Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 2002
Drowned Out
Buy Drowned Out now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Drowned Out' is a 2002 documentary by Franny Armstrong about the Sardar Sarovar Project. Shot over three years, 'Drowned Out' follows one familys stand against a government dam project which is set to destroy their home and their village.
Synopsis
The documentary follows the villagers of Jalsindhi a village in Madhya Pradesh on the banks of the Narmada River about 30 miles upstream from the Sardar Sarovar project - through their battle against the dam. The lead character is Luharia Sonkaria, who is the villages medicine man, a role that was his fathers and grandfathers before him. The government provides them no viable alternatives - they offer unusable land a hundred miles away or a small sum of money in compensation for their river-side land. The film documents hunger strikes, rallies, and a six-year Supreme Court case, and finally follows the villagers as the dam fills and the river starts to rise. The documentary features Arundhati Roy, who has been an outspoken activist bringing international attention to the controversy.
Production
The documentary was shot over three years on three separate trips to India by Franny Armstrong. Assisted by her sister in the first year and by an Australian camera operator in the second, Armstrong shot 80% of the film herself. There was no electricity on location so Armstrong used a portable solar charger she purchased in the UK.
Armstrong was put in jail for one night after the first day of filming. As she wrote in a feature article for 'The Guardian' newspaper, she continued to live and work alongside the villagers and found this almost anthropological way of working helped her capture candid interviews; "Most of the best interviews were done in the last year - when I was on my own - because people really got to know and trust me".
Screening in Jalsindhi village
In August 2003, the Spanner Films crew returned to Jalsindhi village, where 'Drowned Out' had been shot, to screen the film for the villagers. They made a makeshift cinema on the side of the village school, with a diesel generator for electricity, a bedsheet for a screen and a simple sound system. About 120 people from Jalsindhi and surrounding villages came to the screening, and for almost all of them it was the first time they had seen a moving image.
Reception
'Time Out' (London) chose 'Drowned Out' as their Critics Choice, describing the documentary as "compassionate, disturbing and yet empowering". The 'Bermuda Royal Gazette', reviewing the film for a screening at the Bermuda International Film Festival said "Documentaries rarely, if ever, come better than this." The 'San Francisco Chronicle' called it "Heartbreaking" and 'Film Journal International' said it is "A real eye opener."
The OneWorld Media Awards Jury called the documentary "a powerful and masterfully crafted study", and New Internationalist described it as "Quiet, fierce, beautiful."
Awards
Nominated for Best Documentary in the BIFAs
Runner up in San Francisco Film Festival Best Documentary
Distribution
'Drowned Out' has been screened in numerous cinemas and on numerous TV channels around the world. Producers estimate millions of people have seen the film, primarily on TV round the world (including PBS in America).
It was released on DVD in 2004 and can be downloaded or streamed from the Spanner Films website.
See also
*'A Narmada Diary', a 1995 film about opposition to the dam
References
Buy Drowned Out now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 2002