Home | Books By Year | Books from 2013
The Shining Girls
Buy The Shining Girls now from AmazonFirst, read the Wikipedia article. Then, scroll down to see what other TopShelfReviews readers thought about the book. And once you've experienced the book, tell everyone what you thought about it.
Wikipedia article
'The Shining Girls' is a novel by South African author Lauren Beukes. The book centers on a time-traveling Depression-era drifter who must murder the "shining girls" in order to continue his travels.
'The Shining Girls' was published on 15 April 2013 by the Umuzi imprint of Random House Struik in South Africa, on 25 April 2013 by HarperCollins in the United Kingdom, and on 4 June 2013 by Mulholland Books in the United States. HarperCollins had won the international rights to the book in a bidding war with several other publishers.
Unlike her previous novels, which are set in South Africa, 'The Shining Girls' takes place in Chicago. Beukes said that because the story steps back and forth through history, she felt South Africa would not be a suitable setting because "then it would become an Apartheid story". Beukes added that race issues appear frequently in her work, but "Apartheid would have overwhelmed everything else I wanted to do with the novel".
In 2013, 'The Shining Girls' was short-listed for UK based Crime Writers' Association 2013 Goldsboro Gold Dagger award. In 2014 the book won the British Fantasy Society's August Derleth Award for Best Horror Novel
Plot
'The Shining Girls' follows Harper Curtis, a killer from Depression-era Chicago, who finds a key on the person of his latest victim, and uses it to unlock the door to a strange house. Inside, Harper discovers a room covered in seemingly random objects, each with a womans name attached. He quickly figures out that the house wants him to kill these women the titular Shining Girls who live at various times across the next 60 years. All Harper has to do is step out of the room with the house key and a copy of one of the objects the originals remain inside the house and he can visit any year between 1929 and 1993.
So begins Harper Curtis killing spree. He visits each of the Shining Girls when she is little and gives her a token item from the room, such as a baseball card or toy. Then, he leaps forward in time by a decade or more, murders the Shining Girl, and leaves a different womans token at the scene.
His luck changes when he brutally stabs Kirby Mizrachi in 1989 and leaves her for dead. Unbeknownst to Harper, Kirby survives the attempt on her life. And four years later, with her would-be killer still unidentified, she decides to go after him on her own.
Kirby takes a job working for Dan Velazquez, the journalist who covered her story for the 'Chicago Sun-Times'. Shes upfront about wanting to track down her attacker, and she has an impossible theory that the man who tried to kill her has been murdering women in Chicago for the last 60 years. Because Harpers M.O. includes leaving another womans token with each Shining Girl he kills, Kirbys search uncovers anachronisms at the scenes of several Chicago murders, and she realizes that her own token the 1985 My Little Pony figurine a strange man gave her in 1976 is similarly displaced in time. Armed with this information, she enlists Dans help to research the ponys history.
Meanwhile, Harper is hunting Kirby once again, having read one of her articles from 1993. When someone tips her off that a man is looking for her, Kirby turns the tables on Harper and pursues him all the way to the house. After seeing the token room, she tries reporting Harper and the house to the police, but they find nothing amiss inside.
Kirby approaches Dan once more and convinces him to break into the house with her. While Dan fends off Harper in 1929, Kirby gathers the tokens and prepares to burn them. Harper critically injures Dan and returns to the house, arriving just in time to see Kirby set the items ablaze. The novel ends with Kirby shooting Harper and leaving him to die in the burning house while she and Dan escape.
Criticism and reviews
'The Shining Girls' received positive to mixed reviews from critics.
Writing for NPR, American writer and critic Alan Cheuse called 'The Shining Girls' "a triumph" and "a marvelous narrative feat that spans the history of Chicago from the 1930s to the 1990s". He complimented Beukes on her in-depth research into Chicago's history, and described the plot as a "well-made, though extremely complex temporal creation". A reviewer in the 'National Post' described 'The Shining Girls' as "a thoroughly satisfying thriller" and said that Kirby's charm is "irresistible and irrepressible", while Harper reminds one of the 1890s Chicago serial killer H. H. Holmes.
American writer Julia Keller wrote in a review of the book in the 'Chicago Tribune' that she was pleased that 'The Shining Girls' deviates from traditional serial-killer fiction in that it does not glorify the killer. Beukes presents Harper as "greedy and seedy and opportunistic", rather than "scintillatingly brilliant and alluringly damaged". While the book's time-travel theme "stretches scientific plausibility", Keller said that the book's strength comes from Beukes's "audacious imaginative vision", and that she has made "delicate and redemptive magic" out of "something horrific and inexplicable".
Simmy Richman wrote in 'The Independent' that while the book has good ideas, it is "ultimately another high-concept novel that suffers in the execution". He said that the back-and-forth time travel results in the story "feel[ing] all over the place". Richman added that Beukes's characterization of Harper's victims was good, but felt that she does not give the killer the same attention. American author Charles Finch writing in a review in 'USA Today' also felt that 'The Shining Girls' is "not entirely successful in its execution", but added that because Beukes is "so profusely talented capable of wit, darkness, and emotion on a single page", the book should still be a "blockbuster". Finch said that while Beukes "successfully defines and limits her story's magical elements", the magic "come[s] apart at the seams" during the final showdown between Kirby and Harper.
In a review in 'The New York Times', American journalist and critic Janet Maslin wrote that Beukes has made 'The Shining Girls' more than "a standard serial-killer story" by "load[ing] it with acrobatic twists", and said it is a "strong contender for the role of this summer's universal beach read". Maslin added that a strong point of the book is "the emotional effect of the victims' unusual virtue" that Beukes creates, but complained about the book's lack of information about Harper. Maslin also criticized the fact that all the story's "occult power" rests in the House, which "has a mind of its own, but we never find out how it works". Alison Flood wrote in a review in 'The Guardian' that if you accept Beukes's "time-travel conceit", 'The Shining Girls' is a page-turner that will "take some beating this summer". Flood defended Beukes's decision not to explain how the House works, saying that "The [H]ouse just is", and that Harper's underdeveloped character is what makes him an enigma. She complimented Beukes on her victims, calling them "vivid, glowing characters", and described Kirby as "one of the sarkiest, most resilient heroines you're likely to meet this year".
Adaptations
In May 2013, it was announced that MRC and Appian Way, Leonardo DiCaprio's production company, have bought the television rights to 'The Shining Girls'. In July 2020, Apple announced that it green lit a straight-to-series order for 'Shining Girls', launching exclusively on Apple TV+, with Elisabeth Moss set to star and executive produce. In February 2021, Wagner Moura was cast to lead opposite Moss. Production on the series began in Chicago in May 2021. It premiered on April 29, 2022.
Awards
*2013 UJ Prize for South African Writing in English
*2013 RT Thriller of the Year
*2013 Exclusive Books' Readers Choice Award
*2014 The Strand Magazine Critic's Best Novel Award
*2014 British Fantasy Society August Derleth Award for Best Horror Novel
References
Buy The Shining Girls now from Amazon
<-- Return to books from 2013