Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2010
Secrets of the Tribe
Buy Secrets of the Tribe now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Secrets of the Tribe' is a 2010 Brazilian documentary film by director Jos Padilha.
Content
This documentary explores the allegations, first brought to light in the book 'Darkness in El Dorado', written by Patrick Tierney, that anthropologists studying the Yanomami Indians in the 1960s and '70s engaged in bizarre and inappropriate interactions with the tribe, including sexual and medical violations. Scientists accused in this film are among others James Neel, Napoleon Chagnon, Kenneth Good and Jacques Lizot.
Release
Premiered at the 2010 Sundance Film Festival, the film was nominated for a Grand Jury Prize.[http://sundance.bside.com/2010/films/secretsofthetribe_sundance2010;jsessionid=A822FA415B15E2347295B72F3B8C3189 SundanceTwentyTen]
Afterwards
Alice Dreger, an historian of medicine and science, and an outsider to the debate, concluded in a peer-reviewed publication that most of Tierney's claims (the movie is based on claims originally made by Tierney) were "baseless and sensationalistic charges".
A detailed investigation of these charges by a panel set up by the University of Michigan found the most serious charges to have no foundation and others to have been exaggerated. Almost all of the lengthy allegations made in 'Darkness in El Dorado' were publicly rejected by the Provost's office of the University of Michigan in November 2000.
Sponsel and Turner, the two scientists who originally touted the book's claims, admitted that their charge against Neel "remains an inference in the present state of our knowledge: there is no 'smoking gun' in the form of a written text or recorded speech by Neel."[http://www.slate.com/id/91946/ John Tooby, "Jungle Fever: Did two US scientists start a genocidal epidemic in the Amazon or was 'The New Yorker' duped? 'Slate', October 24th, 2000.]
The American Anthropological Association has since rescinded its support of the book and acknowledged fraudulent and improper and unethical conduct by Tierney. The association admitted that "in the course of its investigation, in its publications, in the venues of its national meetings and its web site, [it] condoned a culture of accusation and allowed serious but unevaluated charges to be posted on its website and expressed in its newsletter and annual meetings" and that its "report has damaged the reputations of its targets, distracted public attention from the real sources of the Yanomami tragedy and misleadingly suggested that anthropologists are responsible for Yanomami suffering".[http://www.aaanet.org/stmts/05ref_eldorado.htm AAA Rescinds Acceptance of the El Dorado Report]
Stephen Broomer points out that, "Tierney wrote a polemical, unscientific book that invoked a scandal. Padilha's film is more evenhanded than this, no doubt because it includes that scandal as a subject, allowing Chagnon an opportunity to defend himself".
References
Buy Secrets of the Tribe now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2010