Home | Songs By Year | Songs from 1933


Your Mother's Son-In-Law

Buy Your Mother's Son-In-Law now from Amazon

First, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the song. And once you've experienced the song, tell everyone what you thought about it.

Wikipedia article




"'Your Mother's Son-In-Law'" is a song written by Alberta Nichols and Mann Holiner that was recorded by Billie Holiday with a band led by Benny Goodman on 27 November 1933. It was Holiday's first recording. It was produced by John Hammond. The song was recorded in three takes, and Holiday was paid $35 for her performance.

Holiday was initially nervous as she prepared to make her first recording. The singer Ethel Waters was present in the studio, which further increased her anxiousness. Waters had recorded in the same studio earlier in the day with the same band. Holiday was also intimidated by the presence of the famous vaudevillian Buck Washington who played the piano on the recording. Buck encouraged her to sing, telling her that she wouldn't want "all these people" to think that she was a 'square'. The song was recorded in a key that Holiday was uncomfortable with and at a faster pace than she wanted at Goodman's behest. Holiday's biographer John Szwed describes the arrangement as "busy" and "too fast". Szwed wrote that the arrangement "pitched her voice so high that it forced her to virtually shout over the band".

In his book 'Texan Jazz', Dave Oliphant noted that on the song Holiday was already utilising her noted "quavering drop" at the end of words which was possibly adapted from the trumpet stylings of Louis Armstrong and began words with a "gruffness" to lend her vocal lines forcefulness and personality. Oliphant highlights Jack Teagarden's trombone solo on the song, noting that it shares with Holiday's vocal "some of the same exuberance in the face of the wistful and (even inappropriate lyrics)". Oliphant praises Benny Goodman's clarinet solo as that of a "consummate swing artist".

The song later appeared in Lew Leslie's revue 'Blackbirds of 1934'.

In a 1956 interview with Willis Conover for Voice of America's 'Jazz Hour', Holiday claimed that she was 14 years old at the time of the recording (she was actually eighteen) and that the song "sounds like I was doing comedy" as "my voice sounds so funny and high".

The lyrics of the song reference the opera singer Jules Bledsoe and the actor and singer George Jessel, popular musical artists at the time of the recording.

Personnel



*Billie Holiday vocals

*Charlie Teagarden, Shirley Clay trumpet

*Jack Teagarden trombone

*Benny Goodman clarinet

*Art Karle tenor saxophone

*Buck Washington or Joe Sullivan piano

*Dick McDonough guitar

*Artie Bernstein double bass

*Gene Krupa drums

*Deane Kincaide arranger

References




Buy Your Mother's Son-In-Law now from Amazon

<-- Return to songs from 1933



This work is released under CC-BY-SA. Some or all of this content attributed to http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1070554653.