Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1896
The Monroe Doctrine (1896 film)
Buy The Monroe Doctrine (1896 film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'The Monroe Doctrine', also known as 'The Venezuela Case',:52 is an 1896 American propaganda film. It features an allegorical fight over national determinism between the British Empire, the United States and Venezuela.
Plot
John Bull arrives at a shoreline that represents Venezuela and starts attacking it with guns, overwhelming the country.:27 Uncle Sam arrives from the back of the image and grabs Bull by the neck. Defeating and making an example of him, Sam forces Bull to his knees and has him remove his hat for Venezuela.:viii Sam has stood up for the principles of the Monroe Doctrine.:27
Cast
* Charles F. Walton, known for performing in boxing films and for his lanky physique, as Uncle Sam.:27
* John Mayon, a replacement of Walton's rival John Slavin known for being stout, as John Bull.:27
Background and release
's 1896 political cartoon, Uncle Sam stands with rifle between European figures and representatives of Nicaragua and Venezuela
The film was made by the Edison company as a release film for their Vitascope in 1896.:viii It depicted a political dispute that stemmed from a longstanding disagreement over land sovereignty between British Guiana and Venezuela. Miners from Venezuela had begun exploiting the disputed land, and the British warned them off with threats of armed intervention. The United States, in its assumed role as the protector of Latin America from European political forces, mediated to prevent a conflict.:52
Film historian Charles Musser wrote that the film was "doubtlessly inspired by a political cartoon" depicting the same conflict published earlier in the year,:52 and was made in April 1896.:26 It was premiered at the release of the Vitascope at Koster and Bial's Music Hall in New York City on April 23, 1896; according to the 'New York Herald' the audience were "delighted" by the film and the American dominance shown.:viii:116 The film selection for the premiere had been curated by Raff & Gammon.:26
In July of the same year, it became the first picture to be shown in Venezuela, where the people of Maracaibo were reportedly "moved" that a film representing their country was made.:43-44
Analysis
'The Monroe Doctrine' is described by Musser as a "comic allegory" that was "overtly political".:viii This has been noted particularly in its first context, occupying the fifth spot in the running order at the Vitascope's premiere; it came after 'Walton & Slavin', a burlesque boxing match between allegorical Uncle Sam and John Bull figures, and 'Band Drill' (a section of 'Milk White Flag'),:viii in which American soldiers march off to war.:27 Musser also compared it to the second film shown that night, 'Sea Waves at Dover', which shows detail of the waves at Dover in England battering the shore, reflecting the allegorical imagery used in this film.:27 The choice of patriotic narrative in the films may have been selected to allegorically fight an expected influx of similar devices to the Vitasope from European projection manufacturers,:27:viii or to warn the French film companies away from expanding their market into the Americas.:52 Media historians James Chapman and Nicholas J. Cull refer to it as "probably the first propaganda film".:1
References
Buy The Monroe Doctrine (1896 film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1896