Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2006
Chronicle of an Escape
Buy Chronicle of an Escape now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Chronicle of an Escape' , also known as 'Buenos Aires, 1977', is a 2006 Argentine historical drama film directed by Israel Adrin Caetano. The screenplay is written by Caetano, Esteban Student, and Julin Loyola, based on the autobiographical book 'Pase libre la fuga de la Mansion Ser' written by Claudio Tamburrini. The film was produced by Oscar Kramer and Hugo Sigman, and stars Rodrigo de la Serna, Pablo Echarri and Nazareno Casero. The film tells the true story of four men who narrowly escaped death at the hands of a military death squad during Argentina's last civil-military dictatorship (1976-1983).
Winner of the Silver Condor Award for Best Film, it was Argentina's entry for the 2007 Golden Globes Awards for the Best Foreign Language Film, and director Israel Adrin Caetano was nominated at the 2006 Cannes Film Festival for a Golden Palm.
Plot
On 23 November 1977, during Argentina's last civil-military dictatorship, Claudio Tamburrini (Rodrigo de la Serna), a goalie for a minor league soccer team in Buenos Aires, is abducted by members of the Argentine secret military police. He is taken to a detention center known as Mansin Ser: an old dilapidated house in the suburban neighborhood of Morn on the suspicion he is a guerrilla man who opposes the dictatorship.
Blindfolded, Tamburrini is tortured daily by his jailers, who demand information he does not have because he is not a political activist and never was. Tamburrini discovers an acquaintance nicknamed 'El Tano', whom he has met twice in his life, has lied under torture and falsely implicated him, claiming he has a mimeograph. On New Year's Eve, Huguito, the lead captor, teases Tamburrini by implying he is about to be released. Instead, he is taken to another room with more men. When Huguito insists Tamburrini remove his blindfold and look at him, Tamburrini understands he will never be released alive.
He attacks Tano, who really is a member of a radical group. Tano claims he had no choice but to implicate Tamburrini after his name was discovered in Tano's address book. He insists that since Tamburrini is really innocent, he will be released eventually, but Tamburrini knows better. A new captive, Guillermo (Nazareno Casero), arrives and admits that he was really the one with the mimeograph, which he used to make fake papers for Tano. Tamburrini hopes that now he will be released, but Guillermo tells him that to have any chance of saving himself, he will have to implicate someone else, which Tamburrini refuses to do. Tano and a dozen other captives are told they are being transferred to prison but in reality are drugged and handed over to the Argentine Air Force, presumably being executed on a death flight.
Tamburrini expects to be killed by the ruthless guards at any time. After four months of imprisonment, and many sessions of torture, Tamburrini and his fellow captives Guillermo, Vasco and Gallego dive out a window during a thunderstorm. The four, naked and with nothing but their senses, begin a desperate flight to freedom. After a night hiding in the suburbs, the four men get ahold of some money and clothes and part ways; three of them leave the country, including Tamburrini, whom years later writes the book in which the film is based on.
Cast
* Rodrigo de la Serna as Claudio Tamburrini
* Pablo Echarri as Huguito
* Nazareno Casero as Guillermo Fernndez
* Daniel Valenzuela as 'El Alemn' ("The German")
* Lautaro Delgado as 'El Gallego' ("The Galician")
* Matas Marmorato as 'El Vasco' ("The Basque")
* Martn Urruty as 'El Tano' ("The Italian")
* Diego Alons as Lucas
* Leonardo Bargiga as Capitn Almagro
* Micaela Vzquez as Tamburrini's sister
Production
Historical context and factual basis of the film
The film is based on a real political event that took place in Argentina during Jorge Rafael Videla's reactionary military 'junta', which came to be known as Argentina's last civil-military dictatorship. The dictatorship took over the government after a Coup on March 24, 1976. During the 'junta's rule, the Congress was suspended and unions, political parties and provincial governments were banned. During the period that became known abroad as "the Dirty War", between 9,000 and 30,000 people were disappeared as a result of direct State-sponsored terrorism by the military government.[http://www.yendor.com/vanished/ The Vanished Gallery].
The film is about one such instance: the November 1977 kidnapping of Claudio Tamburrini, a goalkeeper of a B-league 'ftbol' team, who's taken to a clandestine detention center and tortured. On 24 March 1978, Tamburrini escaped along with Guillermo Fernndez, Carlos Garca Muoz ('El Gallego'), and Daniel Rusomano (known as 'El Chino' in the book), and wrote 'Pase libre la fuga de la Mansion Ser', a harrowing account of his experience.
Themes
Before the production began director Israel Adrin Caetano traveled to meet Tamburrini in Stockholm, where he now lives, to learn the truth about the event. There he also met Fernndez, who initiated the breakout.[http://www.emanuellevy.com/article.php?articleID=3876 Levy, Emanuel] . Interview with Israel Adrin Caetano by Levy. Both former prisoners collaborated with Caetano and the screenwriters and helped them to stick closely to the main theme of the film: survival.The production was quite difficult according to Caetano, who stated that "the filming was an endless challenge: shooting almost entirely within four walls, trusting the outcome to the acting, the framing, and the light. It was not always easy to generate fear, paranoia, and neurosis from this prison. Our challenge was how to re-create the madness these prisoners endured".Levy, Emanuel. Ibid.
Reception
'The Hollywood Reporter's' John DeFore thinks American audiences will like the thriller and its pace, especially after the men escape in the rain. He believes that 'Chronicle of an Escape' will give American audiences "an icky feeling" when they view the "fact-based Argentine story through the stylized lens of a horror film. Laced with dread that builds to a thoroughly gripping third act, it should do well with art house audiences who like their history lessons to come with a shot of adrenaline."[https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/film/reviews/article_display.jsp?JSESSIONID=FTf4pLf58H6nkVsd26zPlnvn2C72tB2yVs3yCRj9TPkgm05v13VG!-759115527&&rid=6744 DeFore, John]. 'The Hollywood Reporter', film review at the Austin Film Festival, October 31, 2006.
Critic Deborah Young, writing for 'Variety' magazine, generally liked the film yet felt the film's atonal score was at times irritating. She wrote, "[F]orceful acting plays a key role in giving the story credibility, with De La Serna and Casero lighting the way." She also says the film "feels hollow at the core, leaving a feeling of lingering disappointment over a missed opportunity to probe recent history."[https://www.variety.com/index.asp?layout=features2006&content=jump&jump=review&dept=cannes&nav=RCannes&articleid=VE1117930672&cs=1 Young, Deborah]. 'Variety', "Bottom Line: Real life becomes a horror film in tale of Argentine secret jail", film review at the Cannes Film Festival, May 27, 2006.
Critic Clark Collis liked the film and wrote, "'Chronicle of an Escape's' premise may remind you of Sly Stallone's enjoyably preposterous 1981 soccer/incarceration flick, 'Victory', but this true-story-based movie scores in a different way...The result is blessed with great performances; director Israel Adrin Caetano lets events speak and plead and weep for themselves."[https://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20163028,00.html Collis, Chris]. 'Entertainment Weekly', film review, November 28, 2007. Last accessed: February 18, 2008.
Stephen Holden, critic for 'The New York Times', discussed the film from today's political perspective in the United States. He wrote, "Despite its restraint, 'Chronicle of an Escape' is deeply unsettling. Although the events it depicts happened 30 years ago in South America, it inevitably triggers anguished thoughts of Abu Ghraib, Guantnamo Bay and extraordinary rendition... But as a suspenseful drama of captivity and escape, the movie is a carefully paced, persuasively acted thriller. Its first two-thirds observe Claudio's four-month internment, during which he becomes resigned to the idea that he will be killed. Unlike the other captives, he does not belong to a subversive group; midway through the film he discovers to his fury that an acquaintance and fellow prisoner, while under torture, lied and named him as the owner of a mimeograph machine that printed antigovernment leaflets. The message is explicit: Torture may make people talk, but theyll say anything to avoid further abuse."[https://movies.nytimes.com/2007/11/30/movies/30chro.html?ex=1228021200&en=8dd40a9d8e8854a3&ei=5083&partner=Rotten%20Tomatoes Holden, Stephen]. 'The New York Times', film review, November 30, 2007. Last accessed: February 18, 2008.
Critic Jan Stuart echoed Stephen Holden and wrote, "If there is anything more disturbing than any of the tortures glimpsed in the film, it is turning on the evening news afterward and being reminded that the use of such hardball practices are still, in the minds of some, a subject for debate."[http://www.newsday.com/entertainment/movies/ny-secsing5477759nov28,0,1131631.story Stuart, Jan]. 'Newsday', November 28, 2007. Last accessed: February 18, 2008.
The review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes reported that 60% of critics gave the film a positive review, based on fifteen reviews.[https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/buenos_aires_1977/ 'Chronicle of an Escape'] at Rotten Tomatoes. Last accessed: February 18, 2008.
Accolades
Awards
* Clarn Awards: Clarin Award; Best Director, Adrin Caetano; Best Film; Best New Actor, Nazareno Casero; Best Original Music, Ivn Wyszogrod; Best Screenplay, Adrin Caetano, Esteban Student, and Julian Loyola; Best Supporting Actor, Nazareno Casero; 2006.* Argentine Academy of Cinematography Arts and Sciences Awards: 'Premios Sur'; Best Supporting Actor, Nazareno Casero; Best New Actor, Nazareno Casero; Best Original Music, Ivn Wyszogrod, 2006.[http://www.clarin.com/diario/2006/12/12/um/m-01327004.htm 'Clarn']. "El filme 'Las manos' arras en la entrega de los Premios Sur", article about film awards, December 12, 2006.
* Argentine Film Critics Association Awards: Silver Condor, Best Editing, Alberto Ponce; Best Film; Best Adapted Screenplay, Adrin Caetano, Julian Loyola, and Esteban Student; 2007.
Nominations
* Cannes Film Festival: Golden Palm, Adrin Caetano, 2006.* Independent Spirit Awards: Independent Spirit Award Best Foreign Film, Adrin Caetano, Argentina, 2007.
* Argentine Film Critics Association Awards: Silver Condor, Best Actor, Rodrigo De la Serna; Best Art Direction, Juan Mario Roust and Jorge Ferrari; Best Cinematography, Julin Apeztegua; Best Director, Adrin Caetano; Best Music, Ivn Wyszogrod; Best Sound, Fernando Soldevila; Best Supporting Actor, Nazareno Casero; Best Supporting Actor, Pablo Echarri; 2007.
* Penthouse Film of the Year: Golden Woodie, Adrin Caetano, 2006.
Distribution
The film first opened in Argentina on March 24, 2006. The film was shown at various film festivals, including the 2006 Cannes Film Festival, France; the Toronto International Film Festival, Canada; the Toulouse Latin America Film Festival, France; the Espoo Cin International Film Festival, Finland, and others.
In the United States it was featured at the Austin Film Festival in Texas on October 26, 2006.
References
Buy Chronicle of an Escape now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2006