Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2003
Rosenstrasse (film)
Buy Rosenstrasse (film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Rosenstrae' is a 2003 film directed by Margarethe von Trotta, starring Maria Schrader and Katja Riemann. It deals with the Rosenstrasse protest of 1943.
Plot
In the present day, a widow mourns the death of her husband. She covers up the TV set and all the mirrors in the house.
Her grown children are baffled by this behavior, asking why their mother has suddenly become Orthodox Jewish. The mother will not discuss her past, but her daughter wants to know what happened. Learning of a woman (Lena) who "saved" her mother during the war, she goes to Germany to learn the whole story. She finds Lena, who willingly reminisces about World War II, about her situation and the mother's childhood as a Jew growing up in Germany during the war. Lena herself is a German woman whose Jewish husband was persecuted by the Nazis while the little girl (the widow mother) loses her own mother to the Nazi concentration camps. The principal focus of the film addresses what happened to those who were in a mixed marriage ("Aryan"/Jewish). Amid constant flashbacks, the film pieces together the story of the Rosenstrasse protest, where the women waited for seven days and nights outside of a Nazi jail for their Jewish husbands. The protests took place in Berlin during the winter of 1943.
Production
'Rosenstrae' was Margarethe von Trotta's first film since 1995. Due to funding problems, she had to choose between retreating to academia (as some of her colleagues did) or doing more TV production work.Margret Eifler, "Margarethe von Trotta as Filmmaker: Biographical Retrospectives" 'German Quarterly' 76: 4 (Autumn, 2003), p. 443 - 448. Review of the books 'Margarethe von Trotta: Filmmaking as Liberation' by Renate Hehr and 'Margarethe von Trotta: Filmen, um zu berleben' by Thilo Wydra.
Accolades
The film won a David at the David di Donatello Awards. Franz Rath won for Best Cinematography at the Bavarian Film Awards and the UNICEF Award at the Venice Film Festival.
Reception
Rosenstrae received notable criticism from film critics and historians alike. In particular, the film's explicit claim to give an accurate account of the Rosenstrae protest has caused historians to point out not only a number of minor flaws in the logic of the film, but also some major points where 'Rosenstrae' did not stick to the facts. Among others, historian Beate Meyer compared fact and fiction in a detailed treatment,Beate Meyer, 'Geschichte im Film: Judenverfolgung, Mischehen und der Protest in der Rosenstrae 1943.' In 'Zeitschrift fr Geschichtsforschung' 52 (2004), Pp 23-36 and came to the conclusion that 'Rosenstrae' was a projection of contemporary hopes and myths on history, resulting in a utopia. The audience would inevitably come to wonder how the holocaust could occur "if only seven days of steadfastness would have sufficed to prevent it from happening."
References
Buy Rosenstrasse (film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2003