Home | Movies By Year | Movies from 1938
You and Me (1938 film)
Buy You and Me (1938 film) now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the movie. And once you've experienced the movie, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'You and Me' is a 1938 American crime film noir directed by Fritz Lang and starring Sylvia Sidney and George Raft. They play a pair of criminals on parole and working in a department store full of similar cases; Harry Carey's character routinely hires ex-convicts to staff his store. The film was written by Norman Krasna and Virginia Van Upp.
Plot
Mr. Morris, owner of a large department store, hires offenders released on parole to give them a chance to rehabilitate. The other staff do not know.
Among them is Joe Dennis, who is resigning and leaving for California in order to end his growing friendship with fellow-employee Helen Roberts, as he feels unworthy of her. With his violent past, he does not feel he could marry such a sweet and innocent girl. They spend a last evening together and, as he boards the Greyhound bus, she says that if he did ask to marry her the answer would be yes.
They rush to an instant marriage bureau and then back to her room. The landlady emerges to throw Joe out, but relents when Helen shows her ring. Helen says they must keep the wedding secret, because Mr Morris does not approve of employees marrying each other. In fact he does not mind, but Helen is not allowed to marry while on parole.
When Joe finds a ribboned bundle of what he assumes are love letters in Helen's room, but which are parole cards, he becomes jealous of her past, and meets up for a drink with some criminals from his own. They plan to rob Morris' store at night, and recruit him to join the operation. But one of the gang is sorry for Helen, should Joe end up back in prison, and, trying to disguise his voice on the telephone, encourages her to keep him away that night; but panicking, he fails to cover the telephone properly; she recognizes the voice, deduces why, and warns Morris.
When the robbers break into the store, they are surrounded by armed guards. Morris says he will let them go once they have listened to what Helen has to say. With considerable expertise, she outlines on a blackboard the full costs of the operation they had planned and the meager returns each individual would receive if it had succeeded. Joe is not amused by Helen's role in the affair or by her sophisticated knowledge of heist planning. As he does not offer any reconciliation, she packs her things and disappears.
Joe and his colleagues search all over town, with no leads. From Helen's parole officer, Joe learns that Helen is pregnant and that her marriage was void as it breached her parole conditions. After looking everywhere for her, one of the gang realizes that she'd probably be in a hospital, and finds her. The film ends with their second, but this time valid, marriage.
Cast
* Sylvia Sidney as Helen
* George Raft as Joe Dennis
* Barton MacLane as Mickey
* Harry Carey as Mr. Morris
* Roscoe Karns as Cuffy
* George E. Stone as Patsy
* Warren Hymer as Gimpy
* Robert Cummings as Jim
* Adrian Morris as Knucks
* Roger Gray as Bath House
* Cecil Cunningham as Mrs. Morris
* Vera Gordon as Mrs. Levine
* Egon Brecher as Mr. Levine
* Willard Robertson as Dayton
* Guinn Williams as Text
* Bernadene Hayes as Nellie
* Joyce Compton as Curly Blonde
* Carol Paige as Torch Singer
Production
William LeBaron of Paramount asked Norman Krasna if he could come up with a vehicle for George Raft. Krasna agreed provided he was allowed to direct. Then Carole Lombard read the script and wanted to be involved; Krasna says Paramount did not want first-time director Krasna to be entrusted with a Lombard-Raft film and tried to force Krasna off the project.*McGilligan, Patrick, "Norman Krasna: The Woolworth's Touch", 'Backstory: Interviews with Screenwriters of Hollywood's Golden Age', University of California Press, 1986, p219-220 In 1936, it was reported the film would be delayed because Raft did not want Krasna to direct. There was some talk John Howard might replace Raft. Arline Judge was going to star alongside Lombard. Raft was put on suspension and $24,000 of his salary was withheld. However the film did not go ahead.
Then several months later B.P. Schulberg, who was producing films for Paramount, decided to re-activate the project. He replaced Lombard with Sylvia Sidney and the male lead went to John Trent. Richard Wallace was meant to direct.
Eventually Raft who had made a film with Sidney, 'The Pick Up' (1933) did the film. By May 1937, Schulberg was no longer producer and the director was Fritz Lang who had just made 'Fury' and 'You Only Live Once' with Sidney.
Lang used a musical score from Kurt Weill, who "had nothing to do just then." They worked together and Weill composed introductory music for certain scenes. According to Lang, Weill left him "in the lurch" and left the project before the music was finished, and the score was completed by Boris Morros, head of Paramount's music department.
Lang says he was influenced by Bertolt Brecht, who had developed a style of theatre called Lehrstucke, theatre that teaches. "I wanted to make a didactic picture teaching the audience that crime doesn't pay", said Lang. "Which is a lie, because crime pays very well. The message was spelled out at the end by Sylvia Sidney on a blackboard to a classroom of crooks." Lang later said the scene where prisoners were nostalgic for prison was "stupid".
Production credits
* Fritz Lang - director
* Virginia Van Upp - screenplay
* Norman Krasna - story
* Charles Lang - photography
* Hans Dreier - art direction
* Ernst Fegt - art direction
* Paul Weatherwax - editor
* Harry Lindgren - sound recording
* Walter Oberst - sound recording
* A. E. Freudeman - interior decorations
* Boris Morros - musical direction
* Kurt Weill - music
* Sam Coslow - lyrics
* Phil Boutelje - musical adviser
Songs
*"Song of the Cash Register"
*"Knocking Song"
*"The Right Guy for Me"
*"Romance of a Lifetime"
*"The Song of the Lie"
*"We're the Kind of People Who Sing Lullabies"
Reception
Box office
The film was a box office flop.Everett Aaker, 'The Films of George Raft', McFarland & Company, 2013 p 77 "It was I think deservedly my first real flop", said Lang.Critical
Jonathan Rosenbaum described 'You and Me' as "among Lang's most unjustly neglected Hollywood pictures not an unqualified success by any means but interesting, imaginative, and genuinely strange."Lang later called it a "lousy picture".
'Filmink' said "it flopped and Raft may as well have done it with Krasna."
References
Buy You and Me (1938 film) now from Amazon
<-- Return to movies from 1938