Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1933
Morgenrot (film)
Buy Morgenrot (film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Morgenrot' is a 1933 German submarine film set during World War I.
Released three days after Adolf Hitler became Reichskanzler, it was the first film to have its screening in Nazi Germany. It became a symbol of the new times touted by the Nazi regime. The title (literally "morning-red") is the German term for the reddish coloring of the east sky about a half-hour before the sunrise. 'Dawn' was the U.S. title. It was filmed in Kiel, Schleswig-Holstein, the first German submarine movie made after World War I.
Production
In March 1927, the UFA studio, the largest film production company in Europe, was purchased by the media magnate Alfred Hugenberg, who wanted to own UFA to produce "national" films that glorified his right-wing politics.Leopold p.94 'Morgenrot' was one of the several "national" films that were released by UFA during Hugenberg's time as its owner.Leopold p.94 Despite Hugenberg's hopes, the UFA studio was heavily in debt at the time he purchased it and the transition from silent films to talkies imposed significant new costs on UFA and, as a result, UFA tended to release films with the widest possible appeal instead of the "national" films that Hugenberg had wanted to see produced.Leopold p.94 For Hugenberg, profits trumped his politics with UFA and, contrary to expectations, there was no purge of UFA's Jewish employees after he brought the studio as he did not want to lose talent to rival studios.Leopold p.94 Only a minority of UFA films released between 1927-1933 were the sort of films that Hugenberg had wanted to see produced.Leopold p.94
The script was for 'Morgenrot' was written by Gerhard Menzel, a successful writer from Silesia who had won the Kleist prize for the best new German play in 1927, who was also a Nazi party member.Kester & Veenkamp p.184 In turn, Menzel was inspired by an idea submitted by the writer Edgar von Spiegel von und zu Peckelsheim.Kester & Veenkamp p.184 However, Hugenberg intended for 'Morgenrot' to aid his party, the DNVP ('Deutsche Nationale Volkspartei' - German National People's Party), which he became the leader of in 1928, not the NSDAP ('Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei' - National-socialist German Workers' Party) .Leopold p.94 Hugenberg had a difficult relationship with Adolf Hitler, who was sometimes his ally and sometimes his enemy, which depended largely on Hitler's calculations about how much he needed the help of Hugenberg. At the time that 'Morgenrot' went into production, the NSDAP and the DNVP were enemies, but Hugenberg knew a strong showing by his party might change Hitler's attitude. It appears that 'Morgenort' was a sort of peace offering by Hugenberg to the Nazis, who might become the DNVP's allies once again.Hull p.21
The film was also part of an effort to rehabilitate the reputation of the Imperial Germany Navy and of navalism in general.Waldman p.27 The November Revolution of 1918, the alleged "stab-in-the-back" that defeated Germany just as the 'Reich' was alleged to be on the verge of victory, had started with the great High Seas Fleet mutiny. In October 1918, the mistreated sailors of the High Seas Fleet turned against their officers after being ordered to set sail on a "death ride" into the North Sea to take on the combined Anglo-American Grand Fleet in a battle expected to end in the destruction of the High Seas Fleet at a time when it was already clear that the war was lost. Besides for being mistreated by their officers, who delighted in humiliating them in various petty ways, the sailors of the High Seas Fleet justified the mutiny under the grounds that the war was already lost, making the planned "death ride" utterly pointless and that it was better to live another day than to die now for a lost cause. For the German right, the High Seas Fleet mutiny had given the Navy a vile reputation as a place of mutiny and treason, where the November revolution that had toppled the House of Hohenzollern had begun. Releasing a film featuring a heroic U-boat ace, who is honored to fight and if necessary die for the Fatherland, was intended by the navalist Hugenberg to dissipate the popular image of mutinous sailors waving about red flags, and provide a more positive image of the Imperial Navy.Waldman p.27 Much of what can be described as 'Morgenrot's pro-death message with its portrayal of death in war as noble, honorable and even erotic was intended as a sort of rebuttal to the mutinous sailors of the High Seas Fleet.Kester & Veenkamp p.183-184 One of the slogans used by the High Seas Fleet sailors when they mutinied in 1918 was "We want to live as free men, not die as slaves!"
The title of the film comes from a 19th century poem by the Romantic writer Wilhelm Hauff whose first lines read: '"Morgenrot, morgenrot/Leuchtest mir zum frhen Tod?/Bald wird die Trompete blasen/Dann muss ich Leben lassen/Ich und mancher Kamerad"' ('"Morning dawn, morning dawn/Do you glow to me to the early death?/Soon the trumpet will sound/Then I have to give up my life/Me and some comrades"').Kester & Veenkamp p.184 The film was directed by Gustav Ucicky, an Austrian director resident in Berlin who was one of UFA's best directors who went on to become one of the most prominent film directors of Nazi cinema.Hull p.244 'Morgenrot' was shot in OctoberNovember 1932 at Kiel and in Helsinki with the Baltic sea "playing" the North Sea.Hull p.20-21 To provide realism, the scenes abroad the U-boat were shot abroad a submarine borrowed from the Finnish Navy.Hull p.17
Plot
Set in 1916, the film offered up a highly fictionised version of the death of the British War Secretary, Field Marshal Herbert Kitchener aboard the cruiser HMS 'Hampshire', on his way to Russia. A successful U-boat ace, Helmut Liers, lives in the fictional north German town of Meerskirchen with his mother, who has already lost two sons in the war.Kester & Veenkamp p.184 Liers is the local hero of Meerskirchen due to his command of 'U-21' and the first part of the film concerns the high-spirited adventures of Liers and his crew while on leave.Kester & Veenkamp p.184 Everyone thinks that Helga, the daughter of the 'burgermeister' of Meerskirchen is in love with Lieutenant Phipps "Fips" Fredericks, but in fact she is in love with the older man Liers.Kester & Veenkamp p.184 The Majorin (Lier's mother), tries to get him a shore assignment, which he blocks, saying that he will fight on until Germany either wins the war or he dies, and then goes out to sea on his latest mission.Kester & Veenkamp p.186
In the second part of the film, the German Navy learns that a very important British military leader-who is not named in the film, but is clearly meant to be Kitchener-has boarded a cruiser taking him to Arkhangelsk, leading Liers and his U-boat being sent out to essentially assassinate him by sinking the cruiser, a task which is performed successfully (in reality, the 'Hampshire' was sunk by a mine laid by an U-boat, but not in a torpedo attack).Kester & Veenkamp p.185 Afterwards, a Q ship (a disguised British merchant cruiser), which illegally flies the flag of neutral Denmark, ambushes Liers's submarine, which is badly damaged.Kester & Veenkamp p.185 A squadron of British destroyers pursue 'U-21' across the North Sea, which is finally sunk and comes to rest on the seabed. Two of the 'U-21' crew members including Fips sacrifice themselves to save the others including Liers who make their way back to the Fatherland.Kester & Veenkamp p.185 The film ends with Liers boarding a new submarine to once again go out to continue the war at sea with the last shot being a close-up of the Imperial German Navy Ensign, which flutters proudly in the wind.Kester & Veenkamp p.185-186
Motifs
The film offered a heroization of death, with the captain Liers explicitly stating that Germans may not know how to live, but they know how to die.Baird, p. 8 In a central scene, the captain of the submarine offers to his men that he and the first officer will go down with the ship in order that they may escape; they refuse on the grounds it will be all or none of them, and the captain glorifies the chance to die with such men, a theme that commonly appeared in Nazi-era films.Leiser, pp. 20 The first officer Fredericks, having learned that the woman he loves is in love with captain, not himself, and another sailor commit suicide to save the others a common way to resolve love triangles in Nazi films, where the heroic death saves the man from failure.Leiser, pp. 2021 On the other hand, the Majorin refuses to rejoice over her son's success in sinking the cruiser and with it Lord Kitchener because of the suffering of war, saying that the men abroad the 'Hampshire' also had families-a theme that would not appear in Nazi film.Leiser, pp. 21 The American historian John Leopold argued that 'Morgenrot' was more of a DVNP film than a Nazi film, noting the film "...emphasized traditional nationalist concepts and stressed the advantages of mature leadership as well as the value of youthful exuberance".Leopold p.223
The British historian Jonathan Rayner described the scenes set in the U-boat as highly realistic and authentic as befitting a film shot on an actual submarine, which gave the audience some idea of just how dangerous and claustrophobic life was on submarines in World War One.Rayner p.27 Through the German submarine service was a new one, lacking long traditions, but the sheer dangerousness of submarine duty conferred on the submariners the status of an elite force, which Rayner wrote portrayed very well.Rayner p.27 Rayner also wrote that the action scenes such as the sinking of the 'Hampshire', the battle with the Q-ship, and the final confrontation with the destroyers were all exciting, well done and realistic, making the film into one of the best pre-World War Two submarine films, and as a film that served as a template for many subsequent submarine films.Rayner p.27 Rayner also notes that film portrayed the Germans as behaving with more honor than the British as Liers declines to sink the Q-ship despite the concerns of his men who suspect that the ship is a Q-ship.Rayner p.26 The climax of the film, where Fredericks and another sailor sacrificed themselves to save the other eight creates a blood debt as Liers tells the others: "Our lives are not longer ours. We must sail as long as we have breath, again and again, until God gives us leave".Rayner p.27 Rayner described the film's message as: "The crew's kinship, maintained up and beyond death, surpasses emotional connections on the shore, and compels the German sailors to honor the dead members of the shipboard family in ceaseless service".Rayner p.27 Through the film ends in 1916, but the devotion to duty showed by Liers and his crew stands in marked contrast to the sailors of the High Seas Fleet who mutinied in 1918.
The film is notable for its misogyny with its message that femininity equals weakness and masculinity equals strength.Kester & Veenkamp p.186 A key plot in the film are the efforts of Liers's wealthy mother to get him a shore assignment as she has already lost two sons to the war, an effort which her son successfully blocks, saying he would rather die for the Fatherland than shirk his patriotic duty.Kester & Veenkamp p.186 The female dominated home front in Germany is portrayed as a place of sexual temptation and weakness, in contrast to the harsh and all-male world of the U-boat at sea, which for its all discomforts and dangers, is portrayed in a more favorable light than the home front.Kester & Veenkamp p.186 The conflict between Liers vs. his mother over what she calls his 'todessehnsucht' (literally "longing for death", through "contempt for life" is a more accurate translation) is in fact the film's major conflict.Kester & Veenkamp p.187 Lier's mother calls his 'todessehnsucht' "a new kind of religion", a charge that he does not deny, merely saying in response that "We Germans may not how to live, but we know how to die".Kester & Veenkamp p.187 Lier's mother represents the pre-1914 Germany, which for its all its decency and civility does not have the necessary toughness to survive in a world that is portrayed as merciless and cruel.Kester & Veenkamp p.187 By contrast, Liers with his love of action and violence together with a general contempt for human life represents the hard, ruthless "New Man" spawned by the war, who for his all rough edges and 'todessehnsucht' paradoxically does the necessary toughness to survive.Kester & Veenkamp p.187
Reception
The film's gala premiere in Berlin on 2 February 1933 was attended by the newly appointed Chancellor Hitler as the guest of honor.Waldman p.27 Josef Goebbels wrote in his diary that 'Morgenrot' was "a good film within its limits".Waldman p.27 Critical reception towards 'Morgenrot' was generally favorable with the critics praising the acting and the direction with the film being praised as exciting and brisk.Kester & Veenkamp p.190-191 The 'Frankfurter Zeitung', the most prestigious newspaper in Germany, unusually put its review of 'Morgenrot' on its front page, where the film critic of the 'Frankfurter Zeitung' praised the 'Morgenrot' as one of the best German films ever made.Kester & Veenkamp p.191 However, critics noted that the scenes on the home front were 'idealtypischer Bilder' ("ideal typical picture") in contrast to the scenes set on 'U-21' submarine, which were praised for their realism.Kester & Veenkamp p.191 The character of the Majorin played by Adele Sandrock, was described as the film's most memorable character, which was certainly not the intention of the film's producers.Kester & Veenkamp p.191 The film critic of 'Vorwrts', the newspaper of the SDP, in one of his last film reviews ('Vorwrts' was banned later in February 1933) wrote with the character of the Majorin "any nationalist tendency was taken from the film", judging that the arguments made by the Majorin were stronger than those made by Liers.Kester & Veenkamp p.191 The film critic of 'Vlkischer Beobachter', the newspaper of the NSDAP, in his positive review wrote: "'Morgenrot'-may it be a symbol for the beginning of a new era".Kester & Veenkamp p.191 The Berlin correspondent of 'The New York Times' who attended the premiere reported that "It is a film of exceptional qualities, aside from its propagandistic tendencies".Hull p.17 Together with the 1931 film 'Yorck', 'Morgenrot' was one of the most financially successful of UFA's "national" films released under Hugenberg.Leopold p.94
The film generated much controversy in Britain in 1933 where reviewers were quick to notice that the unnamed British military leader who goes down on a cruiser on his way to Russia was meant to be Kitchener.Fox p.165Hull p.17 Additionally, the film's general picture of "English perfidy" as the British only managed to damage Liers's U-boat by illegally flying the Danish flag on a British ship, which suggested that the British could only defeat the Germans via underhanded methods also generated controversy in Britain.Fox p.165 Right from the film's premiere in Berlin, British newspapers gave 'Morgenrot' extensive coverage, which the film being criticised for its unflattening picture of the Royal Navy.Hull p.17 The film was debated in the House of Commons after a Tory backbencher, Sir Charles Cayzer, demanded that the Foreign Office have the ambassador in Berlin, Sir Horace Rumbold, made an official protest against 'Morgenrot', saying the film was very disrespectful and insulting towards Britain.Hull p.17 The prime minister, Ramsay MacDonald, was unwilling to have such a protest being and the Foreign Secretary, Sir John Simon, found himself during the debates in the House of Commons "...in the rather odd position of having to defend a Nazi film".Hull p.17 To placate Cayzer, Simon agreed to the House of Commons form a committee to investigate 'Morgenrot', which discovered that the UFA had borrowed the submarine used in the film from the Finnish Navy without informing the Finns what the film was all about.Hull p.17
Cast
* Rudolf Forster - Kapitanleutnant Helmut Liers
* Fritz Genschow - Oberleutnant 'Phipps' Fredericks
* Adele Sandrock - Liers' Mother
* Camilla Spira - GreteJaul, Fredericks' girl
* Paul Westermeier - Seaman Jaul
* Gerhard Bienert - Seaman Bhm
* Friedrich Gna - Juraczik
* Franz Nicklisch - Petermann
* Hans Leibelt - Brgermeister von Meerskirchen
* - Helga, Jaul's girl
* Eduard von Winterstein - Hauptmann Kolch
Awards
The National Board of Review of Motion Pictures awarded it with Best Foreign Film for 1933.
References
Bibliography
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Buy Morgenrot (film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1933