Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1998
Alice and Martin
Buy Alice and Martin now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Alice et Martin ' (US title: 'Alice and Martin') is a 1998 French film, a psychological drama, directed by Andr Tchin. It stars Juliette Binoche and Alexis Loret. It is Tchin's second collaboration with Binoche after the 1985 film 'Rendez-vous'. The plot follows the two title characters, Martin, a male model, and Alice, a struggling violinist. Their romance is shattered when Martin's troubled past begins to haunt him.
Plot
At age ten, Martin is living in Cahors with Jeanine, his hairdresser mother and her taxi-driver lover, Said. Martin is the illegitimate child of a successful business man, Victor Sauvagnac. Against the childs wishes his mother sends Martin to live with his father, whom until then he does not know. Victor is married and has three sons older than Martin. The move is not a happy one and quickly Martin finds himself in conflict with his brash, cold father.
Ten years later, just after his twentieth birthday, Martin flees his home following his father's death. He disappears wandering across the country side and tries unsuccessfully to drown himself. Martin emerges weeks later at his half-brother Benjamins apartment in Paris. Benjamin is a struggling actor sharing living arrangements with his best friend Alice, a violinist in a local quintet that specializes in tango music. More outgoing than his younger brother, Benjamin, who is gay, has a close platonic relationship with Alice. Martin finds success quicklywithin weeks he is a highly sought-after model.
Alice is nervous and brittle, harboring her own private grief, the tragic death at age eleven of her gifted sister. At first Alice resents Martin's presence in the apartment and she is cold towards him. Though Alice does not like the brooding Martin much, he becomes obsessed with her and starts surreptitiously following her. Alice discovers it and confronts him. She is gradually captivated by his attentions, and the two begin a passionate love affair.
Leaving Benjamin behind, Alice accompanies Martin to Granada, Spain, on a modeling shoot. Their happiness is brief. During the trip Martin's behavior becomes erratic and he becomes more and more self-obsessed. When Alice reveals she is pregnant, his decline continues. Martin suffers a nervous breakdown and falls into coma. The doctors determine that his condition is psychosomatic. In an effort to restore his health, Alice rents a cabin by the sea in Spains south coast. Martin swims for hours each night, but remains withdrawn. He is haunted by his fathers death.
A flashback recounts the period preceding Victor Sauvagnacs death. His relationship with his sons was problematic: the aimless and withdrawn Martin failed to please him; Benjamin irritated him and a reunion about the prospects of the family's business ended up in a fist fight between Franois and Frdric, the two eldest siblings. Martin celebrates his 20th birthday with Benjamin, who comes from Paris for the occasion. Their reunion is interrupted by a phone call from Franois who commits suicide hanging himself in the family's factory. When Martin decides to leave for Paris an argument erupts and Martin pushes his father downs the stairs killing him. Unable to deal with what he has just done, Martin runs away.
After Martin reveals that he caused his father's death, unable to bear the guilt and pain any longer, he commits himself to a mental institution. Alice, following Martins wishes, travels to Cahors to talk to the Sauvagnac family. She befriends Martin's mother, but Lucie, Victors widow, is unsympathetic. Frdric Sauvagnac, who is the town's major, is openly hostile. Benjamin comes to town in an effort to stop Alice interfering in his family affairs. However they two reconcile. Eventually Lucie decides to tell the authorities about Martins culpability in her husbands death. Martin confesses his crime, surrenders to the authorities and goes to prison. Alice decides to have her baby. She appears playing her violin in a wedding. Martin is in prison but, in a letter to Alice, he seems to be finally at peace with himself.
Cast
* Juliette Binoche as Alice
* Alexis Loret as Martin
* Mathieu Amalric as Benjamin
* Marthe Villalonga as Lucie Sauvagnac
* Pierre Maguelon as Victor Sauvagnac
* Carmen Maura as Jeanine
* Jean-Pierre Lorit as Frdric Sauvagnac
* Erik Kreikenmayer as Franois Sauvagnac
* Franck de la Personne as The Examining Magistrate
* Jeremy Kreikenmayer as Martin as a child
Production
The script was written by Andr Tchin and his frequent scriptwriting partner Gilles Taurand with the help of Olivier Assayas. Filming took place on location in France (Paris and the southwest Cahors region and Duravel in the Lot valley) and Spain (Granada), where Martin's climactic breakdown occurs.Marshall, 'Andr Tchin', p. 99
Release
'Alice et Martin' had its world premiere at the 1998 Valladolid International Film Festival in the presence of Andr Tchin, Juliette Binoche and Alain Sarde. The version screened ran at 114 mins, 10 mins shorter than the version that was released theatrically. The film premiered in France on 4 November 1998.
Reception
'Alice et Martin', Tchins thirteenth film, came after a string of three critic and artistic successful films: 'My Favorite Season' (1993) (Ma saison prfre); 'Wild Reeds' (1994) (Les roseaux sauvages) and, 'Thieves' (Les voleurs) (1996).Marshall, 'Andr Tchin', p. 98 In a general consensus, critics and audiences perceived' Alice et Martin' as a disappointment, particularly due to the grim nature of the plot.Marshall, 'Andr Tchin', p. 100 The star power of Juliette Binoche, who became known to the American public thanks her Oscar-winning performance in 'The English Patient', was not enough for the film to find a large audience. In France, the reviewer in 'Cahiers du cinma' raised doubts about the films narrative procedure and the incongruity of the epic sweep and the banal family narrative depicted.
Rotten Tomatoes reported that 62% of 42 sampled critics gave the film positive reviews. Andrew Sarris from 'The New York Observer' called the film "not to be missed". Jonathan Rosenbaum from 'Chicago Reader' commented that "The sheer neurotic intensity of Techine's characters -- characteristically stretching both backward and forward in time, as in a Faulkner novel--holds one throughout, as does Techine's masterful direction and many of the other performances".
A.O. Scott in 'The New York Times' called 'Alice et Martin' " A richly populated, observant film that suffers, forgivable, from an excess of curiosity about the world it depicts -- a surfeit of generosity, intelligence and art". Edward Guthmann in the 'San Francisco Chronicle' saw the film as " heartfelt and passionate and brave in what it attempts to explore. It is only a qualified success". In his review for 'Los Angeles Times', Kevin Thomas described it as " Boldly structured, intensely focused and briskly paced, Alice and Martin has a tremendous emotional density that places the utmost demands upon its actors--and asks a lot of audiences, too." While in a disagreeing note Lisa Schwarzbaum from 'Entertainment Weekly' said that "It's as if, in exploring the scars that shape these personalities, Tchin has forgotten to color in the flesh."
DVD release
'Alice et Martin' is available in Region 2 DVD. Audio in French and English subtitles. The only extra feature Is the film's trailer. There is no Region 1 DVD available.
Notes
References
*Marshall, Bill. 'Andr Tchin', Manchester University Press, 2007,
Buy Alice and Martin now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1998