinced us unquestionably that the American public would not be dupes for any Communist line, and that our 'Hiawatha' picture could only serve the highest ends of education and entertainment".
Contrary to Broidy's statement that the 'Hiawatha' screenplay was "written by a scenarist whose Americanism is unquestioned", film and television historian Paul Mavis, who devotes a considerable portion of his 'DVD Talk' review of 'Hiawatha' to this controversial aspect of the film, posits that the name of the screenwriter, Arthur Strawn was, in fact, among those of Communists and sympathizers listed in the anti-Communist pamphlet, 'Red Channels', and states that "'Hiawatha' was his last official credit, no doubt before he was blacklisted (Others first blacklisted after June 1950).[http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/61628/hiawatha-warner-archive-collection/ Mavis, Paul. "Hiawatha (Warner Archive Collection)" ('DVD Talk', September 12, 2013)] Describing it as a "[M]odest, respectful little Indian tale...lousy with Red Commie propaganda", Mavis details how "then-contemporary 1950s politics lie not so subtly beneath the so-called biographical surface, with the real Hiawatha's purported role as a peacemaker and tribe-uniter used as a framework for some thinly veiled jabs at American military might" and goes on to point out "how clearly screenwriter Strawn (with an assist by Dan Ullman) grafts Red-tinged 'Daily Worker' pacifist carps about American muscle onto Hiawatha's efforts to unite his fellow tribesmen".
Mavis also describes that "[W]hen Hiawatha defeats Pau PukKeewis in their first death match, Hiawatha refuses to kill him, which the movie takes as another positive sign of the innate "rightness" of Hiawatha's pacifism. Of course what the movie doesn't comment on is the price of Hiawatha's pacifism: had Hiawatha killed the clearly evil, troublemaking Pau PukKeewis when he first had the chance, the many subsequent deaths caused by Pau PukKeewis's continued duplicitous war campaign, would not have happened." He concludes that "muscular Vince Edwards looks and sounds right as the soft-spoken, determined Hiawatha. Had Monogram and company stuck with this relatively realistic look at Indian life before the White man came, and ditched all the phony Cold War platitudes, Hiawatha might have turned out to be a minor little gem".
Evaluation in film guides
'Steven H. Scheuer's Movies on TV' provided 2 stars (out of 4) and called it a "[M]ildly entertaining adventure based on Longfellow's poem", while 'Leonard Maltin's Movie Guide' had a somewhat lower opinion, giving 1 stars (out of 4) and denigrating it as a "[J]uvenile low-budget version of the Longfellow classic."
Assigning 2 stars (out of 5), 'The Motion Picture Guide' stated that "Edwards is cast as the title character in this family version of the classic Longfellow poem" and ultimately described it as "[A]n entertaining film for kids that masks its theme in a flurry of arrows and romance."
Among British references, Leslie Halliwell, in his 'Film Guide', gave no stars (Halliwell's top rating is 4), dismissing it as a "[M]uddled actioner which has little to do with Longfellow's poem."
References
Buy Hiawatha (1952 film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1952