Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1975
Earthquake in Chile (film)
Buy Earthquake in Chile (film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'Earthquake in Chile' is a 1975 West German television drama film directed by Helma Sanders-Brahms. The film is an adaptation of the Heinrich von Kleist novella 'The Earthquake in Chile'.Knight, Julia. 'Women and the New German Cinema'. Verso Books, 1992. , 9780860915683. p. [https://books.google.com/books?id=YmmTv4NiZ-UC&pg=PA96 96].
Plot
Handsome Jeronimo Rugera is hired to tutor the rich heiress, Josephe Asteron. They fall in love, yet the church forbids their relationship, and Josephe is hidden in a convent. When the church discovers she is pregnant, Josephe is sentenced to death by decapitation. Jeronimo tracks her down, yet is jailed before he can rescue her. When fate intervenes in the form of a massive earthquake, the two lovers have no idea what is in store for them. Sanders-Brahms uses a voice-over of the first and final sentences of the book, placing them in the beginning and end of the film.
Analysis
According to critic Elaine Martin, author of the scholarly article "Rewrites and Remakes: Screen Adaptations of Romantic Works," the film director "erases the uncanny aspect of Kleist's tale and replaces it with a socio-political explanation" and intended to politicize the earthquake narrative's context in a higher degree compared to the original work. For the adaptation Sanders-Brahms uses parallel plotlines that intersect in the end instead of the flashbacks used in the original work. Sanders-Brahms created story segments referred to by Martin as "pre-stories, as it were."Martin, p. [https://books.google.com/books?id=G8aokatYPsQC&pg=PA671&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false 671]. Martin states that the new segments "locate" the characters "socially and temperamentally." In addition Sanders-Brahms removed the nineteenth century Prussia context, what Martin calls "the stage that represents Kleist's narrative filter." The author added that the ending of the film is "less sanguine" compared to the novella because the director added a "veiled reference" to the "economic value" of the surviving child. The child is scheduled to inherit the wealth of the parents, who are dead. She further wrote that in the film Don Fernando is "a coolly calculating businessman, shaped by a bourgeois business mentality" instead of a "divine hero."
Cast
*Julia Pea as Josephe Asteron (German voice: Maddalena Kerrh)
*Victor Alczar as Jeronimo Rugera (German voice: Fred Maire)
*Juan Amigo as Don Fernando Ormez (German voice: Manfred Schott)
*Mara Jess Hoyos as Dona Elvira Ormez (German voice: Lis Kertelge)
*Mara Vico as Dona Elisabeth Ormez (German voice: Helga Trmper)
*Antonio Gamero as Shoemaker Pedrillo (German voice: Bruno W. Pantel)
*Raquel Rodrigo as Shoemaker Pedrillo's Wife (German voice: Marianne Wischmann)
*Antonio Requena as Barber (German voice: Mogens von Gadow)
*ngel lvarez as Bishop (German voice: Erik Jelde)
*Jos Villasante as Familiar (German voice: Alois Maria Giani)
*Miguel Angel Andes as Dominican (German voice: Rdiger Bahr)
*Fernando Villena as Don Henrico Asteron (German voice: Wolf Ackva)
*Marisa Porcel as Warden's Wife (German voice: Emely Reuer)
*Fernando Snchez Polack as Warden (German voice: Norbert Gastell)
*Francisco Ortuo as Mestizo (German voice: Fred Klaus)
*Mara de la Riva as Indian Woman (German voice: Lisa Helwig)
Release
The film was released on DVD by Facets Multi-Media in 2009.
Reception
Film critic Greg Titian wrote a generally negative review of the film in which he stated that "'Earthquake in Chile' throws the audience into the story with scant setup. Narration at the opening sets the scene in a way that was dissatisfying to this reviewer [...] I felt that 'Earthquake in Chile' made emotional demands on the audience without properly establishing an emotional attachment in the audience to those characters [...] Perhaps I missed the point, or the historical significance of this particular piece of German cinema, but the predictable storyline, in my estimation, ultimately falls a bit flat," though he nevertheless praised the fact that the "DVD sports a very high quality transfer." 'Der Spiegel's critic Siegfried Schober's review made similar negative remarks.
Legacy
The director made the 1976 film 'Heinrich' because, during work on 'Earthquake in Chile', she developed an interest in the work's original author.
References
Bibliography
*Martin, Elaine. "Rewrites and Remakes: Screen Adaptations of Romantic Works." In: Gillespie, Gerald, Manfred Engel, and Bernard Dieterle (editors). 'Romantic Prose Fiction'. John Benjamins Publishing Company, 2008, p. 664ff. , 9789027234568.
Buy Earthquake in Chile (film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1975