Home | Songs By Year | Songs from 1930
Love for Sale (song)
Buy Love for Sale (song) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the song. And once you've experienced the song, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
"'Love for Sale'" is a song by Cole Porter introduced by Kathryn Crawford in the musical 'The New Yorkers,' which opened on Broadway on December 8, 1930 and closed in May 1931 after 168 performances. The song is written from the viewpoint of a prostitute advertising "love for sale".
Early versions
The song's chorus, like many in the Great American Songbook, is written in the A-A-B-A format. However, instead of 32 bars, it has 64, plus an 8-bar tag. The tag is often dropped when the song is performed. The tune, like many of Porter's, shifts between a major and minor feeling. The A section is in the key of B-flat minor before modulating to B-flat major and back.
Background
When the song came out in 1930, a newspaper labelled it as 'in bad taste';Schwartz, Charles (1979). 'Cole Porter'. Da Capo Press. , pp. 115116 radio stations avoided broadcasting it. Because of the complaints, Porter shifted the setting of the song in the musical to the Cotton Club in Harlem, where it was sung by an African-American, Elisabeth Welch, instead of white singer Kathryn Crawford.
Popular recordings in 1931 were made by Libby Holman and by Fred Waring's Pennsylvanians. The Jack Teagarden Orchestra recorded the song in February 1940, with Kitty Kallen as the featured vocalist.Shaw, M., Rust, B. (2002). Jazz and Ragtime Records, 1897-1942: L-Z. United States: Mainspring Press. https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Jazz_and_Ragtime_Records_1897_1942_L_Z/_J9HAAAAMAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=0
Cover versions
*Billie Holiday recorded a version of the song in 1952.
*Ella Fitzgerald recorded the song for her 1956 album 'Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Cole Porter Song Book'.
*Tony Bennett recorded a version of this on his 1957 album 'The Beat of My Heart'.
*Miles Davis recorded a version of the song with his sextet in 1958, published in '1958 Miles' and as a bonus track on the 2008 reissue of 'Kind of Blue'.
*Boney M. released a disco version of it on their album 'Love for Sale' (1977).
*Astrud Gilberto - for the album 'That Girl from Ipanema' (1977).
*The Manhattan Transfer included this song on their 1978 album 'Pastiche'.
*Mel Torme performed "scat" versions in 1979 on the Merv Griffin Show with Buddy Rich (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrNjF14dnzg) and a live version on the 1981 LP Mel Torme and Friends.
*Elvis Costello released a version of the tune, including the opening verse (prologue), on a Rhino re-release of his 1981 album 'Trust'.
*Anne Pigalle produced by Adrian Sherwood and released on Illuminated Records in 1982
*Vic Godard And The Subway Sect - for his album 'Songs For Sale' (1982).
*Jacky Terrasson included the song in his 1998 live album 'Alive'.
*Seal recorded a version of the song for his 2017 album 'Standards'.
*Pink Martini published a version of the song on their 2016 album Je dis oui!.
*k.d. lang published a version 2010.
It is also widely recorded as a jazz standard. Instrumental versions included those by Sidney Bechet, Erroll Garner, Stan Kenton, Charlie Parker, The Three Sounds, Art Tatum, Cannonball Adderley, Dexter Gordon, Buddy Rich, Ryo Fukui, and Cecil Taylor. There is a version of the song by Hal Kemp's Orch. & The Smoothies, 1940.
Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga version
{{Infobox song
| name = Love for Sale
| cover =
| alt =
| type = single
| artist = Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga
| album = Love for Sale
| released = September 17, 2021
| recorded =
| studio = Electric Lady (New York City)
| genre = Jazz
| length = 3:40
| label =
| writer = Cole Porter
| producer = Dae Bennett
| chronology = Tony Bennett
| prev_title = I Get a Kick Out of You
| prev_year = 2021
| next_title =
| next_year =
| misc =
}}
Background and reception
Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga released a collaborative jazz album, titled 'Cheek to Cheek', in 2014. Shortly after the album was released Bennett asked Gaga if she would like to record another album with him, this time with songs written by Cole Porter. Accepting the invitation, the duo recorded their second collaborative album, 'Love for Sale'. After the record was finished, they went through all the songs to choose the album title, and decided to name it after the song "Love for Sale", which was Bennett's favourite. "Love for Sale" was later chosen as the second single off the album, released on September 17, 2021, to digital retailers. The duo's rendition of the Cole Porter standard is an old-fashioned duet, trading lines and harmonies over the joyous, up-tempo big-band arrangement. The song starts with Bennett softly singing the lines alone, with the big band arrangement joining him at the chorus. Gaga, in the role of streetwalker, joins him and trills: "Who will buy?" The track also involves a bebop saxophone solo. Their rendition brings a "hearty helping of old-school Broadway razzle-dazzle" to the "grim scenario", the "sleazy world of sex work".Justin Curto of 'Vulture' believed that Bennett and Gaga's fruitful collaborative relationship is "on prime display" in the song, which sees "the singers go toe-to-toe on the sensuous standard". 'NME' El Hunt thought that in the song Gaga "channels the arm-swinging enthusiasm of a milkmaid dancing through an 'Oliver!' show tune: 'Who will buy?' she hollers." According to Derrick Rossignol at Uproxx, the song "shows that Bennett hasn't lost his vocal chops even at 95 years old and that Gaga remains an excellent accompaniment for the legend." Ross Horton of 'The Line of Best Fit' thought that "Love for Sale", along with the album's opening two tracks "It's De-Lovely" and "Night and Day", showcase how well the duos vocals come together, saying: "Bennett and Gaga's voices seem to bounce off each other, and become emboldened and enlivened by its presence." Mary Siroky of 'Consequence' felt that the duo is "imbuing the title track with refreshing, heartfelt energy." Eric Handerson from 'Slant Magazine' was critical of their version of the song, which "sung from the POV of a sex worker, makes literally no sense as a duet."
Music video and promotion
The accompanying music video premiered on MTV on September 18, 2021. It starts with Gaga exclaiming "I'm singin' with Tony B!", and then shows the duo recording the song in the studio, with Gaga wriggling around during the session. The visual is cut with clips of the pair laughing together, and occasional close-up shots of the big band. At the end the video, Gaga declares "We got that ending, we stuck it", and the session ends with the two hugging. 'Entertainment Weekly' Joey Nolfi called the music video "tear-jerking", "which highlights their deep, mutual adoration as they stare lovingly into each other's eyes while singing the tune." Cillea Houghton of ABC News noted that in the video "Gaga treats [the studio session] more as a performance than simply singing into a microphone, dancing alongside Tony as they sing". Justin Curto of 'Vulture' wrote that in the video the duo are "showcasing the sort of connection" with each other "that you just can't form over a day in the studio. Whatever they're selling? We'll take it."On July 2, 2021, Bennett and Gaga performed "Love for Sale" and other songs in front of an intimate studio audience in New York City. It was recorded for 'MTV Unplugged', which aired on MTV on December 16, 2021, while the performance of "Love for Sale" was also released as a standalone video on YouTube a week earlier. The duo gave a performance at Radio City Music Hall on August 3 and 5, 2021, called 'One Last Time: an Evening with Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga', and "Love for Sale" was one of the duets they performed together. The performance was later included in a television special of the same name, which premiered on CBS and Paramount+ on November 28, 2021. After Bennett retired from performing live on "doctors' orders", Gaga gave solo performances of the song, including on her Jazz & Piano Vegas residency, and at the 64th Annual Grammy Awards, where she performed the song along with "Do I Love You".
See also
*List of 1930s jazz standards
References
Buy Love for Sale (song) now from Amazon
<-- Return to songs from 1930